• Re: Discussion of FTP vs WebDav for Android/iOS filesystem sharing on Windows PC

    From Maria Sophia@mariasophia@comprehension.com to alt.comp.os.windows-11,alt.comp.os.windows-10,comp.mobile.android on Tue Feb 10 04:21:34 2026
    From Newsgroup: comp.mobile.android

    Arno Welzel wrote:
    When just using WebDAV to access Android this may not be that relevant,
    but with bigger servers used by many other users as well and not just a smartphone acting like a server, things like these may be an issue.

    Hi Arno,

    I'm one of the few people on Usenet who, not only have a very strong
    opinion based on experience, but my experiences determine whe4ther or not I will *change* that opinion on a dime, if/when new information is produced.

    I've changed my mind on WebDAV.

    Recently I've copied my entire Android file system over to Windows over
    Wi-Fi and I've found that WebDAV in the later Android operating systems is nowhere near as reliable as it was in the earlier Android OS versions.

    I haven't changed a thing in my Android WebDAV setup, and it's not working
    as it was now in this later Android version than it did in prior versions.

    Since I was in a rush to copy over all my Android data to Windows without resorting to the kindergarten-style use of "the cloud", I didn't spend the
    time to debug the various quirks that popped up which I never saw before.

    Suffice to say that "maybe" WebDAV is less reliable than it was in the past
    on Android (but I haven't tested the iOS WebDAV implementation recently).

    I'll withhold judgment as I have more pressing needs to explore, but I will
    let you know ahead of time that I need to re-assess WebDAV in so much as
    its ability to mount the entire visible mobile device filesys on Windows as
    a read/write drive letter.

    More later, as this is a courtesy response based on recent WebDAV
    experiences even as I first tested WebDAV to mount Android onto Windows
    many years ago and found it almost perfect for that use model at the time.

    Thanks for keeping up on this as I never disagree with any logically
    sentient point of view from anyone.
    --
    My analysis always starts with the simplest theory that fits the facts.
    --- Synchronet 3.21b-Linux NewsLink 1.2