From Newsgroup: rec.arts.startrek.misc

AI/LLM Reviews of Star Trek The Next Generation -Time's Arrow

Google Gemini

Plot Synopsis (Parts I & II)
The story begins with an astonishing discovery in a cave on Earth: the preserved, 500-year-old head of Lieutenant Commander Data. Simultaneously, the Enterprise detects an anomaly leading to 19th-century San Francisco. Determined to find out why his future self was decapitated, Data enters the temporal rift and finds himself in 1893.

Captain Picard and a small away team (Troi and La Forge) follow Data to 19th-century Earth. They discover that mysterious energy-draining aliensrCothe DevidiansrCoare posing as human relief workers and using the time portal to extract life force from the poor and dying to sustain their own existence in a future, dying time period.

Data, meanwhile, attempts to blend in and is briefly befriended by the young writer Jack London before being incapacitated and losing his memory chip, which is found by the famous American humorist, Samuel Clemens (Mark Twain). The Enterprise crew struggles hilariously with 19th-century culture but eventually teams up with Clemens, who uses his influence to help them confront the Devidians.

In a dramatic climax, Data is repaired, and the crew manages to destabilize the DevidiansrCO time-travel mechanism. The Enterprise team successfully returns to the 24th century, but not before Data's active head is severed by the Devidian's temporal beam (just before his body re-enters the portal), thus completing the time loop and resolving the initial paradox.

Strengths
Handling of Time Paradox: The episode expertly sets up and resolves a complex temporal paradox. The discovery of Data's head causes Data to travel back in time, ultimately resulting in his head being left behind. This "closed loop" is a satisfying piece of time-travel writing.

Fish-Out-of-Water Comedy: The crew's struggle to adapt to 1893rCoespecially Picard's discomfort with their "period-appropriate" clothing and Troi's lack of social etiquetterCoprovides wonderful, genuine humor and showcases the actors' comedic talents.

Data and the Human Condition: DatarCOs interaction with historical figures like Jack London and Mark Twain is a beautiful way to explore his pursuit of humanity. Mark Twain, played wonderfully by Jerry Hardin, is instrumental in the resolution and provides a witty foil for Picard.

Thematically Rich: The episode is not only an adventure but a commentary on class, poverty, and the exploitation of the vulnerable, themes relevant in both the 19th and 24th centuries.

Weaknesses
Generic Villains: The Devidians themselves, a time-traveling, life-force-draining vampire race, are not particularly memorable or philosophically engaging compared to other TNG antagonists. They function primarily as a plot device to keep the crew in danger.

The Devidian Time-Travel Device: The mechanics of the aliensrCO time travel and their means of sustenance are explained with a heavy dose of technobabble that is necessary but slightly unwieldy.

Overall Impression
"Time's Arrow" is an exciting, well-paced two-parter that successfully balances serious temporal mechanics with strong character development and delightful comedy. It provides a unique setting for the crew to interact, highlights DatarCOs enduring quest for humanity, and features an unforgettable guest turn by Mark Twain. It is a spectacular end and beginning to the seasons it spans.

Rating: 9/10

That was a great one to look at! It gives us a fascinating look at the challenges of time travel.

ChatGPt

HererCOs my review of ***Star Trek: The Next Generation rCo rCLTimerCOs Arrow (Parts I & II)rCY*** (Season 5 raA Season 6 two-parter), based on the Chakoteya scripts and broader commentary, plus a rating out of 10.

---

## What the Episode Does / Plot Summary

* In *Part I*, the Enterprise discovers what appears to be 19th-century human relics (including **DatarCOs severed head** buried in a cave under San Francisco). The clues point to temporal anomalies and alien interference. Data deduces that his head traveled back in time and that a species from the planet Devidia II may be behind it. He becomes phase-displaced and ends up in 1893 San Francisco. He encounters historical figures (Mark Twain / Samuel Clemens), meets Guinan (revealing that she is already on Earth in that era), and tries to gather resources to continue his mission. Meanwhile, the Enterprise works to trace the alien energy source, build a phase discriminator, and eventually a team (Picard, Riker, Troi, Geordi, Crusher) follows through a temporal portal to the past.
* In *Part II*, the team continues in 19th century Earth, discovering that the aliens are feeding on the life forces of people dying from epidemics (e.g. cholera) by extracting rCLstrandsrCY of life energy at moment of death. They track the aliens, reassemble DatarCOs head with the living crew, confront the aliens in a cave time portal, and thwart their plan. Picard crafts a clever way to send a message across time by embedding a binary signal (via iron filings) in DatarCOs head, which will be discovered 500 years later. Samuel Clemens also crosses into the future briefly, and Guinan is left in 19th century care for a time. The alien habitat is destroyed with phase-timed photon torpedoes, and Picard is returned to his own time, reuniting with Guinan.
* The arc also gives us a rCLfirst meetingrCY backstory between Picard and Guinan, which had been long hinted at.
* The two-part episode is ambitiousrCoit combines time travel, character history, moral stakes, and weird aliens.
([turn0search8]([Wikipedia][1]), [turn0search1]([jammersreviews.com][2]), [turn0search4]([douxreviews.com][3]))

---

## What Works Well

1. **Bold Ambition & Scope**
ItrCOs rare for TNG to attempt a multi-season crossover with time travel, historical settings, and alien metaphysics all in one. The idea of DatarCOs head being buried for centuries is striking. The blending of sci-fi and period drama is commendable.
(JammerrCOs Reviews describes *Part I* as rCLserviceable but underwhelming as a season-ender,rCY acknowledging its ambition but critiquing execution.) ([jammersreviews.com][2])

2. **PicardrCoGuinan Mystery & Backstory**
Fans had long speculated about PicardrCOs relationship with Guinan. This arc gives the tease a partial payoff: Guinan is already present in 19th century Earth, and they meet (or will meet). That subplot gives emotional resonance and rewards long-term viewers.
(Doux Reviews mentions that *Part II* is more about Clemens and the costumes, but the PicardrCoGuinan thread is one of the emotional pillars.) ([douxreviews.com][3])

3. **Historical & Literary References**
Using figures like Mark Twain / Samuel Clemens is a classic sci-fi gambit. In *Part II*, Clemens becomes more than cameo: his reactions to the future, his critique of power and humanity, and his journey across time raise existential questions. (Though reviews often note he is uneven.) ([douxreviews.com][3])
The use of Jack London as a minor character is predictable but in keeping with classic habits of time travel stories. ([douxreviews.com][3])

4. **Visual Style, Costumes, Atmosphere**
The late 19th century costuming, sets, and atmospheric touches are praised. *Part II* in particular enjoys acclaim for its production values (costume, hair). (According to Wikipedia, *Part II* won Emmy awards in Costume Design and Hairstyling.) ([Wikipedia][1])

5. **Science-Fiction Ideas & Time Logic**
The method of embedding a message in data (via iron filings), the notion of phase displacement, the idea that the aliens feed on life energy during transitionsrCoall are interesting speculative ideas. Some commentators (e.g. on Wikipedia) note that the time travel mechanics are handled in a way that avoids strict paradoxes. ([Wikipedia][1])
Also, many reviews praise the opening shock of seeing DatarCOs head buried, which raises immediate stakes about mortality, identity, and fate.

---

## What Falters / Criticisms

1. **Pacing & Imbalance**
Many criticsrCoespecially JammerrCoargue that *Part I* is heavy on setup and weak on payoff. The second half, by contrast, rushes in places, especially in resolving plot threads. *Part II*rCOs narrative feels uneven, sometimes padded with historical detours (Clemens plotting) that slow the core alien conflict. ([jammersreviews.com][2])
Doux Reviews says *Part II* is rCLnot bad but not great,rCY more rCLfluffyrCY than deeply hauntingrColots of running around 1893 San Francisco, but less philosophical weight. ([douxreviews.com][3])

2. **Character Displacement & Underuse**
Some regular characters get relatively little to do in the 19th century. Worf, for example, is underutilized; the alien villains are not deeply fleshed. The focus is heavily on Data, Picard, Guinan, and Clemens. (Saga of the Jasonite notes Worf has few lines, but he does get moments to rCLtalk senserCY to Riker.) ([Saga of the Jasonite][4])
In reviews like The A.V. Club, *Part II* is criticized strongly: Zack Handlen called *Part I* rCLterriblerCY and *Part II* rCLworse,rCY with the historical scenes dragging, Clemens becoming a burden, and the pacing breaking down. ([AV Club][5])

3. **Villain & Motivations Weak**
The alien antagonistsrCothe DevidiansrCoare seen by many as underdeveloped. Their motivation (feeding on human life force via epidemic shadows) is speculative but not deeply grounded. Some reviews note thererCOs no clear conceptual depth to them, making them more plot device than existential threat. (Doux Reviews: rCLthe motivation and disposition of the bad guys was never adequately explained.rCY) ([douxreviews.com][3])
Also the idea that the aliens focus on the 19th century Earth (rather than another population or era) feels somewhat arbitrary. (Doux notes this as a plot hole.) ([douxreviews.com][3])

4. **Emotional & Narrative Inconsistencies**
The PicardrCoGuinan meeting, while emotionally planned, is criticized for lacking the build to feel fully earned. Some fans feel GuinanrCOs mysterious role is undercooked.
Also, elements like the binary message via iron filings are clever but strain credulity. How such messages survive centuries, or how characters manipulate them, sometimes feels too narrative-driven. (Doux reviews calls that solution rCLcoolrCY but rCLutterly ridiculousrCY in execution.) ([douxreviews.com][3])
The abrupt transitionsrCoe.g. Clemens crossing into future, Picard stranded, then rescuedrCofeel a bit jarring. Handlen criticizes *Part II* for being disjointed and dragging when Clemens is on screen. ([AV Club][5])

---

## Final Verdict & Rating: **7.5 / 10**

**Why 7.5:**

* *TimerCOs Arrow* is ambitious and has many high points: the Data mortality framing, the Picard/Guinan backstory theme, the visual blend of sci-fi and 19th century drama, and the speculative elements of time and identity.
* However, it doesnrCOt quite live up to its potential. The pacing is uneven, certain characters and the alien threat are underdeveloped, and some narrative conveniences are too thin. *Part II* in particular earns sharp criticism for dragging and uneven structure.
* In short: itrCOs a good two-parterrCoworth watching, with some moments that shinerCobut not among TNGrCOs absolute best.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time%27s_Arrow_%28Star_Trek%3A_The_Next_Generation%29?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Time's Arrow (Star Trek: The Next Generation)"
[2]: https://www.jammersreviews.com/st-tng/s5/arrow1.php?utm_source=chatgpt.com "\"Time's Arrow, Part I\" | Star Trek: TNG"
[3]: https://www.douxreviews.com/2018/04/star-trek-next-generation-times-arrow_21.html?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Star Trek The Next Generation: Time's Arrow, Part 2"
[4]: https://sagaofthejasonite.wordpress.com/star-trek-the-next-generation/season-six/review-of-episode-126-times-arrow-part-ii/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Review of episode 126: Time's Arrow, Part II"
[5]: https://www.avclub.com/star-trek-the-next-generation-times-arrow-part-ii-1798168466?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Star Trek: The Next Generation: \"Time's Arrow, Part II\" ..."
--
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant
--- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2