• Re: Umpires replaced a 10 overs old duke ball with a 30 overs old ball at Lords test

    From John Hall@john_nospam@jhall.co.uk to uk.sport.cricket on Sun Aug 3 18:56:08 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.sport.cricket

    In message <mf8tokFk2djU1@mid.individual.net>, David North <nospam@lane-farm.fsnet.co.uk> writes
    On 02/08/2025 17:44, FBInCIAnNSATerroristSlayer wrote:
    <snip>
    India asked for a ball change because it WENT out of SHAPE, NOT
    because the ball is soft or not swinging.

    So if they think the ball has gone of out shape, they always ask for it
    be changed, without considering whether changing it is likely to be to
    their advantage? That doesn't sound very clever.


    I've always thought that the ball going out of shape should be to the
    benefit of the fielding side, if that's all that's wrong with it, as
    surely it should make the bounce less predictable.
    --
    John Hall
    "I look upon it, that he who does not mind his belly,
    will hardly mind anything else."
    Dr Samuel Johnson (1709-84)
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From FBInCIAnNSATerroristSlayer@FBInCIAnNSATerroristSlayer@america.com to uk.sport.cricket on Sun Aug 3 21:30:06 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.sport.cricket

    On 8/3/2025 10:15 AM, David North wrote:
    On 03/08/2025 12:40, FBInCIAnNSATerroristSlayer wrote:
    On 8/3/2025 3:59 AM, David North wrote:
    On 02/08/2025 17:44, FBInCIAnNSATerroristSlayer wrote:
    On 8/2/2025 9:33 AM, David North wrote:
    On 31/07/2025 05:20, FBInCIAnNSATerroristSlayer wrote:



    Umpires replaced a 10 overs old ball with a 30 overs old ball at
    Lords test


    https://indianexpress.com/article/sports/cricket/india-vs-
    england-30- over-old-ball-after-10-overs-lords-test-10160065/?
    ref=hometop_hp



    England vs India: Visitors raise red flag after umpires gave 30-
    overs- old replacement ball after 10 overs at LordrCOs

    Changed cherry offered much less assistance to Indian bowlers,
    allowing hosts to build match-changing partnership in a game they >>>>>> won by 22 runs

    IndiarCOs team management is not happy with the ball-change protocol >>>>>> during the ongoing Test series in England and has conveyed its
    concerns to the ICC match referee. The management also believes
    that England got preferential treatment when it came to choosing
    balls at the start of the crucial third Test of the series at
    LordrCOs earlier this month.

    The Indian Express has learnt that during EnglandrCOs first innings >>>>>> at LordrCOs, when the second new ball went out of shape after 10
    overs, the replacement turned out to be 30-35 overs old. The
    protocol states the replacement needs to be as old as the original

    No it doesn't, it says that the replacement ball should have "wear
    comparable with that which the previous ball had received before
    the need for its replacement." That will depend on what has
    happened to the two balls, not just how many overs have been bowled >>>>> with them.



    Sure but common sense dictates that it would be VERY RARE for a
    30-35 overs old ball to have the same wear and tear as a 10 over old
    ball.




    but it is learnt that the umpires told the team there was no ball >>>>>> in stock that was 10 overs old.

    The Indians feel that since they got a softer and older
    replacement for a harder ball, which had been swinging and getting >>>>>> seam movement in the first 10 overs, it put them at a disadvantage >>>>>> in the Test that England eventually won by 22 runs to take a 2-1
    lead in the series. The fourth Test ended in a tense draw with the >>>>>> last match starting on Thursday.

    rCLAt LordrCOs, after about 10 overs, the Dukes ball lost its shape, >>>>>> something that has been happening so often in the series. The ball >>>>>> failed to pass through the rings that the umpires carry on the
    field to check if the ball is uniformly spherical. However, the
    umpires didnrCOt have a ball that was 10 overs old, so the Indian >>>>>> team at a crucial moment of the match got a ball that was 30-35
    overs old,rCY said an Indian team official.

    rCLCheck the scoreboard to see how the game changed after that. The >>>>>> bowlers lost their swing and England scored with ease,rCY the
    official said.

    On getting the much older ball, the Indian team management
    appealed to the match referee to allow them to switch back to the >>>>>> original that had gone out of shape. ThatrCOs when they were shown >>>>>> the rule book.

    rCLWhen you ask for a ball change, you arenrCOt told about the age of >>>>>> the replacement you will be getting.

    Why ask for a replacement if the ball is working for you? (Not
    that's it's up to the bowling side to ask)

    India asked for a ball change because it WENT out of SHAPE, NOT
    because the ball is soft or not swinging.

    So if they think the ball has gone of out shape, they always ask for
    it be changed, without considering whether changing it is likely to
    be to their advantage? That doesn't sound very clever.




    Not always but in this case they asked for a change.

    I think they asked for a change of ball thinking that an approximately
    10 over old ball "in shape" would be better than a 10 over old ball
    "out of shape".

    If the out-of-shape ball "had been swinging and getting seam movement in
    the first 10 overs" (and they had taken 3 for 27 in the last 5.3 overs
    with it), I would have thought the odds were against a replacement
    between better, and the best bet would be to keep quiet and stick with
    what they had. If the original ball subsequently stopped swinging and seaming, they would still be able to ask for a change, whereas if they
    got the ball changed and the replacement wasn't as good, they'd be stuck with it. Of course, if they kept quiet and the umpires checked the ball
    of their own accord at some point, they would have changed it anyway,
    but there was no need to draw their attention to it.



    Yeah, Indian team was kind of dumb to ask for replacement ball at that juncture.


    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2