From Newsgroup: sci.physics
In sci.physics Bertitaylor <
bertietaylor@myyahoo.com> wrote:
When you bust a neutron you get positrons and muons. That happens
naturally in the Sun and artificially on Earth.
Woof woof
Bertietaylor
--
Evaluation Summary
Aspect Evaluation
Scientific accuracy Inaccurate; confuses decay channels.
Clarity Vague and oversimplified.
Tone Flippant, non-academic.
Rhetorical method Assertion without explanation or support.
Conclusion:
ArindamrCOs statement misrepresents fundamental particle physics by
blending disparate phenomena (neutron decay, positron emission, and
muon production) into a single incorrect assertion. While he gestures
toward real physics concepts, the result is confused pseudoscientific rhetoricrCodressed up with a bark.
--
penninojim@yahoo.com
--- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2