• Why iOS Requires an Apple ID for Basic Functionality

    From Marian@marianjones@helpfulpeople.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Thu Dec 25 14:07:51 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone


    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from
    others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually designed.

    Tyrone wrote:
    With ones Apple devices meshed via iCloud - and all the secure
    communications and storage therein, the powerful personal experience
    emerges when one daily drives a Mac/iPhone/Watch and if need be iPad and
    others.

    Exactly. This is the entire point of the Apple ecosystem.
    Everything works together.

    This thread can be titled any of the following to help people understand
    iOS Design, and specifically "What Happens When You Refuse the Apple ID"?

    iOS Design Assumptions and Apple ID Dependence
    How iOS Behaves When You Decline an Apple ID
    The Role of Apple ID in iOS Functionality
    iOS Architecture and Mandatory Cloud Integration
    iOS as a Cloud-Dependent Platform: Design or Limitation?
    The Apple Ecosystem and Forced Cloud Integration
    iOS Without an Apple ID: What Actually Happens
    Living Signed-Out on iOS: A Technical Reality Check
    iOS Prompts and Apple ID Lock-In: A Closer Look
    etc.

    If you refuse to sign in, like I do, then iOS will repeatedly prompt you.
    That part is absolutely real whether or not people are aware of it.

    The system is built around the assumption that an Apple ID is always
    present, so if you decline to provide one, you end up in a permanent "incomplete setup" state that keeps resurfacing.

    Obviously iOS relies heavily on Apple ID for syncing, App Store access, iMessage, FaceTime, passkeys, and almost every other integrated feature.
    So yes, once you are signed into the Cupertino servers, "everything works together" because the device is designed to treat the cloud services as
    the center of gravity. The local device becomes the interface layer for
    that larger system.

    Once you're signed in, the system handles authentication silently in the background, but hiding that sign-in does not mean it is not happening.
    It simply means the prompts are suppressed because the device finally has
    the credentials it keeps asking for.

    If you refuse to sign in (as I have been testing for years), then you
    will eventually be forced by Apple to sign in again. The system will keep trying to complete tasks that require an Apple ID, and each failure
    triggers another prompt. That is not a bug. It is how the platform is
    designed.

    And one of the clearest examples is that you cannot update apps at all
    unless you are signed into an Apple ID. Even apps you already have
    installed cannot be updated without logging into the Apple servers. At
    the same time, the OS itself *can* be updated without an Apple ID. This
    means that over time, the OS will advance while the apps remain frozen,
    and eventually many of them will refuse to run because they no longer
    match the newer OS requirements. This is not hypothetical. It is built
    into the design.

    Every common consumer ecosystem "works together" if you are willing to
    stay logged into the mothership all day long. Apple simply pushes that
    model harder than most.

    A case in point - and this does not apply generally[1] to Android is
    Passkeys, the growing secure login method for a rapidly growing number
    of sites.

    There are fundamental concepts that need to be stated about the locked-in nature of the Apple ecosystem, which we may need to discuss in a separate thread.

    It seems we need a separate thread on the topic of how iOS is designed.

    On Apple, the same Passkey one has set up from any of his iCloud linked
    accounts is near instantly available via iCloud/Passwords on his other
    devices that have secure login (biometric or password guarded: ie on my
    Mac it's fingerprint, Phone:FaceID). No special app needed - it's in
    the bones of iOS, MacOS, etc.

    What needs to be taught is that iOS is designed around the assumption that
    the cloud is the authoritative source. Once you're signed into the Apple servers, of course things appear seamless. That is the whole point of the design. The device is not meant to operate independently of that system.

    It seems we need a separate thread on the topic of how iOS is designed.

    Exactly. This is the entire point of the Apple ecosystem. Everything works together. Something Arlen will never admit - or even understand.

    What needs to be taught is that iOS devices lose major functionality when
    you are not logged into the Apple servers. The platform is structured so
    that the cloud account is not optional. If you decline to sign in, you
    will be prompted constantly because the system is trying to complete tasks
    that it cannot complete without those credentials.

    It seems we need a separate thread on the topic of how iOS is designed.

    Because Troll.

    Smooth sailing at the Apple Country Club. A gated facility with free
    access to the wilder world outside.

    The frequency of sign-ins to Apple's Cupertino matrix is high simply
    because almost every subsystem on iOS expects an Apple ID:
    App Store
    iCloud
    iMessage
    FaceTime
    Keychain / Passkeys
    Find My
    Device backups
    App updates
    Subscriptions
    Apple Pay
    Screen Time
    Family Sharing
    Photos sync
    Notes sync
    Safari sync
    Password autofill
    Two-factor prompts
    System services that check entitlement status
    etc.

    When you're signed out, each of these tries to initialize, fails, and
    triggers a prompt. So the frequency I am describing is rational and
    predictable given the architecture.

    [1] This is possible on an Android phone - via "Google Password Manager"
    in Chrome. Eeeeeiiii ! What a stinkin' plop of proposition that is!

    The fact is that iOS devices are designed around the assumption that the
    cloud account is always present. That is why the experience feels like a
    dumb terminal when you decline to participate in that model.

    Any OS can behave like iOS if you are willing to log into the mothership servers constantly. The difference is that on iOS, the design makes that
    model unavoidable, and if you refuse to sign in, you see the underlying mechanics exposed all day, every day, forever.
    --
    My goal on these Apple newsgroups is to teach, learn and to help others.
    This particular thread is all about learning from others & teaching them.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marian@marianjones@helpfulpeople.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Thu Dec 25 14:39:15 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Marian wrote:
    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually designed.

    To help users on this Apple newsgroup LEARN how iOS actually works, and to
    help further the conversation to discuss how iOS actually works, here are
    the unavoidable facts based on long-term testing of iOS devices while
    avoiding manual Apple ID logins & avoiding Apple's cloud ecosystem as much
    as possible so that the true nature of the iOS ecosystem was being tested.

    1. *Device activation and Apple servers with respect to the AppleID*
    An iOS device cannot be brought into a usable state without contacting
    Apple's activation servers. This activation step is mandatory and is
    separate from creating or signing into an Apple ID.

    Even if you skip the Apple ID portion, the device must still check
    in with Apple before setup can complete.

    2. *Operating an iOS device without signing into an Apple ID*
    It is possible to skip signing into an Apple ID during setup, but the
    device operates in a limited state. Many system components repeatedly
    prompt for Apple ID credentials because the OS assumes that an Apple ID
    will eventually be provided.

    3. *App updates versus OS updates with & without logging into an AppleID*
    If you do not sign into an Apple ID, you cannot update any apps at all,
    including apps that were already installed on the device.
    However, the OS itself can still be updated without an Apple ID.
    Over time, this causes a mismatch where the OS continues to advance
    but the apps remain frozen.

    Eventually, some apps stop functioning because they are no longer
    compatible with the newer OS version.

    4. *Long-term testing without manually signing into the AppleID*
    Two different iPads were operated for roughly two years without signing
    back into the associated Apple ID. After that period, both devices
    became activation-locked.

    To regain access, it was necessary to visit Apple in person and I had
    to present government-issued identification. After verification,
    the devices were unlocked, and the same Apple ID credentials that
    had always worked were accepted.

    This shows that the lockout was triggered solely & unilaterally
    by Apple's systems, not by any forgotten or incorrect password.

    5. *Two-factor verification (2FV) when signing into the AppleID*
    Apple now requires two-factor verification for Apple IDs.
    It is no longer possible to create an Apple ID without enabling 2FV.

    Even for old grandfathered AppleIDs, once 2FV is enabled, Apple does
    not allow 2FV/MFV to be removed after the standard waiting period
    has passed. Attempts to operate an older device without 2FV eventually
    result in the account being forced into 2FV with no option to revert.

    6. *Attempting to initialize an iOS device without contacting Apple*
    It is not possible to activate or initialize an iOS device entirely
    offline. Even without creating an Apple ID, the activation step still
    requires communication with Apple's servers.

    Without that server contact, the device cannot complete setup.

    These behaviors are not theoretical. They are the observed results of deliberately operating multiple iOS devices for extended periods without signing into an Apple ID, without enabling 2FV, and without allowing the devices to complete the cloud-dependent workflows that iOS expects.

    Thus this is the true nature of how iOS really works, which I'd guess that likely one out of a million Apple owners has any inkling of understanding.
    --
    Sharing the lesser-known realities of iOS learned by testing, that only a
    tiny minority of users ever discover so the whole group can always benefit. --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Tyrone@none@none.none to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Thu Dec 25 21:57:33 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Dec 25, 2025 at 4:07:51rC>PM EST, "Marian" <marianjones@helpfulpeople.com> wrote:


    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually designed.

    No we don't. Again, one can't "teach" a topic when one knows nothing about the topic.

    Tyrone wrote:
    With ones Apple devices meshed via iCloud - and all the secure
    communications and storage therein, the powerful personal experience
    emerges when one daily drives a Mac/iPhone/Watch and if need be iPad and >>> others.

    I did not write the above. But it IS 100% correct.


    Exactly. This is the entire point of the Apple ecosystem.
    Everything works together.

    This thread can be titled any of the following to help people understand
    iOS Design, and specifically "What Happens When You Refuse the Apple ID"?

    It can be titled "These are Arlen's fantasies about iOS, because Arlen knows nothing about iOS since Arlen clearly has no iOS devices". He did not even know how the Files app worked. Which BTW, requires no login to Apple. Neither does the SMB Server app.

    You REALLY do prattle on, don't you? Why don't you start ANOTHER topic where you talk to yourself?

    Delusional nonsense snipped.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Your Name@YourName@YourISP.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Fri Dec 26 11:28:07 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2025-12-25 21:57:33 +0000, Tyrone said:
    On Dec 25, 2025 at 4:07:51rC>PM EST, "Marian" <marianjones@helpfulpeople.com> wrote:

    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from
    others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually designed.

    No we don't. Again, one can't "teach" a topic when one knows nothing about the
    topic.

    True, but there are plenty of tutors, teachers, and even university
    lecturers who believe they can and get apid for it. :-(

    In high school I had a mathematics teacher who wrote "X + X = 3X" on
    the blackboard as part of a bigger equation, and then spent the rest of
    the one hour lesson trying to figure out where he went wrong. :-\
    That was near the start of the year, and I completely ignoref the fool
    for the rest of the year and went thought the text book by myself.

    In university, there was a computer science lecturer who claimed that
    "no personal computer can do multitasking" ... until several people
    pointed out to him that the Commodore Amiga had been doing it for at
    least a year by that time.



    Tyrone wrote:
    With ones Apple devices meshed via iCloud - and all the secure
    communications and storage therein, the powerful personal experience
    emerges when one daily drives a Mac/iPhone/Watch and if need be iPad and >>>> others.

    I did not write the above. But it IS 100% correct.


    Exactly. This is the entire point of the Apple ecosystem. Everything
    works together.

    This thread can be titled any of the following to help people understand
    iOS Design, and specifically "What Happens When You Refuse the Apple ID"?

    It can be titled "These are Arlen's fantasies about iOS, because Arlen knows nothing about

    ... anything at all."

    Fixed it for you. :-)



    iOS since Arlen clearly has no iOS devices". He did not even know how
    the Files app worked. Which BTW, requires no login to Apple. Neither
    does the SMB Server app.

    You REALLY do prattle on, don't you? Why don't you start ANOTHER topic
    where you talk to yourself?

    Delusional nonsense snipped.


    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marian@marianjones@helpfulpeople.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Thu Dec 25 15:31:43 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Tyrone wrote:
    On Dec 25, 2025 at 4:07:51rC>PM EST, "Marian" <marianjones@helpfulpeople.com> wrote:


    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from
    others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually designed.

    No we don't. Again, one can't "teach" a topic when one knows nothing about the
    topic.

    Tyrone wrote:
    With ones Apple devices meshed via iCloud - and all the secure
    communications and storage therein, the powerful personal experience
    emerges when one daily drives a Mac/iPhone/Watch and if need be iPad and >>>> others.

    I did not write the above. But it IS 100% correct.


    Exactly. This is the entire point of the Apple ecosystem.
    Everything works together.

    This thread can be titled any of the following to help people understand
    iOS Design, and specifically "What Happens When You Refuse the Apple ID"?

    It can be titled "These are Arlen's fantasies about iOS, because Arlen knows nothing about iOS since Arlen clearly has no iOS devices". He did not even know how the Files app worked. Which BTW, requires no login to Apple. Neither does the SMB Server app.

    You REALLY do prattle on, don't you? Why don't you start ANOTHER topic where you talk to yourself?

    Delusional nonsense snipped.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Merry Christmas!

    Your personal comments aren't relevant to the technical topic, so I'll stay focused on discussing the known behavior of iOS as observed in actual use.

    The points I've described come from direct testing on multiple devices over extended periods. They aren't theoretical and don't depend on anyone's
    opinion of anyone else. To summarize the relevant behaviors:

    1. *Activation requirement*
    Every iOS device must contact Apple's activation servers before it can
    be used, even when no Apple ID is created.

    2. *Operating without an Apple ID*
    A device can be used without signing into an Apple ID, but the OS
    continues to prompt for one and certain features remain limited.

    3. *App installation and updates*
    Installing apps from the App Store requires signing into an Apple ID,
    because the App Store will not function without authenticating to
    Apple's servers. App updates also require an Apple ID, while OS updates
    do not. Over time this leads to app/OS version divergence.

    4. *Default apps and services that require Apple ID login*
    Several built-in apps depend on Apple's cloud services and cannot
    function fully without signing into an Apple ID. Examples include
    iMessage (in iMessage mode), FaceTime, iCloud Drive, Find My, Notes
    with iCloud syncing, Photos with iCloud Photos enabled, Reminders with
    iCloud syncing, Safari iCloud Tabs and bookmark syncing, Keychain
    syncing, and Mail for @icloud.com addresses. These apps either refuse
    to activate or operate only in a reduced, local-only mode until an
    Apple ID login is provided.

    5. *Long-term unsigned-in behavior*
    Devices left unsigned-in for extended periods eventually became
    activation-locked and required in-person verification to unlock.

    6. *Two-factor verification requirements*
    Apple now requires two-factor verification for all Apple IDs, including
    older accounts once 2FV has been enabled.

    7. *Offline setup limitations*
    Initial device setup cannot be completed entirely offline; activation
    requires contacting Apple's servers.

    While something like only one out of a million Apple owners understands any
    of this above, these points describe the system's actual behavior, which is independent of anyone's assumptions or preferences.

    If anyone has contradictory observations from real devices, this is the
    proper newsgroup to learn how iOS really works & to discuss implications.
    --
    Exploring the parts of iOS that only a very small number of users ever see,
    so we can all better understand the platform better conversing as adults.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marian@marianjones@helpfulpeople.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Thu Dec 25 15:31:57 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Tyrone wrote:
    On Dec 25, 2025 at 4:07:51rC>PM EST, "Marian" <marianjones@helpfulpeople.com> wrote:


    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from
    others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually designed.

    No we don't. Again, one can't "teach" a topic when one knows nothing about the
    topic.

    Tyrone wrote:
    With ones Apple devices meshed via iCloud - and all the secure
    communications and storage therein, the powerful personal experience
    emerges when one daily drives a Mac/iPhone/Watch and if need be iPad and >>>> others.

    I did not write the above. But it IS 100% correct.


    Exactly. This is the entire point of the Apple ecosystem.
    Everything works together.

    This thread can be titled any of the following to help people understand
    iOS Design, and specifically "What Happens When You Refuse the Apple ID"?

    It can be titled "These are Arlen's fantasies about iOS, because Arlen knows nothing about iOS since Arlen clearly has no iOS devices". He did not even know how the Files app worked. Which BTW, requires no login to Apple. Neither does the SMB Server app.

    You REALLY do prattle on, don't you? Why don't you start ANOTHER topic where you talk to yourself?

    Delusional nonsense snipped.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Merry Christmas!

    Your personal comments aren't relevant to the technical topic, so I'll stay focused on discussing the known behavior of iOS as observed in actual use.

    The points I've described come from direct testing on multiple devices over extended periods. They aren't theoretical and don't depend on anyone's
    opinion of anyone else. To summarize the relevant behaviors:

    1. *Activation requirement*
    Every iOS device must contact Apple's activation servers before it can
    be used, even when no Apple ID is created.

    2. *Operating without an Apple ID*
    A device can be used without signing into an Apple ID, but the OS
    continues to prompt for one and certain features remain limited.

    3. *App installation and updates*
    Installing apps from the App Store requires signing into an Apple ID,
    because the App Store will not function without authenticating to
    Apple's servers. App updates also require an Apple ID, while OS updates
    do not. Over time this leads to app/OS version divergence.

    4. *Default apps and services that require Apple ID login*
    Several built-in apps depend on Apple's cloud services and cannot
    function fully without signing into an Apple ID. Examples include
    iMessage (in iMessage mode), FaceTime, iCloud Drive, Find My, Notes
    with iCloud syncing, Photos with iCloud Photos enabled, Reminders with
    iCloud syncing, Safari iCloud Tabs and bookmark syncing, Keychain
    syncing, and Mail for @icloud.com addresses. These apps either refuse
    to activate or operate only in a reduced, local-only mode until an
    Apple ID login is provided.

    5. *Long-term unsigned-in behavior*
    Devices left unsigned-in for extended periods eventually became
    activation-locked and required in-person verification to unlock.

    6. *Two-factor verification requirements*
    Apple now requires two-factor verification for all Apple IDs, including
    older accounts once 2FV has been enabled.

    7. *Offline setup limitations*
    Initial device setup cannot be completed entirely offline; activation
    requires contacting Apple's servers.

    While something like only one out of a million Apple owners understands any
    of this above, these points describe the system's actual behavior, which is independent of anyone's assumptions or preferences.

    If anyone has contradictory observations from real devices, this is the
    proper newsgroup to learn how iOS really works & to discuss implications.
    --
    Exploring the parts of iOS that only a very small number of users ever see,
    so we can all better understand the platform better conversing as adults.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marian@marianjones@helpfulpeople.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Thu Dec 25 15:39:58 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Your Name wrote:
    True, but there are plenty of tutors, teachers, and even university lecturers who believe they can and get apid for it. :-(

    In high school I had a mathematics teacher who wrote "X + X = 3X" on
    the blackboard as part of a bigger equation, and then spent the rest of
    the one hour lesson trying to figure out where he went wrong. :-\
    That was near the start of the year, and I completely ignoref the fool
    for the rest of the year and went thought the text book by myself.

    In university, there was a computer science lecturer who claimed that
    "no personal computer can do multitasking" ... until several people
    pointed out to him that the Commodore Amiga had been doing it for at
    least a year by that time.


    Hi Your Name,

    Merry Christmas!

    I'm here to help others understand the deeper mechanics of iOS that
    most people never run into (and that Apple marketing never explains).

    Your anecdotes about teachers in the 1960s when you went to high school (at least I went to high school at that time) are rather interesting, but they don't really speak to the current technical points under discussion.

    None of the items I listed were opinions or theories as all were real-world observations of how iOS behaves in practice on actual devices.

    If any specific point in that list is factually incorrect, I'm happy to
    examine it. But stories about unrelated classroom experiences don't really address whether iOS requires activation, whether app installation requires
    an Apple ID, or how default apps behave without cloud login.

    If you have different observations from real devices, that would be useful
    to compare.

    To help you focus on the topic for discussion, here's a quick re-summary:
    1. iOS devices must contact Apple's activation servers before use.
    2. Devices can run without an Apple ID, but with repeated prompts and
    limits.
    3. App installation and app updates require an Apple ID; OS updates do not.
    4. Several built-in apps require Apple ID login to function fully.
    5. Devices left unsigned-in long-term eventually became activation-locked.
    6. Apple now requires two-factor verification for all Apple IDs.
    7. Initial setup cannot be completed offline; activation is required.

    If your claim is one of those items is wrong, or just an opinion, let's
    discuss it like adults do, instead of implying all teaching is wrong.
    --
    I'm here to help others understand the deeper mechanics of iOS that
    most people never run into (and that Apple marketing never explains).
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marian@marianjones@helpfulpeople.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Thu Dec 25 15:41:50 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Your Name wrote:
    True, but there are plenty of tutors, teachers, and even university lecturers who believe they can and get apid for it. :-(

    In high school I had a mathematics teacher who wrote "X + X = 3X" on
    the blackboard as part of a bigger equation, and then spent the rest of
    the one hour lesson trying to figure out where he went wrong. :-\
    That was near the start of the year, and I completely ignoref the fool
    for the rest of the year and went thought the text book by myself.

    In university, there was a computer science lecturer who claimed that
    "no personal computer can do multitasking" ... until several people
    pointed out to him that the Commodore Amiga had been doing it for at
    least a year by that time.


    Hi Your Name,

    Merry Christmas!

    I'm here to help others understand the deeper mechanics of iOS that
    most people never run into (and that Apple marketing never explains).

    Your anecdotes about teachers in the 1960s when you went to high school (at least I went to high school at that time) are rather interesting, but they don't really speak to the current technical points under discussion.

    None of the items I listed were opinions or theories as all were real-world observations of how iOS behaves in practice on actual devices.

    If any specific point in that list is factually incorrect, I'm happy to
    examine it. But stories about unrelated classroom experiences don't really address whether iOS requires activation, whether app installation requires
    an Apple ID, or how default apps behave without cloud login.

    If you have different observations from real devices, that would be useful
    to compare.

    To help you focus on the topic for discussion, here's a quick re-summary:
    1. iOS devices must contact Apple's activation servers before use.
    2. Devices can run without an Apple ID, but with prompts & limits.
    3. App installation and app updates require an Apple ID; OS updates do not.
    4. Several built-in apps require Apple ID login to function fully.
    5. Devices left unsigned-in long-term eventually became activation-locked.
    6. Apple now requires two-factor verification for all Apple IDs.
    7. Initial setup cannot be completed offline; activation is required.

    If your claim is one of those items is wrong, or just an opinion, let's
    discuss it like adults do, instead of implying all teaching is wrong.
    --
    I'm here to help others understand the deeper mechanics of iOS that
    most people never run into (and that Apple marketing never explains).
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jolly Roger@jollyroger@pobox.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Fri Dec 26 00:02:06 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2025-12-25, Tyrone <none@none.none> wrote:
    On Dec 25, 2025 at 4:07:51rC>PM EST, "Marian" <marianjones@helpfulpeople.com> wrote:

    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from
    others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually designed.

    No we don't. Again, one can't "teach" a topic when one knows nothing about the
    topic.

    Tyrone wrote:
    With ones Apple devices meshed via iCloud - and all the secure
    communications and storage therein, the powerful personal experience
    emerges when one daily drives a Mac/iPhone/Watch and if need be iPad and >>>> others.

    I did not write the above. But it IS 100% correct.


    Exactly. This is the entire point of the Apple ecosystem.
    Everything works together.

    This thread can be titled any of the following to help people understand
    iOS Design, and specifically "What Happens When You Refuse the Apple ID"?

    It can be titled "These are Arlen's fantasies about iOS, because Arlen knows nothing about iOS since Arlen clearly has no iOS devices". He did not even know how the Files app worked. Which BTW, requires no login to Apple.

    I remember his claim that the Files app required connecting to the Apple mothership, which is ridiculous to anyone who has actually used the
    Files app to connect to a NAS or other SMB shared volume on their local network.

    "Marian" doesn't know how Apple kit actually works, yet constantly calls
    anyone who corrects his bullshit "low-IQ" "moron" "Apple trolls" (among
    other schoolyard insults). He's a piece of shit, and so is anyone who
    backs him.
    --
    E-mail sent to this address may be devoured by my ravenous SPAM filter.
    I often ignore posts from Google. Use a real news client instead.

    JR
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marian@marianjones@helpfulpeople.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Thu Dec 25 18:18:19 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Jolly Roger wrote:
    On 2025-12-25, Tyrone <none@none.none> wrote:
    On Dec 25, 2025 at 4:07:51'PM EST, "Marian" <marianjones@helpfulpeople.com> >> wrote:

    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from
    others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually designed. >>
    No we don't. Again, one can't "teach" a topic when one knows nothing about the
    topic.

    Tyrone wrote:
    With ones Apple devices meshed via iCloud - and all the secure
    communications and storage therein, the powerful personal experience >>>>> emerges when one daily drives a Mac/iPhone/Watch and if need be iPad and >>>>> others.

    I did not write the above. But it IS 100% correct.


    Exactly. This is the entire point of the Apple ecosystem.
    Everything works together.

    This thread can be titled any of the following to help people understand >>> iOS Design, and specifically "What Happens When You Refuse the Apple ID"? >>
    It can be titled "These are Arlen's fantasies about iOS, because Arlen knows >> nothing about iOS since Arlen clearly has no iOS devices". He did not even >> know how the Files app worked. Which BTW, requires no login to Apple.

    I remember his claim that the Files app required connecting to the Apple mothership, which is ridiculous to anyone who has actually used the
    Files app to connect to a NAS or other SMB shared volume on their local network.

    "Marian" doesn't know how Apple kit actually works, yet constantly calls anyone who corrects his bullshit "low-IQ" "moron" "Apple trolls" (among
    other schoolyard insults). He's a piece of shit, and so is anyone who
    backs him.

    Without responding to the ad hominems, keeping purely technical regarding
    the Files app so that we can concentrate on what was actually said, and not what Jolly Roger may have thought was said, here are details about the
    Files app workings in iOS, both with and without the use of the AppleID.

    First & foremost, the Files app on iOS is a built-in system app, not an App Store app, which thus allows it to inherit a few practical consequences:
    1. We do NOT need an Apple ID to use the Files app.
    2. We do NOT need an Apple ID for the Files app to be updated.
    3. Unlike most iOS apps, the Files app is updated when iOS itself
    is updated (via Settings > General > Software Update), because
    the Files app is actually a key part of the operating system.
    4. iOS system updates themselves do not require that any Apple ID
    be signed in (which is a critical feature to teach others).

    A device with no Apple ID can still receive and install iOS updates, and
    that is how the Files app gets updated.

    To the point that Jolly Roger just raised, the Files app does not require
    any connection to Apple's servers in order to browse or use files on iOS.

    That includes:
    a. On-device storage
    b. External storage (USB drives, SD cards, etc., where supported)
    c. Local network shares (SMB servers, NAS boxes, file shares on the LAN)
    d. Third-party cloud services such as Dropbox, Google Drive, OneDrive,
    Box, etc. (which use their own logins, not an Apple ID)

    We need to refresh Jolly Roger's memory that the only part of Files that involves Apple's servers is the iCloud Drive section, which is optional and simply does not appear if you are not signed in with an Apple ID or if
    iCloud Drive is disabled. The rest of Files works entirely without iCloud.

    When we connect to a NAS or SMB share from the Files app, we are using
    standard SMB networking. The traffic goes between our iOS device and the
    SMB server (for example, our NAS or a shared folder on our LAN), using the normal SMB ports (e.g. TCP port 445, and in some setups also 139). In that scenario, there is no need for the connection to involve Apple's Cupertino matrix at all, and no requirement to be logged into any Apple account.

    So, to summarize in concrete terms so that Jolly Roger is less confused:
    A. Can we use Files with no Apple ID?
    Yes.
    B. Can we connect Files to a local SMB share or NAS with no Apple ID?
    Yes.
    C. Can the Files app still receive updates with no Apple ID?
    Yes, whenever iOS itself is updated.
    D. Does Files require a permanent connection to any "Apple mothership"
    to function? No. It uses local storage, LAN, and whatever servers
    we explicitly configure (SMB, third-party clouds, etc.).

    Apple's servers are only involved if/when we choose to use iCloud Drive.
    --
    Focused on how iOS truly behaves when used outside the usual
    Apple-ID-first workflow (which is something few users ever experience).
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marian@marianjones@helpfulpeople.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Thu Dec 25 18:18:37 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Jolly Roger wrote:
    On 2025-12-25, Tyrone <none@none.none> wrote:
    On Dec 25, 2025 at 4:07:51'PM EST, "Marian" <marianjones@helpfulpeople.com> >> wrote:

    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from
    others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually designed. >>
    No we don't. Again, one can't "teach" a topic when one knows nothing about the
    topic.

    Tyrone wrote:
    With ones Apple devices meshed via iCloud - and all the secure
    communications and storage therein, the powerful personal experience >>>>> emerges when one daily drives a Mac/iPhone/Watch and if need be iPad and >>>>> others.

    I did not write the above. But it IS 100% correct.


    Exactly. This is the entire point of the Apple ecosystem.
    Everything works together.

    This thread can be titled any of the following to help people understand >>> iOS Design, and specifically "What Happens When You Refuse the Apple ID"? >>
    It can be titled "These are Arlen's fantasies about iOS, because Arlen knows >> nothing about iOS since Arlen clearly has no iOS devices". He did not even >> know how the Files app worked. Which BTW, requires no login to Apple.

    I remember his claim that the Files app required connecting to the Apple mothership, which is ridiculous to anyone who has actually used the
    Files app to connect to a NAS or other SMB shared volume on their local network.

    "Marian" doesn't know how Apple kit actually works, yet constantly calls anyone who corrects his bullshit "low-IQ" "moron" "Apple trolls" (among
    other schoolyard insults). He's a piece of shit, and so is anyone who
    backs him.

    Without responding to the ad hominems, keeping purely technical regarding
    the Files app so that we can concentrate on what was actually said, and not what Jolly Roger may have thought was said, here are details about the
    Files app workings in iOS, both with and without the use of the AppleID.

    First & foremost, the Files app on iOS is a built-in system app, not an App Store app, which thus allows it to inherit a few practical consequences:
    1. We do NOT need an Apple ID to use the Files app.
    2. We do NOT need an Apple ID for the Files app to be updated.
    3. Unlike most iOS apps, the Files app is updated when iOS itself
    is updated (via Settings > General > Software Update), because
    the Files app is actually a key part of the operating system.
    4. iOS system updates themselves do not require that any Apple ID
    be signed in (which is a critical feature to teach others).

    A device with no Apple ID can still receive and install iOS updates, and
    that is how the Files app gets updated.

    To the point that Jolly Roger just raised, the Files app does not require
    any connection to Apple's servers in order to browse or use files on iOS.

    That includes:
    a. On-device storage
    b. External storage (USB drives, SD cards, etc., where supported)
    c. Local network shares (SMB servers, NAS boxes, file shares on the LAN)
    d. Third-party cloud services such as Dropbox, Google Drive, OneDrive,
    Box, etc. (which use their own logins, not an Apple ID)

    We need to refresh Jolly Roger's memory that the only part of Files that involves Apple's servers is the iCloud Drive section, which is optional and simply does not appear if you are not signed in with an Apple ID or if
    iCloud Drive is disabled. The rest of Files works entirely without iCloud.

    When we connect to a NAS or SMB share from the Files app, we are using
    standard SMB networking. The traffic goes between our iOS device and the
    SMB server (for example, our NAS or a shared folder on our LAN), using the normal SMB ports (e.g. TCP port 445, and in some setups also 139). In that scenario, there is no need for the connection to involve Apple's Cupertino matrix at all, and no requirement to be logged into any Apple account.

    So, to summarize in concrete terms so that Jolly Roger is less confused:
    A. Can we use Files with no Apple ID?
    Yes.
    B. Can we connect Files to a local SMB share or NAS with no Apple ID?
    Yes.
    C. Can the Files app still receive updates with no Apple ID?
    Yes, whenever iOS itself is updated.
    D. Does Files require a permanent connection to any "Apple mothership"
    to function? No. It uses local storage, LAN, and whatever servers
    we explicitly configure (SMB, third-party clouds, etc.).

    Apple's servers are only involved if/when we choose to use iCloud Drive.
    --
    Focused on how iOS truly behaves when used outside the usual
    Apple-ID-first workflow (which is something few users ever experience).
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marian@marianjones@helpfulpeople.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Thu Dec 25 18:52:00 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Your Name wrote:
    On 2025-12-25 17:57:10 +0000, Tyrone said:
    On Dec 25, 2025 at 12:10:14rC>PM EST, "Alan Browne" <bitbucket@blackhole.com>
    wrote:
    On 2025-12-25 11:46, Marian wrote:

    ...to log into the various Apple mothership tracking servers... which most >>>> Apple owners have no idea they're always tethered to... because an iOS >>>> device doesn't do much without them...

    Distorted Reality message again from Arlen. Par I guess.

    1) iOS runs fine w/o any connection to Apple cloud at all. Can surf the >>> web, do one's e-mail, use myriad other apps and web based services, etc.

    Yep. You can easily use an iPhone, iPad, or Mac computer without any connection to the outside world at all. The iPhone will of course
    simply be a small iPad / iPod Touch / digital diary rather than an
    actual 'phone' (although in many places a mobile phone even without a
    SIM card can still be used to call emergency services).


    Hi Your Name,

    Merry Christmas!

    I think it is worth being precise about what runs fine actually means in
    the context of iOS because iOS is different from all other common OS's.

    The key distinction is that iOS is the only widely used OS that does not
    permit installation of third party software without authenticating to the vendor controlled account system. Android allows sideloading and allows the
    use of alternative store clients such as Aurora without any Google account. Windows, macOS, Linux, and Android all permit software installation without
    any vendor account. iOS does not.

    It is correct that an iPhone or iPad will boot and operate without signing
    into an Apple ID, and it is correct that you can use offline apps, local
    media, basic web browsing, and email through third party providers.
    However, this is only possible after the device has already been activated
    on Apple servers and after any desired applications have already been
    installed through an authenticated App Store session. iOS does not permit installation of applications without Apple ID authentication, and every App Store installation is tied to the Apple ID used.

    So, without the account, you can't install a single app, or update it.
    That's huge.

    iOS is the only mobile OS that requires server side activation tied to the device hardware before the device can be used. This activation is mandatory
    and cannot be bypassed. Windows and macOS have activation mechanisms, but
    they do not require a cloud account and they do not lock the device to a personal identity. That's also a huge difference you didn't yet mention.

    Only iOS has the concept of requiring a mothership account to install apps. Only iOS has the concept of the default messenger even having an account.
    Only iOS forces activation on matrix-tracking servers. Nobody else does.
    Only Apple unilaterally locks the device if you haven't logged in recently. Only Apple requires government ID in order to get that iOS device unlocked. etc.

    So rest assured, when you think about how iOS is vastly different from all other operating systems (including macOS), you will think differently.

    Yes, an iPhone or iPad will boot and operate without signing into an Apple
    ID, and yes, you can use it for offline apps, local media, basic web
    browsing, and email through third party providers if (and this is big), if you've already activated the iOS device on Apple's tracking servers, and if you've already installed apps using a login on Apple's tracking servers
    (where Apple inserts a unique identifier for you into ever app installed).

    None of that is in dispute by anyone who understands how iOS really works.

    But it is also technically accurate that a large portion of iOS
    functionality is architecturally dependent on Apple authenticated services.

    That is not a value judgment. It is simply how the platform is designed. Without an Apple ID, you lose:
    a. App Store access including app installation and updates
    b. iMessage to iMessage (but not to SMS/RCS) and FaceTime
    c. iCloud sync, backup, and Keychain
    d. Find My and Activation Lock
    e. Apple Books, Apple Music, Apple TV, and similar services
    etc.

    These are not fringe features. They are core components of the ecosystem.

    So while the device will operate, it does so in a significantly reduced
    mode. Calling that fine depends on what someone considers baseline functionality, but from a technical standpoint, the OS is intentionally
    built around authenticated cloud services.

    None of this requires assuming anything about motives or motherships.
    It is simply the practical reality of how iOS is engineered.
    --
    Discussing actual technical realities of iOS design that only a tiny
    fraction of users ever learn because Apple marketing doesn't explain this.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Mon Dec 29 17:09:29 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2025-12-25 13:07, Marian wrote:

    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually designed.

    Tyrone wrote:
    With ones Apple devices meshed via iCloud - and all the secure
    communications and storage therein, the powerful personal experience
    emerges when one daily drives a Mac/iPhone/Watch and if need be iPad and >>> others.

    Exactly. This is the entire point of the Apple ecosystem.
    Everything works together.

    This thread can be titled any of the following to help people understand
    iOS Design, and specifically "What Happens When You Refuse the Apple ID"?

    iOS Design Assumptions and Apple ID Dependence
    How iOS Behaves When You Decline an Apple ID
    The Role of Apple ID in iOS Functionality
    iOS Architecture and Mandatory Cloud Integration
    iOS as a Cloud-Dependent Platform: Design or Limitation?
    The Apple Ecosystem and Forced Cloud Integration
    iOS Without an Apple ID: What Actually Happens
    Living Signed-Out on iOS: A Technical Reality Check
    iOS Prompts and Apple ID Lock-In: A Closer Look
    etc.

    If you refuse to sign in, like I do, then iOS will repeatedly prompt you. That part is absolutely real whether or not people are aware of it.

    The system is built around the assumption that an Apple ID is always
    present, so if you decline to provide one, you end up in a permanent "incomplete setup" state that keeps resurfacing.

    Obviously iOS relies heavily on Apple ID for syncing, App Store access, iMessage, FaceTime, passkeys, and almost every other integrated feature.
    So yes, once you are signed into the Cupertino servers, "everything works together" because the device is designed to treat the cloud services as
    the center of gravity. The local device becomes the interface layer for
    that larger system.

    But you are not forced or required to use any of those services, with
    the one exception of App Store access.

    For all the others, how in the world do you expect to integrate services across multiple devices WITHOUT authentication?


    Once you're signed in, the system handles authentication silently in the background, but hiding that sign-in does not mean it is not happening.

    OK. So?

    It simply means the prompts are suppressed because the device finally has
    the credentials it keeps asking for.

    If you refuse to sign in (as I have been testing for years), then you
    will eventually be forced by Apple to sign in again. The system will keep trying to complete tasks that require an Apple ID, and each failure
    triggers another prompt. That is not a bug. It is how the platform is designed.

    As I've already demonstrated, this is simply not so.

    Each failure does NOT trigger another prompt.

    As I showed back in August of 2024:

    <https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1UkFTfR0p5MyRakngCmF0NstYjF8OOb5j?usp=share_link>


    And one of the clearest examples is that you cannot update apps at all
    unless you are signed into an Apple ID. Even apps you already have
    installed cannot be updated without logging into the Apple servers. At

    This is true. It is literally the only true thing you've written so far.

    the same time, the OS itself *can* be updated without an Apple ID. This
    means that over time, the OS will advance while the apps remain frozen,
    and eventually many of them will refuse to run because they no longer
    match the newer OS requirements. This is not hypothetical. It is built
    into the design.

    And you can create an AppleID with absolutely minimal personal
    information to avoid this.


    Every common consumer ecosystem "works together" if you are willing to
    stay logged into the mothership all day long. Apple simply pushes that
    model harder than most.

    They make it attractive by offering a suite of useful services.

    I LIKE that my passwords are seamlessly and securely synched across my devices.

    Likewise for my:

    Notes
    Messages
    Contacts
    Calendars
    Reminders
    Safari bookmarks
    News
    Stocks
    Wallet
    FaceTime
    Books
    Maps

    Etc.!


    A case in point - and this does not apply generally[1] to Android is
    Passkeys, the growing secure login method for a rapidly growing number
    of sites.

    There are fundamental concepts that need to be stated about the locked-in nature of the Apple ecosystem, which we may need to discuss in a separate thread.

    It seems we need a separate thread on the topic of how iOS is designed.

    As if you'd understand it.


    On Apple, the same Passkey one has set up from any of his iCloud linked
    accounts is near instantly available via iCloud/Passwords on his other
    devices that have secure login (biometric or password guarded: ie on my
    Mac it's fingerprint, Phone:FaceID). No special app needed - it's in
    the bones of iOS, MacOS, etc.

    What needs to be taught is that iOS is designed around the assumption that the cloud is the authoritative source. Once you're signed into the Apple servers, of course things appear seamless. That is the whole point of the design. The device is not meant to operate independently of that system.

    It seems we need a separate thread on the topic of how iOS is designed.

    You said that already.


    Exactly. This is the entire point of the Apple ecosystem. Everything
    works
    together. Something Arlen will never admit - or even understand.

    What needs to be taught is that iOS devices lose major functionality when
    you are not logged into the Apple servers. The platform is structured so
    that the cloud account is not optional. If you decline to sign in, you
    will be prompted constantly because the system is trying to complete tasks that it cannot complete without those credentials.

    Cloud services require the cloud. This is not news.


    It seems we need a separate thread on the topic of how iOS is designed.

    You said that already.


    Because Troll.

    Smooth sailing at the Apple Country Club. A gated facility with free
    access to the wilder world outside.

    The frequency of sign-ins to Apple's Cupertino matrix is high simply
    because almost every subsystem on iOS expects an Apple ID:
    App Store

    Which you almost certainly need.

    iCloud

    Which you can decline to use.

    iMessage

    Which you can decline to use.

    FaceTime

    Which you can decline to use.

    Keychain / Passkeys

    Which you can decline to use.

    Find My

    Which you can decline to use.

    Device backups

    Which you can decline to use.

    App updates

    Which is the same as "App Store"

    Subscriptions

    Which you can decline to use.

    Apple Pay

    Which you can decline to use.

    Screen Time

    Which you can decline to use.

    Family Sharing

    Which you can decline to use.

    Photos sync

    Which you can decline to use.

    Notes sync

    Which you can decline to use.

    Safari sync

    Which you can decline to use.

    Password autofill

    Which you can decline to use.

    Two-factor prompts

    Which you can decline to use.

    System services that check entitlement status

    Such as?

    etc.

    When you're signed out, each of these tries to initialize, fails, and triggers a prompt. So the frequency I am describing is rational and predictable given the architecture.

    Wrong.


    [1] This is possible on an Android phone - via "Google Password Manager" >>> in Chrome. Eeeeeiiii ! What a stinkin' plop of proposition that is!

    The fact is that iOS devices are designed around the assumption that the cloud account is always present. That is why the experience feels like a
    dumb terminal when you decline to participate in that model.

    Any OS can behave like iOS if you are willing to log into the mothership servers constantly. The difference is that on iOS, the design makes that model unavoidable, and if you refuse to sign in, you see the underlying mechanics exposed all day, every day, forever.

    You can log in only when you want to install or update apps.

    Period.

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Mon Dec 29 17:19:03 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2025-12-25 13:39, Marian wrote:
    Marian wrote:
    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from
    others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually
    designed.

    To help users on this Apple newsgroup LEARN how iOS actually works, and to help further the conversation to discuss how iOS actually works, here are
    the unavoidable facts based on long-term testing of iOS devices while avoiding manual Apple ID logins & avoiding Apple's cloud ecosystem as much
    as possible so that the true nature of the iOS ecosystem was being tested.

    1. *Device activation and Apple servers with respect to the AppleID*
    -a An iOS device cannot be brought into a usable state without contacting
    -a Apple's activation servers. This activation step is mandatory and is
    -a separate from creating or signing into an Apple ID.
    -a Even if you skip the Apple ID portion, the device must still check
    -a in with Apple before setup can complete.

    So that it can be ascertained whether or not the device has been stolen.


    2. *Operating an iOS device without signing into an Apple ID*
    -a It is possible to skip signing into an Apple ID during setup, but the
    -a device operates in a limited state. Many system components repeatedly
    -a prompt for Apple ID credentials because the OS assumes that an Apple ID
    -a will eventually be provided.

    This is false.

    I have a freshly set up iPad immediately to the left of me, and I have
    signed out of the Apple Account (formerly "AppleID"; get the details
    right). I'll see how many prompts I get in the next day and you'll see.


    3. *App updates versus OS updates with & without logging into an AppleID*

    This is your first true claim.

    -a If you do not sign into an Apple ID, you cannot update any apps at all,
    -a including apps that were already installed on the device. -a However, the OS itself can still be updated without an Apple ID. -a Over time,
    this causes a mismatch where the OS continues to advance -a but the apps remain frozen.
    -a Eventually, some apps stop functioning because they are no longer
    -a compatible with the newer OS version.

    Except you can sign in only to install and update the apps.


    4. *Long-term testing without manually signing into the AppleID*
    -a Two different iPads were operated for roughly two years without signing
    -a back into the associated Apple ID. After that period, both devices became activation-locked.
    -a To regain access, it was necessary to visit Apple in person and I had
    -a to present government-issued identification. After verification,
    -a the devices were unlocked, and the same Apple ID credentials that
    had always worked were accepted.
    -a This shows that the lockout was triggered solely & unilaterally
    -a by Apple's systems, not by any forgotten or incorrect password.

    I don't believe you.


    5. *Two-factor verification (2FV) when signing into the AppleID*
    -a Apple now requires two-factor verification for Apple IDs. -a It is no longer possible to create an Apple ID without enabling 2FV.
    -a Even for old grandfathered AppleIDs, once 2FV is enabled, Apple does
    -a not allow 2FV/MFV to be removed after the standard waiting period
    -a has passed. Attempts to operate an older device without 2FV eventually
    -a result in the account being forced into 2FV with no option to revert.

    This is true. And a good thing.


    6. *Attempting to initialize an iOS device without contacting Apple*
    -a It is not possible to activate or initialize an iOS device entirely
    -a offline. Even without creating an Apple ID, the activation step still
    -a requires communication with Apple's servers.
    -a Without that server contact, the device cannot complete setup.

    Which you already said.

    Are you drinking?


    These behaviors are not theoretical. They are the observed results of deliberately operating multiple iOS devices for extended periods without signing into an Apple ID, without enabling 2FV, and without allowing the devices to complete the cloud-dependent workflows that iOS expects.

    Thus this is the true nature of how iOS really works, which I'd guess that likely one out of a million Apple owners has any inkling of understanding.

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Tyrone@none@none.none to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Tue Dec 30 01:59:37 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Dec 29, 2025 at 8:09:29rC>PM EST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:

    They make it attractive by offering a suite of useful services.

    I LIKE that my passwords are seamlessly and securely synched across my devices.

    Likewise for my:

    Notes
    Messages
    Contacts
    Calendars
    Reminders
    Safari bookmarks
    News
    Stocks
    Wallet
    FaceTime
    Books
    Maps

    Etc.!

    Exactly. The whole point of Apple.

    The frequency of sign-ins to Apple's Cupertino matrix is high simply
    because almost every subsystem on iOS expects an Apple ID:
    App Store

    Which you almost certainly need.

    iCloud

    Which you can decline to use.

    iMessage

    Which you can decline to use.

    FaceTime

    Which you can decline to use.

    Keychain / Passkeys

    Which you can decline to use.

    Find My

    Which you can decline to use.

    Device backups

    Which you can decline to use.

    App updates

    Which is the same as "App Store"

    Subscriptions

    Which you can decline to use.

    Apple Pay

    Which you can decline to use.

    Screen Time

    Which you can decline to use.

    Family Sharing

    Which you can decline to use.

    Photos sync

    Which you can decline to use.

    Notes sync

    Which you can decline to use.

    Safari sync

    Which you can decline to use.

    Password autofill

    Which you can decline to use.

    Two-factor prompts

    Which you can decline to use.

    And once you stop using all of these built-in Apple services, you would have
    an Android phone.

    No thanks.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Your Name@YourName@YourISP.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Dec 30 18:14:34 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2025-12-30 01:59:37 +0000, Tyrone said:
    On Dec 29, 2025 at 8:09:29rC>PM EST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:

    They make it attractive by offering a suite of useful services.

    I LIKE that my passwords are seamlessly and securely synched across my devices.

    Likewise for my:

    Notes
    Messages
    Contacts
    Calendars
    Reminders
    Safari bookmarks
    News
    Stocks
    Wallet
    FaceTime
    Books
    Maps

    Etc.!

    Exactly. The whole point of Apple.

    Well, not the "whole point" ... personally I only have one device (a
    desktop Mac) and do not use any of the iCloud stuff. We also have an
    iPad, but that is used by someone else so is separate (although does
    use my Apple ID for ease of my being the "tech support" for system
    updates). :-)




    The frequency of sign-ins to Apple's Cupertino matrix is high simply
    because almost every subsystem on iOS expects an Apple ID:
    App Store

    Which you almost certainly need.

    Only if you want to install other apps or any updates, which isn't a
    necessity for many people.



    iCloud

    Which you can decline to use.

    iMessage

    Which you can decline to use.

    FaceTime

    Which you can decline to use.

    Keychain / Passkeys

    Which you can decline to use.

    Find My

    Which you can decline to use.

    Device backups

    Which you can decline to use.

    App updates

    Which is the same as "App Store"

    Subscriptions

    Which you can decline to use.

    Apple Pay

    Which you can decline to use.

    Screen Time

    Which you can decline to use.

    Family Sharing

    Which you can decline to use.

    Photos sync

    Which you can decline to use.

    Notes sync

    Which you can decline to use.

    Safari sync

    Which you can decline to use.

    Password autofill

    Which you can decline to use.

    Two-factor prompts

    Which you can decline to use.

    And once you stop using all of these built-in Apple services, you would have an Android phone.

    I've never used any of those services, other than OS updates. I simply
    have zero need for them. My computer and the other person's iPad
    function perfectly well.


    No thanks.

    The real reason most people use Apple devices is because they are
    simply much easier to actually use. Almost everybody who uses an Apple
    device then does not want to go back to the awful mess of Andud or
    Windoze.



    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Tyrone@none@none.none to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Tue Dec 30 16:22:29 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Dec 30, 2025 at 12:14:34rC>AM EST, "Your Name" <YourName@YourISP.com> wrote:

    The real reason most people use Apple devices is because they are
    simply much easier to actually use. Almost everybody who uses an Apple
    device then does not want to go back to the awful mess of Andud or
    Windoze.

    Very true.

    But it is the combined ecosystem of Apple devices that really makes things easy. Phones, tablets, PCs and watches. All running the same OS and the same apps and services. All tied together by a single cloud service.

    To me, if you have a iPhone then you need an iPad. At that point, if you ever need a laptop then a Mac is the obvious choice.

    A Windows (or even worse, Linux) PC from THIS company and an Android phone
    from THAT company and an Android tablet from whoever is just a waste of time and energy. I don't need such challenges in my personal life. I have no desire to do systems integration for free.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Dec 30 11:06:49 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2025-12-29 21:14, Your Name wrote:
    On 2025-12-30 01:59:37 +0000, Tyrone said:
    On Dec 29, 2025 at 8:09:29rC>PM EST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:

    They make it attractive by offering a suite of useful services.

    I LIKE that my passwords are seamlessly and securely synched across
    my devices.

    Likewise for my:

    Notes
    Messages
    Contacts
    Calendars
    Reminders
    Safari bookmarks
    News
    Stocks
    Wallet
    FaceTime
    Books
    Maps

    Etc.!

    Exactly.-a-a The whole point of Apple.

    Well, not the "whole point" ... personally I only have one device (a
    desktop Mac) and do not use any of the iCloud stuff. We also have an
    iPad, but that is used by someone else so is separate (although does use
    my Apple ID for ease of my being the "tech support" for system
    updates).-a :-)

    If I can suggest, unless that iPad is used by a child you don't want to
    tie to an Apple Account yet, set up a separate account, and create a
    second user on the desktop machine, just for authentication.





    The frequency of sign-ins to Apple's Cupertino matrix is high simply
    because almost every subsystem on iOS expects an Apple ID:
    App Store

    Which you almost certainly need.

    Only if you want to install other apps or any updates, which isn't a necessity for many people.

    I would disagree with that.

    I doubt there are many people at all who never install a single app on
    their iOS devices.

    But I can tell you that I've set up an iPad with a pretty much blank
    Apple Account and I've signed in only for the App Store...

    ...and contrary to Arlen's drunken ravings, I haven't been asked to
    "complete" anything in the nearly 24 hours since I did it.




    iCloud

    Which you can decline to use.

    iMessage

    Which you can decline to use.

    FaceTime

    Which you can decline to use.

    Keychain / Passkeys

    Which you can decline to use.

    Find My

    Which you can decline to use.

    Device backups

    Which you can decline to use.

    App updates

    Which is the same as "App Store"

    Subscriptions

    Which you can decline to use.

    Apple Pay

    Which you can decline to use.

    Screen Time

    Which you can decline to use.

    Family Sharing

    Which you can decline to use.

    Photos sync

    Which you can decline to use.

    Notes sync

    Which you can decline to use.

    Safari sync

    Which you can decline to use.

    Password autofill

    Which you can decline to use.

    Two-factor prompts

    Which you can decline to use.

    And once you stop using all of these built-in Apple services, you
    would have
    an Android phone.

    I've never used any of those services, other than OS updates. I simply
    have zero need for them. My computer and the other person's iPad
    function perfectly well.

    And that's great.

    I would suggest you're in a (very) small minority that never uses any of those.



    No thanks.

    The real reason most people use Apple devices is because they are simply much easier to actually use. Almost everybody who uses an Apple device
    then does not want to go back to the awful mess of Andud or Windoze.

    Agreed.

    I no longer sell Apple gear, but when I did, I had many customers I
    convinced to give Macs a try...

    ...and only two (just 2!) ever wanted to go back.

    And these days, while there are still clients of mine who use Apple
    devices, they're mostly clients in name only...

    ...because they almost never need any support!

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marian@marianjones@helpfulpeople.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Tue Dec 30 18:49:15 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Tyrone wrote:
    The real reason most people use Apple devices is because they are
    simply much easier to actually use. Almost everybody who uses an Apple
    device then does not want to go back to the awful mess of Andud or
    Windoze.

    Very true.

    But it is the combined ecosystem of Apple devices that really makes things easy. Phones, tablets, PCs and watches. All running the same OS and the same apps and services. All tied together by a single cloud service.

    To me, if you have a iPhone then you need an iPad. At that point, if you ever need a laptop then a Mac is the obvious choice.

    A Windows (or even worse, Linux) PC from THIS company and an Android phone from THAT company and an Android tablet from whoever is just a waste of time and energy. I don't need such challenges in my personal life. I have no desire
    to do systems integration for free.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    The problem is all you're doing is parroting baseless Apple propaganda.
    You don't actually understand iOS, nor Android - you're just a parrot.

    I use Android & iOS all day, every day, so I understand them both.
    You understand neither.

    Whether iOS or Android is easier depends greatly on what tasks you're
    doing. For example, try moving a downloaded PDF from your email into a
    specific folder and opening it in a non-Apple app. On Android it's one
    step. On iOS it's a scavenger hunt.

    Likewise after downloading a ZIP file on iOS, opening it, and moving one of
    the files into a specific app's folder, where, on Android it's a two-tap action, yet on iOS it turns into a maze of share sheets and hidden menus.

    What's easier on iOS or Android depends greatly on what you're doing.

    Plug an iPhone and an Android into Windows and tell me which is easier for bidirectional file transfers, or try to load an app from anywhere outside
    of the app store, or even from the app store WITHOUT an account.

    Hell, try to re-install any IPA/APK of any version on Android versus iOS? What's impossible to do with iOS is trivial to do on Android in many cases.

    Anyone who parrots Apple propaganda doesn't understand anything about iOS.

    Try to customize your home screen, or change the default app for dialing, messaging, app launcher, file manager, assistant, camera, etc.

    Android lets you set a default dialer, SMS app, launcher, assistant, camera
    and file manager, while iOS locks every one of those defaults to Apple.

    Worse, you can't even DO on iOS half the things that you can do on Android.

    There's a reason I assess anyone who parrots Apple's meaningless (but brilliant) propaganda, doesn't know anything about iOS nor about Android.
    --
    The entry fee for posting on Usenet operating system newsgroups should be
    that the people posting should know something about the operating system.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Tue Dec 30 18:05:06 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2025-12-30 17:49, Marian wrote:
    Tyrone wrote:
    The real reason most people use Apple devices is because they are
    simply much easier to actually use. Almost everybody who uses an Apple
    device then does not want to go back to the awful mess of Andud or
    Windoze.

    Very true.
    But it is the combined ecosystem of Apple devices that really makes
    things
    easy.-a Phones, tablets, PCs and watches. All running the same OS and
    the same
    apps and services. All tied together by a single cloud service.

    To me, if you have a iPhone then you need an iPad. At that point, if
    you ever
    need a laptop then a Mac is the obvious choice.
    A Windows (or even worse, Linux) PC from THIS company and an Android
    phone
    from THAT company and an Android tablet from whoever is just a waste
    of time
    and energy. I don't need such challenges in my personal life. I have
    no desire
    to do systems integration for free.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    The problem is all you're doing is parroting baseless Apple propaganda.
    You don't actually understand iOS, nor Android - you're just a parrot.

    I use Android & iOS all day, every day, so I understand them both.
    You understand neither.

    Whether iOS or Android is easier depends greatly on what tasks you're
    doing. For example, try moving a downloaded PDF from your email into a specific folder and opening it in a non-Apple app. On Android it's one
    step. On iOS it's a scavenger hunt.

    Nope. It's one step to save it in a specific folder.


    Likewise after downloading a ZIP file on iOS, opening it, and moving one of the files into a specific app's folder, where, on Android it's a two-tap action, yet on iOS it turns into a maze of share sheets and hidden menus.

    Is this as accurate a claim as your claim that iOS wouldn't allow an app
    to provide an SMB service on standard Windows ports?

    <snip>
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Wed Dec 31 02:34:02 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Dec 30, 2025 at 6:49:15rC>PM MST, "Marian" wrote <10j1veq$2oai$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:

    Tyrone wrote:
    The real reason most people use Apple devices is because they are
    simply much easier to actually use. Almost everybody who uses an Apple
    device then does not want to go back to the awful mess of Andud or
    Windoze.

    Very true.

    But it is the combined ecosystem of Apple devices that really makes things >> easy. Phones, tablets, PCs and watches. All running the same OS and the same
    apps and services. All tied together by a single cloud service.

    To me, if you have a iPhone then you need an iPad. At that point, if you ever
    need a laptop then a Mac is the obvious choice.

    A Windows (or even worse, Linux) PC from THIS company and an Android phone >> from THAT company and an Android tablet from whoever is just a waste of time >> and energy. I don't need such challenges in my personal life. I have no desire
    to do systems integration for free.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    The problem is all you're doing is parroting baseless Apple propaganda.

    Can you point to this propaganda Apple is publishing?

    You don't actually understand iOS, nor Android - you're just a parrot.

    I use Android & iOS all day, every day, so I understand them both.

    No evidence you have an iOS device.

    You understand neither.

    Whether iOS or Android is easier depends greatly on what tasks you're
    doing. For example, try moving a downloaded PDF from your email into a specific folder and opening it in a non-Apple app. On Android it's one
    step. On iOS it's a scavenger hunt.

    This is similar to the task I compared for macOS. Would love to see your Android video showing how you do it. I will then show how I do a similar task on iOS. Look forward to your video.

    Likewise after downloading a ZIP file on iOS, opening it, and moving one of the files into a specific app's folder, where, on Android it's a two-tap action, yet on iOS it turns into a maze of share sheets and hidden menus.

    Again, show a video and I will, too. We can both learn.

    What's easier on iOS or Android depends greatly on what you're doing.

    Plug an iPhone and an Android into Windows and tell me which is easier for bidirectional file transfers, or try to load an app from anywhere outside
    of the app store, or even from the app store WITHOUT an account.

    You do not like security features. OK.

    Hell, try to re-install any IPA/APK of any version on Android versus iOS? What's impossible to do with iOS is trivial to do on Android in many cases.

    Anyone who parrots Apple propaganda doesn't understand anything about iOS.

    Again: please point to this propaganda Apple is posting.

    Try to customize your home screen, or change the default app for dialing, messaging, app launcher, file manager, assistant, camera, etc.

    Sure. Show how you do it in a video and I will show how on iOS.

    Android lets you set a default dialer, SMS app, launcher, assistant, camera and file manager, while iOS locks every one of those defaults to Apple.

    That is not in the slightest true. I thought you said you use iOS.

    Worse, you can't even DO on iOS half the things that you can do on Android.

    Apparently you cannot make a simple video. :)

    There's a reason I assess anyone who parrots Apple's meaningless (but brilliant) propaganda, doesn't know anything about iOS nor about Android.

    Show the videos. But off you run. 100% predictable.
    --
    It's impossible for someone who is at war with themselves to be at peace with you.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jose' Francisco de Paula Juan Soto@null@nowhere.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone,alt.computer.workshop,alt.fan.rush-limbaugh on Wed Dec 31 03:03:59 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Brock McNuggets <brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com> wrote in news:69548b9a$0$23$882e4bbb@reader.netnews.com:

    On Dec 30, 2025 at 6:49:15rC>PM MST, "Marian" wrote <10j1veq$2oai$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:

    Tyrone wrote:
    The real reason most people use Apple devices is because they are
    simply much easier to actually use. Almost everybody who uses an
    Apple device then does not want to go back to the awful mess of
    Andud or Windoze.

    Very true.

    But it is the combined ecosystem of Apple devices that really makes
    things easy. Phones, tablets, PCs and watches. All running the same
    OS and the same apps and services. All tied together by a single
    cloud service.

    To me, if you have a iPhone then you need an iPad. At that point, if
    you ever need a laptop then a Mac is the obvious choice.

    A Windows (or even worse, Linux) PC from THIS company and an Android
    phone from THAT company and an Android tablet from whoever is just a
    waste of time and energy. I don't need such challenges in my
    personal life. I have no desire to do systems integration for free.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    The problem is all you're doing is parroting baseless Apple
    propaganda.

    Can you point to this propaganda Apple is publishing?

    You don't actually understand iOS, nor Android - you're just a
    parrot.

    I use Android & iOS all day, every day, so I understand them both.

    No evidence you have an iOS device.

    You understand neither.

    Whether iOS or Android is easier depends greatly on what tasks you're
    doing. For example, try moving a downloaded PDF from your email into
    a specific folder and opening it in a non-Apple app. On Android it's
    one step. On iOS it's a scavenger hunt.

    This is similar to the task I compared for macOS. Would love to see
    your Android video showing how you do it. I will then show how I do a
    similar task on iOS. Look forward to your video.

    Likewise after downloading a ZIP file on iOS, opening it, and moving
    one of the files into a specific app's folder, where, on Android it's
    a two-tap action, yet on iOS it turns into a maze of share sheets and
    hidden menus.

    Again, show a video and I will, too. We can both learn.

    What's easier on iOS or Android depends greatly on what you're doing.

    Plug an iPhone and an Android into Windows and tell me which is
    easier for bidirectional file transfers, or try to load an app from
    anywhere outside of the app store, or even from the app store WITHOUT
    an account.

    You do not like security features. OK.

    Hell, try to re-install any IPA/APK of any version on Android versus
    iOS? What's impossible to do with iOS is trivial to do on Android in
    many cases.

    Anyone who parrots Apple propaganda doesn't understand anything about
    iOS.

    Again: please point to this propaganda Apple is posting.

    Try to customize your home screen, or change the default app for
    dialing, messaging, app launcher, file manager, assistant, camera,
    etc.

    Sure. Show how you do it in a video and I will show how on iOS.

    Android lets you set a default dialer, SMS app, launcher, assistant,
    camera and file manager, while iOS locks every one of those defaults
    to Apple.

    That is not in the slightest true. I thought you said you use iOS.

    Worse, you can't even DO on iOS half the things that you can do on
    Android.

    Apparently you cannot make a simple video. :)

    There's a reason I assess anyone who parrots Apple's meaningless (but
    brilliant) propaganda, doesn't know anything about iOS nor about
    Android.

    Show the videos. But off you run. 100% predictable.


    This is a classic example of snit, Brock McNuggets attempting to set up another one of his trolls.
    Do not be fooled.

    If you reply to him it will turn into a shit show food fight because snit
    is not a normal person.
    In case you don't believe it, look here for information regarding the
    snit troll.
    Also be aware that he likes to sock up so watch carefully.

    <https://tinyurl.com/WhatIsSnit>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitliesmethods>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snit-Reviews>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitwhopperlie>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snit-teddybear>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitonduck>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitongoogle>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitdrugabuse1>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitdrugabuse2>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitdrugabuse3>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitdrugabuse4>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitdrugabuse5>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitdrugabuse6>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitdrugabuse7>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitdrugabuse8>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitdrugabuse9>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitdrugabuse10>
    <https://tinyurl.com/Snitdrugabuse11>
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brock McNuggets@brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com to alt.fan.rush-limbaugh,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Wed Dec 31 03:37:45 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Dec 30, 2025 at 8:03:59rC>PM MST, ""Jose' Francisco de Paula Juan Soto"" wrote <6954929f$0$23$882e4bbb@reader.netnews.com>:

    Brock McNuggets <brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com> wrote in news:69548b9a$0$23$882e4bbb@reader.netnews.com:

    On Dec 30, 2025 at 6:49:15rC>PM MST, "Marian" wrote
    <10j1veq$2oai$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:

    Tyrone wrote:
    The real reason most people use Apple devices is because they are
    simply much easier to actually use. Almost everybody who uses an
    Apple device then does not want to go back to the awful mess of
    Andud or Windoze.

    Very true.

    But it is the combined ecosystem of Apple devices that really makes
    things easy. Phones, tablets, PCs and watches. All running the same
    OS and the same apps and services. All tied together by a single
    cloud service.

    To me, if you have a iPhone then you need an iPad. At that point, if
    you ever need a laptop then a Mac is the obvious choice.

    A Windows (or even worse, Linux) PC from THIS company and an Android
    phone from THAT company and an Android tablet from whoever is just a
    waste of time and energy. I don't need such challenges in my
    personal life. I have no desire to do systems integration for free.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    The problem is all you're doing is parroting baseless Apple
    propaganda.

    Can you point to this propaganda Apple is publishing?

    You don't actually understand iOS, nor Android - you're just a
    parrot.

    I use Android & iOS all day, every day, so I understand them both.

    No evidence you have an iOS device.

    You understand neither.

    Whether iOS or Android is easier depends greatly on what tasks you're
    doing. For example, try moving a downloaded PDF from your email into
    a specific folder and opening it in a non-Apple app. On Android it's
    one step. On iOS it's a scavenger hunt.

    This is similar to the task I compared for macOS. Would love to see
    your Android video showing how you do it. I will then show how I do a
    similar task on iOS. Look forward to your video.

    Likewise after downloading a ZIP file on iOS, opening it, and moving
    one of the files into a specific app's folder, where, on Android it's
    a two-tap action, yet on iOS it turns into a maze of share sheets and
    hidden menus.

    Again, show a video and I will, too. We can both learn.

    What's easier on iOS or Android depends greatly on what you're doing.

    Plug an iPhone and an Android into Windows and tell me which is
    easier for bidirectional file transfers, or try to load an app from
    anywhere outside of the app store, or even from the app store WITHOUT
    an account.

    You do not like security features. OK.

    Hell, try to re-install any IPA/APK of any version on Android versus
    iOS? What's impossible to do with iOS is trivial to do on Android in
    many cases.

    Anyone who parrots Apple propaganda doesn't understand anything about
    iOS.

    Again: please point to this propaganda Apple is posting.

    Try to customize your home screen, or change the default app for
    dialing, messaging, app launcher, file manager, assistant, camera,
    etc.

    Sure. Show how you do it in a video and I will show how on iOS.

    Android lets you set a default dialer, SMS app, launcher, assistant,
    camera and file manager, while iOS locks every one of those defaults
    to Apple.

    That is not in the slightest true. I thought you said you use iOS.

    Worse, you can't even DO on iOS half the things that you can do on
    Android.

    Apparently you cannot make a simple video. :)

    There's a reason I assess anyone who parrots Apple's meaningless (but
    brilliant) propaganda, doesn't know anything about iOS nor about
    Android.

    Show the videos. But off you run. 100% predictable.


    This is a classic example of snit,

    Right... asking for evidence and offering my own. Thanks for noticing.
    --
    It's impossible for someone who is at war with themselves to be at peace with you.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jose' Francisco de Paula Juan Soto@null@nowhere.com to alt.fan.rush-limbaugh,comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Wed Dec 31 03:50:34 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Brock McNuggets <brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com> wrote in news:69549a89$0$20$882e4bbb@reader.netnews.com:

    On Dec 30, 2025 at 8:03:59rC>PM MST, ""Jose' Francisco de Paula Juan
    Soto"" wrote <6954929f$0$23$882e4bbb@reader.netnews.com>:

    Brock McNuggets <brock.mcnuggets@gmail.com> wrote in
    news:69548b9a$0$23$882e4bbb@reader.netnews.com:

    On Dec 30, 2025 at 6:49:15rC>PM MST, "Marian" wrote
    <10j1veq$2oai$1@nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>:

    Tyrone wrote:
    The real reason most people use Apple devices is because they are
    simply much easier to actually use. Almost everybody who uses an
    Apple device then does not want to go back to the awful mess of
    Andud or Windoze.

    Very true.

    But it is the combined ecosystem of Apple devices that really
    makes things easy. Phones, tablets, PCs and watches. All running
    the same OS and the same apps and services. All tied together by a
    single cloud service.

    To me, if you have a iPhone then you need an iPad. At that point,
    if you ever need a laptop then a Mac is the obvious choice.

    A Windows (or even worse, Linux) PC from THIS company and an
    Android phone from THAT company and an Android tablet from whoever
    is just a waste of time and energy. I don't need such challenges
    in my personal life. I have no desire to do systems integration
    for free.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    The problem is all you're doing is parroting baseless Apple
    propaganda.

    Can you point to this propaganda Apple is publishing?

    You don't actually understand iOS, nor Android - you're just a
    parrot.

    I use Android & iOS all day, every day, so I understand them both.

    No evidence you have an iOS device.

    You understand neither.

    Whether iOS or Android is easier depends greatly on what tasks
    you're doing. For example, try moving a downloaded PDF from your
    email into a specific folder and opening it in a non-Apple app. On
    Android it's one step. On iOS it's a scavenger hunt.

    This is similar to the task I compared for macOS. Would love to see
    your Android video showing how you do it. I will then show how I do
    a similar task on iOS. Look forward to your video.

    Likewise after downloading a ZIP file on iOS, opening it, and
    moving one of the files into a specific app's folder, where, on
    Android it's a two-tap action, yet on iOS it turns into a maze of
    share sheets and hidden menus.

    Again, show a video and I will, too. We can both learn.

    What's easier on iOS or Android depends greatly on what you're
    doing.

    Plug an iPhone and an Android into Windows and tell me which is
    easier for bidirectional file transfers, or try to load an app from
    anywhere outside of the app store, or even from the app store
    WITHOUT an account.

    You do not like security features. OK.

    Hell, try to re-install any IPA/APK of any version on Android
    versus iOS? What's impossible to do with iOS is trivial to do on
    Android in many cases.

    Anyone who parrots Apple propaganda doesn't understand anything
    about iOS.

    Again: please point to this propaganda Apple is posting.

    Try to customize your home screen, or change the default app for
    dialing, messaging, app launcher, file manager, assistant, camera,
    etc.

    Sure. Show how you do it in a video and I will show how on iOS.

    Android lets you set a default dialer, SMS app, launcher,
    assistant, camera and file manager, while iOS locks every one of
    those defaults to Apple.

    That is not in the slightest true. I thought you said you use iOS.

    Worse, you can't even DO on iOS half the things that you can do on
    Android.

    Apparently you cannot make a simple video. :)

    There's a reason I assess anyone who parrots Apple's meaningless
    (but brilliant) propaganda, doesn't know anything about iOS nor
    about Android.

    Show the videos. But off you run. 100% predictable.


    This is a classic example of snit,

    Right... asking for evidence and offering my own. Thanks for noticing.

    Be gone troll. You are not welcome here. In fact you are not welcome in
    any usenet group. Need evidence?
    https://tinyurl.com/WhatIsSnit
    https://tinyurl.com/Snitliesmethods
    https://tinyurl.com/Snit-Reviews

    And unlike you snit, my evidence backs up my claim that you are a troll.
    A very sick troll.


    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Tyrone@none@none.none to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Wed Dec 31 04:05:59 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Dec 30, 2025 at 9:05:06rC>PM EST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:

    On 2025-12-30 17:49, Marian wrote:
    Tyrone wrote:
    The real reason most people use Apple devices is because they are
    simply much easier to actually use. Almost everybody who uses an Apple >>>> device then does not want to go back to the awful mess of Andud or
    Windoze.

    Very true.
    But it is the combined ecosystem of Apple devices that really makes
    things
    easy. Phones, tablets, PCs and watches. All running the same OS and
    the same
    apps and services. All tied together by a single cloud service.

    To me, if you have a iPhone then you need an iPad. At that point, if
    you ever
    need a laptop then a Mac is the obvious choice.
    A Windows (or even worse, Linux) PC from THIS company and an Android
    phone
    from THAT company and an Android tablet from whoever is just a waste
    of time
    and energy. I don't need such challenges in my personal life. I have
    no desire
    to do systems integration for free.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    The problem is all you're doing is parroting baseless Apple propaganda.
    You don't actually understand iOS, nor Android - you're just a parrot.

    I use Android & iOS all day, every day, so I understand them both.
    You understand neither.

    Whether iOS or Android is easier depends greatly on what tasks you're
    doing. For example, try moving a downloaded PDF from your email into a
    specific folder and opening it in a non-Apple app. On Android it's one
    step. On iOS it's a scavenger hunt.

    Nope. It's one step to save it in a specific folder.


    Likewise after downloading a ZIP file on iOS, opening it, and moving one of >> the files into a specific app's folder, where, on Android it's a two-tap
    action, yet on iOS it turns into a maze of share sheets and hidden menus.

    Is this as accurate a claim as your claim that iOS wouldn't allow an app
    to provide an SMB service on standard Windows ports?

    <snip>

    Yes. Just as accurate.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Tyrone@none@none.none to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Wed Dec 31 04:17:03 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Dec 30, 2025 at 8:49:15rC>PM EST, "Marian" <marianjones@helpfulpeople.com> wrote:

    Plug an iPhone and an Android into Windows and tell me which is easier for bidirectional file transfers.

    This AGAIN? Are you drunk?

    This is the 21st century. You don't NEED to "plug an iPhone into Windows".
    You can do Wi-Fi networking file transfers using the Files app on iOS to connect to the standard Windows networking. Both directions. As you know, I do this all the time.

    AND, you can install an SMB Server on iOS and do wi-fi file transfers THAT
    way, from Windows File Explorer. Both directions. Remember this?
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Dec 30 20:47:49 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2025-12-29 17:19, Alan wrote:

    2. *Operating an iOS device without signing into an Apple ID*
    -a-a It is possible to skip signing into an Apple ID during setup, but the >> -a-a device operates in a limited state. Many system components repeatedly >> -a-a prompt for Apple ID credentials because the OS assumes that an
    Apple ID
    -a-a will eventually be provided.

    This is false.

    I have a freshly set up iPad immediately to the left of me, and I have signed out of the Apple Account (formerly "AppleID"; get the details
    right). I'll see how many prompts I get in the next day and you'll see.

    It's now been more than 24 hours (more than 27 hours, actually) and I
    haven't been asked to sign in by anything.

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marian@marianjones@helpfulpeople.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Wed Dec 31 00:12:25 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Tyrone wrote:
    Plug an iPhone and an Android into Windows and tell me which is easier for >> bidirectional file transfers.

    This AGAIN? Are you drunk?

    This is the 21st century. You don't NEED to "plug an iPhone into Windows". You can do Wi-Fi networking file transfers using the Files app on iOS to connect to the standard Windows networking. Both directions. As you know, I do
    this all the time.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    The issue is not familiarity or knowing any particular sequence of steps.
    It is that the two platforms behave very differently at the protocol level.

    On Windows, an Android phone connects using industry-standard MTP.
    The file system appears in Windows File Explorer every time you plug it in. Using standard protocols, you can browse the entire internal storage, place files anywhere you choose, and retrieve files from anywhere on the device. Transfers work in both directions with no additional software or services.

    Another difference is that Android USB transfers do not require any account association at all. You plug it in and move files. With iOS, the official
    USB workflow through iTunes or Finder requires the same Apple ID on both
    the PC and the iPhone. Without matching accounts, the device will not
    easily sync or easily allow file transfers through that method. This is another example of iOS depending on Apple specific services instead of on industry-standard USB behavior.

    iOS does not provide anything like the Android/PC platform compatibility. Almost none of that industry-standard USB functionality works with iOS.

    Claiming that iOS is "easier" ignores the fact that iOS does not expose its file system over industry-standard USB using industry-standard MTP or industry-standard mass storage protocols. Plug in iOS and Windows can only
    see the DCIM folder, and only for one-way photo transfer. Nothing else on
    the iOS device is accessible. It is not possible to place files anywhere
    you choose on the iOS device or to retrieve files from arbitrary locations when connected over industry-standard USB. iOS does not expose its storage over industry-standard USB in a way that allows full, bidirectional access.

    Any other transfer method, whether through WiFi, iCloud, iTunes or Finder,
    or third party tools, depends on Apple specific services rather than on industry-standard USB file access.

    That is the ease-of-use distinction I am pointing out:
    a. Android supports industry-standard two-way USB file transfer protocols
    b. iOS does not

    Everything you are describing on iOS is a workaround required because Apple refuses to fully support industry-standard USB protocols for full, bidirectional file access when connecting a phone to a Windows PC.

    Android adheres to industry standards when it comes to easy file transfer. Apple does not.

    These are simply the extremely well-known well-described technical
    differences between the platforms, and they are not a matter of opinion.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marian@marianjones@helpfulpeople.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Wed Dec 31 00:38:14 2025
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Tyrone wrote:
    Is this as accurate a claim as your claim that iOS wouldn't allow an app
    to provide an SMB service on standard Windows ports?

    <snip>

    Yes. Just as accurate.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    Since this thread is about the pervasive need to use an Apple ID when
    no mothership ID is needed for almost everything every other OS does,
    and since you brought up SMB, it is worth being clear about what SMB
    actually is and what it is not.

    SMB is a Windows networking protocol. It works over WiFi or Ethernet.
    It is not USB, it is not plug-and-play, and it is not the baseline
    behavior of a phone when you connect it to a PC. SMB requires network configuration on both sides, credentials, and a working LAN. None of
    that is required for industry-standard USB file transfer.

    Yes, iOS can use SMB as a client, and yes, you can run an SMB server
    app on iOS. But that is a network workaround, not native USB
    interoperability.

    It is not automatic (SMB requires manual setup, manual connection, and
    a functioning network; USB does not), it is not guaranteed to be
    available on every network, and it is not something an average user
    would ever expect to set up just to move a file between two devices.

    By contrast, Android does not need WiFi, does not need a LAN, does not
    need credentials, and does not need any third-party apps. You plug it
    in and the entire file system appears. Linux behaves the same way: you
    plug it in and it mounts as a standard USB device with no accounts, no ecosystem, and no workarounds. That is the definition of "easier."

    And just to be clear, the original topic here was the requirement for
    an Apple ID for basic functionality. The "ease of use" angle only
    appeared when people tried to defend that requirement by pointing to
    the Apple ecosystem. But none of those ecosystem arguments change the
    basic fact that iOS needs an Apple ID for things that other platforms
    do without any account at all. SMB, WiFi transfers, and other network workarounds do not alter that point.

    So if the question is whether SMB works: yes, it works.

    If the question is whether SMB is easier than standard USB: no, it is
    not. SMB is a network protocol. USB is a direct connection. They are
    not even in the same category.

    My original point stands unchanged: Android supports industry-standard
    USB file transfer. Linux supports industry-standard USB file transfer.
    iOS does not. Everything else on iOS, including SMB, is a workaround
    layered on top of that limitation.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jolly Roger@jollyroger@pobox.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Thu Jan 1 01:24:16 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2025-12-31, Tyrone <none@none.none> wrote:
    On Dec 30, 2025 at 8:49:15rC>PM EST, "Marian" <marianjones@helpfulpeople.com> wrote:

    Plug an iPhone and an Android into Windows and tell me which is
    easier for bidirectional file transfers.

    This AGAIN? Are you drunk?

    This is the 21st century. You don't NEED to "plug an iPhone into
    Windows". You can do Wi-Fi networking file transfers using the Files
    app on iOS to connect to the standard Windows networking. Both
    directions. As you know, I do this all the time.

    AND, you can install an SMB Server on iOS and do wi-fi file transfers
    THAT way, from Windows File Explorer. Both directions. Remember
    this?

    Of course he remembers. He just wishes the rest of us would forget.
    --
    E-mail sent to this address may be devoured by my ravenous SPAM filter.
    I often ignore posts from Google. Use a real news client instead.

    JR
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Mon Jan 5 22:42:17 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2025-12-29 17:19, Alan wrote:
    On 2025-12-25 13:39, Marian wrote:
    Marian wrote:
    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from
    others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually
    designed.

    To help users on this Apple newsgroup LEARN how iOS actually works,
    and to
    help further the conversation to discuss how iOS actually works, here are
    the unavoidable facts based on long-term testing of iOS devices while
    avoiding manual Apple ID logins & avoiding Apple's cloud ecosystem as
    much
    as possible so that the true nature of the iOS ecosystem was being
    tested.

    1. *Device activation and Apple servers with respect to the AppleID*
    -a-a An iOS device cannot be brought into a usable state without contacting >> -a-a Apple's activation servers. This activation step is mandatory and is
    -a-a separate from creating or signing into an Apple ID.
    -a-a Even if you skip the Apple ID portion, the device must still check
    -a-a in with Apple before setup can complete.

    So that it can be ascertained whether or not the device has been stolen.


    2. *Operating an iOS device without signing into an Apple ID*
    -a-a It is possible to skip signing into an Apple ID during setup, but the >> -a-a device operates in a limited state. Many system components repeatedly >> -a-a prompt for Apple ID credentials because the OS assumes that an
    Apple ID
    -a-a will eventually be provided.

    This is false.

    I have a freshly set up iPad immediately to the left of me, and I have signed out of the Apple Account (formerly "AppleID"; get the details
    right). I'll see how many prompts I get in the next day and you'll see.
    ...and I finally received a prompt!

    There was red badge on the Settings app, and when I opened it, there was
    a suggestion (with no dire warnings at all, mind you!) that I start
    using iCloud, and a few words about the advantages it offers.

    I tapped "Not now" and it's gone!

    :-)
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Tyrone@none@none.none to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Tue Jan 6 14:53:57 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Jan 6, 2026 at 1:42:17 AM EST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:

    On 2025-12-29 17:19, Alan wrote:
    On 2025-12-25 13:39, Marian wrote:
    Marian wrote:
    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from >>>> others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually
    designed.

    To help users on this Apple newsgroup LEARN how iOS actually works,
    and to
    help further the conversation to discuss how iOS actually works, here are >>> the unavoidable facts based on long-term testing of iOS devices while
    avoiding manual Apple ID logins & avoiding Apple's cloud ecosystem as
    much
    as possible so that the true nature of the iOS ecosystem was being
    tested.

    1. *Device activation and Apple servers with respect to the AppleID*
    An iOS device cannot be brought into a usable state without contacting >>> Apple's activation servers. This activation step is mandatory and is
    separate from creating or signing into an Apple ID.
    Even if you skip the Apple ID portion, the device must still check
    in with Apple before setup can complete.

    So that it can be ascertained whether or not the device has been stolen.


    2. *Operating an iOS device without signing into an Apple ID*
    It is possible to skip signing into an Apple ID during setup, but the >>> device operates in a limited state. Many system components repeatedly >>> prompt for Apple ID credentials because the OS assumes that an
    Apple ID
    will eventually be provided.

    This is false.

    I have a freshly set up iPad immediately to the left of me, and I have
    signed out of the Apple Account (formerly "AppleID"; get the details
    right). I'll see how many prompts I get in the next day and you'll see.
    ...and I finally received a prompt!

    There was red badge on the Settings app, and when I opened it, there was
    a suggestion (with no dire warnings at all, mind you!) that I start
    using iCloud, and a few words about the advantages it offers.

    I tapped "Not now" and it's gone!

    :-)

    Wait. So you are saying that Arlen is AGAIN lying?

    I am stunned. My head is spinning. I can't process this. Arlen is SUCH a fountain of info!
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Bobby@Bobby@ggemail.net to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Tue Jan 6 10:08:40 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    In article
    <4KacnTS8QJmYv8D0nZ2dnZfqn_idnZ2d@supernews.com>,
    none@none.none says...

    On Jan 6, 2026 at 1:42:17 AM EST, "Alan" <nuh-uh@nope.com> wrote:

    On 2025-12-29 17:19, Alan wrote:
    On 2025-12-25 13:39, Marian wrote:
    Marian wrote:
    It seems we need a separate thread on teaching others and learning from >>>> others more about the very important topic of how iOS is actually
    designed.

    To help users on this Apple newsgroup LEARN how iOS actually works,
    and to
    help further the conversation to discuss how iOS actually works, here are >>> the unavoidable facts based on long-term testing of iOS devices while
    avoiding manual Apple ID logins & avoiding Apple's cloud ecosystem as
    much
    as possible so that the true nature of the iOS ecosystem was being
    tested.

    1. *Device activation and Apple servers with respect to the AppleID*
    An iOS device cannot be brought into a usable state without contacting >>> Apple's activation servers. This activation step is mandatory and is >>> separate from creating or signing into an Apple ID.
    Even if you skip the Apple ID portion, the device must still check
    in with Apple before setup can complete.

    So that it can be ascertained whether or not the device has been stolen. >>

    2. *Operating an iOS device without signing into an Apple ID*
    It is possible to skip signing into an Apple ID during setup, but the >>> device operates in a limited state. Many system components repeatedly >>> prompt for Apple ID credentials because the OS assumes that an
    Apple ID
    will eventually be provided.

    This is false.

    I have a freshly set up iPad immediately to the left of me, and I have
    signed out of the Apple Account (formerly "AppleID"; get the details
    right). I'll see how many prompts I get in the next day and you'll see.
    ...and I finally received a prompt!

    There was red badge on the Settings app, and when I opened it, there was
    a suggestion (with no dire warnings at all, mind you!) that I start
    using iCloud, and a few words about the advantages it offers.

    I tapped "Not now" and it's gone!

    :-)

    Wait. So you are saying that Arlen is AGAIN lying?

    I am stunned. My head is spinning. I can't process this. Arlen is SUCH a fountain of info!

    Yea, Arlen sure is a fountain of info. The problem is the
    water supply for the fountain comes directly from the
    local sewer system.

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Tue Jan 6 10:10:03 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Tyrone wrote:
    I am stunned. My head is spinning. I can't process this.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    Of course you "can't process this", because you've never tested iOS.
    I have.

    Every day, all day, my iPad asks me to sign in multiple times in a row.
    That's just a fact.

    It's not an opinion.
    It's how iOS works.

    You just don't see it because when it asks, you log in.
    But watch what happens when you do NOT log in.

    Note: You're already logged in. Keep that in mind. You never logged out.
    Yet, over time, Apple requires you to log in again. And again. And again.

    Every iOS device in the world does this, Tyrone.
    You simply log in when it asks you to log in, so you don't remember it.

    But mine constantly asks me all day, every day, to log into my accounts.
    Even though I never logged out.

    Every iOS device in the world would do that too, if you did what I did.
    Which you didn't do.

    Because you're not testing how iOS actually works, Tyrone.
    I am.

    Try this to better understand how iOS actually works:
    1. Initialize your iOS device on Apple's mothership tracking servers.
    2. Then create an Apple Account (Apple ID) on other mothership servers.
    3. Do the normal Apple-specific login steps (iCloud mail, App Store, etc.)

    Then... wait... wait... wait...

    Just wait.
    That's all.

    Wait.

    Watch what happens.
    Only after you do that "can" you begin to understand how iOS works.
    --
    It's not strange that most iOS users never understand how iOS works.
    What's strange is that they deny iOS works the way that iOS works.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From RobbieA@robbier9k@email.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,alt.computer.workshop,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Tue Jan 6 10:20:18 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    In article <10jj8kb$2k90$1
    @nnrp.usenet.blueworldhosting.com>,
    mariasophia@comprehension.com says...

    Tyrone wrote:
    I am stunned. My head is spinning. I can't process this.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    Of course you "can't process this", because you've never tested iOS.
    I have.

    Every day, all day, my iPad asks me to sign in multiple times in a row. That's just a fact.

    It's not an opinion.
    It's how iOS works.

    You just don't see it because when it asks, you log in.
    But watch what happens when you do NOT log in.

    Note: You're already logged in. Keep that in mind. You never logged out.
    Yet, over time, Apple requires you to log in again. And again. And again.

    Every iOS device in the world does this, Tyrone.
    You simply log in when it asks you to log in, so you don't remember it.

    But mine constantly asks me all day, every day, to log into my accounts.
    Even though I never logged out.

    Every iOS device in the world would do that too, if you did what I did.
    Which you didn't do.

    Because you're not testing how iOS actually works, Tyrone.
    I am.

    Try this to better understand how iOS actually works:
    1. Initialize your iOS device on Apple's mothership tracking servers.
    2. Then create an Apple Account (Apple ID) on other mothership servers.
    3. Do the normal Apple-specific login steps (iCloud mail, App Store, etc.)

    Then... wait... wait... wait...

    Just wait.
    That's all.

    Wait.

    Watch what happens.
    Only after you do that "can" you begin to understand how iOS works.

    iOS is total crap. The Apple fan-boys really do believe
    Apple takes care of all security and that they are safe
    and secure in the bosom of their beloved Apple device.
    And the fools pay a premium for that bosom.
    Not that it matters because the majority of Apple fan-boys
    have few if any technical skills which is why they want
    Apple to do everything for them.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Tue Jan 6 10:25:41 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-01-06 07:10, Maria Sophia wrote:
    Tyrone wrote:
    I am stunned. My head is spinning. I can't process this.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    Of course you "can't process this", because you've never tested iOS.
    I have.

    Every day, all day, my iPad asks me to sign in multiple times in a row. That's just a fact.

    And yet to "prove" it, you produce images from nearly 4 years ago...


    It's not an opinion.
    It's how iOS works.

    You just don't see it because when it asks, you log in.
    But watch what happens when you do NOT log in.

    Note: You're already logged in. Keep that in mind. You never logged out.
    Yet, over time, Apple requires you to log in again. And again. And again.

    Every iOS device in the world does this, Tyrone.
    You simply log in when it asks you to log in, so you don't remember it.

    But mine constantly asks me all day, every day, to log into my accounts.
    Even though I never logged out.

    Every iOS device in the world would do that too, if you did what I did.
    Which you didn't do.

    Because you're not testing how iOS actually works, Tyrone.
    I am.

    Try this to better understand how iOS actually works:
    1. Initialize your iOS device on Apple's mothership tracking servers.

    Did that.

    2. Then create an Apple Account (Apple ID) on other mothership servers.

    Did that.

    3. Do the normal Apple-specific login steps (iCloud mail, App Store, etc.)

    Did that.


    Then... wait... wait... wait...

    Just wait.
    That's all.

    Wait.

    Watch what happens.
    Only after you do that "can" you begin to understand how iOS works.

    NOTHING happened.

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Chris@ithinkiam@gmail.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Jan 6 18:29:31 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Tyrone wrote:
    I am stunned. My head is spinning. I can't process this.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    Of course you "can't process this", because you've never tested iOS.
    I have.

    Every day, all day, my iPad asks me to sign in multiple times in a row. That's just a fact.

    It's not an opinion.
    It's how iOS works.

    No it isn't. It's the way iOS works *for you*.

    You just don't see it because when it asks, you log in.
    But watch what happens when you do NOT log in.

    Note: You're already logged in. Keep that in mind. You never logged out.
    Yet, over time, Apple requires you to log in again. And again. And again.

    Nope. Never happens here. Neither ipad nor iphone.

    Every iOS device in the world does this, Tyrone.
    You simply log in when it asks you to log in, so you don't remember it.

    But mine constantly asks me all day, every day, to log into my accounts.
    Even though I never logged out.

    Clearly this is a you problem. Alan just gave an example where his device
    only suggested once in a week.

    Every iOS device in the world would do that too, if you did what I did.
    Which you didn't do.

    Because you're not testing how iOS actually works, Tyrone.
    I am.

    Try this to better understand how iOS actually works:
    1. Initialize your iOS device on Apple's mothership tracking servers.
    2. Then create an Apple Account (Apple ID) on other mothership servers.
    3. Do the normal Apple-specific login steps (iCloud mail, App Store, etc.)

    Then... wait... wait... wait...

    Just wait.
    That's all.

    Wait.

    Watch what happens.
    Only after you do that "can" you begin to understand how iOS works.



    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to misc.phone.mobile.iphone,comp.sys.mac.advocacy on Tue Jan 6 10:40:00 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-01-06 10:29, Chris wrote:
    Maria Sophia <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:
    Tyrone wrote:
    I am stunned. My head is spinning. I can't process this.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    Of course you "can't process this", because you've never tested iOS.
    I have.

    Every day, all day, my iPad asks me to sign in multiple times in a row.
    That's just a fact.

    It's not an opinion.
    It's how iOS works.

    No it isn't. It's the way iOS works *for you*.

    Once...

    ...nearly 4 YEARS ago.


    You just don't see it because when it asks, you log in.
    But watch what happens when you do NOT log in.

    Note: You're already logged in. Keep that in mind. You never logged out.
    Yet, over time, Apple requires you to log in again. And again. And again.

    Nope. Never happens here. Neither ipad nor iphone.

    Correct. It never happens to me either.


    Every iOS device in the world does this, Tyrone.
    You simply log in when it asks you to log in, so you don't remember it.

    But mine constantly asks me all day, every day, to log into my accounts.
    Even though I never logged out.

    Clearly this is a you problem. Alan just gave an example where his device only suggested once in a week.

    Correct.

    I've now restored it to my regular Apple Account, and I'll report the
    first time it asks for me to log in again.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Tyrone@none@none.none to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Tue Jan 6 21:20:19 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On Jan 6, 2026 at 10:10:03rC>AM EST, "Maria Sophia" <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:

    Tyrone wrote:
    I am stunned. My head is spinning. I can't process this.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    Of course you "can't process this", because you've never tested iOS.
    I have.

    That was sarcasm you moron. I don't believe a word you say.

    In fact, no one does.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Alan@nuh-uh@nope.com to comp.sys.mac.advocacy,misc.phone.mobile.iphone on Tue Jan 6 14:42:05 2026
    From Newsgroup: misc.phone.mobile.iphone

    On 2026-01-06 13:20, Tyrone wrote:
    On Jan 6, 2026 at 10:10:03rC>AM EST, "Maria Sophia" <mariasophia@comprehension.com> wrote:

    Tyrone wrote:
    I am stunned. My head is spinning. I can't process this.

    Hi Tyrone,

    Happy New Year!

    Of course you "can't process this", because you've never tested iOS.
    I have.

    That was sarcasm you moron. I don't believe a word you say.

    In fact, no one does.

    He lacks the wit...

    (and is too much of a narcissist)

    ...to see when he's being mocked.

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2