• Re: =?ISO-8859-1?Q?Network_Rail_admits?==?ISO-8859-1?Q?_=EF=BF=BDsignificant_cha?==?ISO-8859-1?Q?llenges=EF=BF=BD_maintain?==?ISO-8859-1?Q?ing_sliding_canal_b?==?ISO-8859-1?Q?ridge_after_recent_?==?ISO-8859-1?Q?failures?=

    From Nobody@jock@soccer.com to uk.railway,uk.rec.waterways on Sat Jul 5 12:20:48 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.waterways

    On Sat, 5 Jul 2025 18:47:17 +0100, Arthur Figgis
    <afiggis@example.invalid> wrote:
    On 05/07/2025 15:32, Tweed wrote:
    Marland <gemehabal@btinternet.co.uk> wrote:
    John Williamson <johnwilliamson@btinternet.com> wrote:
    On 05/07/2025 08:46, Graeme Wall wrote:
    On 04/07/2025 22:15, Roger wrote:
    Cross posted from uk.rec.waterways to uk.railway

    On 04/07/2025 07:02, Martin Nicholas wrote:
    Latest:
    https://www.newcivilengineer.com/latest/network-rail-admits-significant-challenges-maintaining-sliding-canal-bridge-after-recent-failures-03-07-2025/


    The canal towpath goes over the bridge*, so the structure can be closely >>>>>> examined by walkers.

    * Vazon Sliding Railway Bridge, Keadby, Scunthorpe, on the South
    Humberside
    Main Line over the Stainforth and Keadby Canal.

    Wouldn't the answer be to put a drop lock each side of the bridge to >>>>> drop boats below the level of the tracks, similar to the ones on the >>>>> Forth-Clyde canal at Dalmuir.

    Probably easier and cheaper to operate if they lifted the railway to
    give enough headroom.


    To the full 3m (?)airdraught that was required for the commercial traffic >>> or a compromise that would let reasonable size leisure craft pass. The
    latter would upset those owners of historic craft or those who have
    imported Dutch Barges etc, OTOH. some of those only need 2m with a low or >>> descending wheelhouse so would still allow some reasonably large craft.

    GH


    Nothing a couple of Brusio spirals wouldn’t fix :)


    https://www.amusingplanet.com/2015/02/the-inclined-boat-lifts-of-elblag-canal.html
    Along similar lines (sorry) but never completed: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chignecto_Marine_Transport_Railway>
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From chrisnd @ukrw@chrisnd@privacy.net to uk.rec.waterways,uk.railway on Sun Jul 6 17:51:02 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.waterways

    On 05/07/2025 16:25, Graeme Wall wrote:
    On 05/07/2025 14:07, John Williamson wrote:
    On 05/07/2025 14:03, John Williamson wrote:
    On 05/07/2025 08:46, Graeme Wall wrote:
    On 04/07/2025 22:15, Roger wrote:
    Cross posted from uk.rec.waterways to uk.railway

    On 04/07/2025 07:02, Martin Nicholas wrote:
    Latest:
    https://www.newcivilengineer.com/latest/network-rail-admits-
    significant-challenges-maintaining-sliding-canal-bridge-after-
    recent-failures-03-07-2025/



    The canal towpath goes over the bridge*, so the structure can be
    closely
    examined by walkers.

    * Vazon Sliding Railway Bridge, Keadby, Scunthorpe, on the South
    Humberside
    Main Line over the Stainforth and Keadby Canal.

    Wouldn't the answer be to put a drop lock each side of the bridge to
    drop boats below the level of the tracks, similar to the ones on the
    Forth-Clyde canal at Dalmuir.

    Probably easier and cheaper to operate if they lifted the railway to
    give enough headroom.

    By the way, the dropped locks (or the "Falkirk wheels") would also
    need to be bypassed to allow enough water to flow for the cooling of
    the local power station. The channel is legally required to provide
    enough for for that purpose.


    As it is a wide canal, it's probably possible to keep a level channel to maintain the water supply while still allowing space for a drop-locked
    route for boats to pass under the railway. It is already narrowed to
    reduce the bridge length.

    Or move Keadby Lock about 200 yards westwards?
    At the railway's expense of course!

    Chris
    --
    http://www.Deuchars.co.uk
    Author & Publisher: "A Boaters Guide to BOATING"
    Mixing old and new waterway techniques. ISBN 9780953151202
    Details: http://www.deuchars.co.uk/publication/

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mike Humphrey@mail@michaelhumphrey.me.uk to uk.rec.waterways,uk.railway on Sun Jul 6 22:35:29 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.waterways

    On Sun, 6 Jul 2025 17:51:02 +0100, chrisnd @ukrw wrote:
    On 05/07/2025 16:25, Graeme Wall wrote:
    As it is a wide canal, it's probably possible to keep a level channel
    to maintain the water supply while still allowing space for a
    drop-locked route for boats to pass under the railway. It is already
    narrowed to reduce the bridge length.

    Or move Keadby Lock about 200 yards westwards?
    At the railway's expense of course!

    Not sure that would help. Keadby lock has gates facing both ways, and
    looks to be more about keeping the changes in level in the Trent (which is tidal here) out of the canal than difference in heights. If the lock was
    moved above the railway and the bridge fixed, boats would only be able to
    pass the bridge when the Trent was low.

    Mike
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roland Perry@roland@perry.uk to uk.rec.waterways,uk.railway on Mon Jul 7 07:40:38 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.waterways

    In message <104etnh$2fovn$1@dont-email.me>, at 22:35:29 on Sun, 6 Jul
    2025, Mike Humphrey <mail@michaelhumphrey.me.uk> remarked:
    On Sun, 6 Jul 2025 17:51:02 +0100, chrisnd @ukrw wrote:
    On 05/07/2025 16:25, Graeme Wall wrote:
    As it is a wide canal, it's probably possible to keep a level channel
    to maintain the water supply while still allowing space for a
    drop-locked route for boats to pass under the railway. It is already
    narrowed to reduce the bridge length.

    Or move Keadby Lock about 200 yards westwards?
    At the railway's expense of course!

    Not sure that would help. Keadby lock has gates facing both ways, and
    looks to be more about keeping the changes in level in the Trent (which is >tidal here) out of the canal than difference in heights. If the lock was >moved above the railway and the bridge fixed, boats would only be able to >pass the bridge when the Trent was low.

    You can already only use the lock to the tidal Trent at certain times,
    to co-ordinate with those times Cromwell Lock is also open to traverse
    to/from the non-tidal Thames. It's not recommended to try to moor
    overnight on the tidal section.

    I went through there exactly 50yrs ago (almost to the day). We were
    doing a three-week narrowboat cruise from Shropshire via Nottingham, the Trent, Leeds and the Leeds/Liverpool Canal, to Manchester, the Ship
    Canal and back to Shropshire via Chester. I'll be posting some photos in
    my Facebook group "canal trips 50ys ago" in the next few days.

    To exit the tidal Trent it was necessary to go slightly past the lock entrance, with the tide. Then do a u-turn and FULL SPEED ahead into the
    tide, turning right. Luckily the boat's maximum water speed was slightly greater then the tidal flow, otherwise we'd have ended up in the Humber
    near Hull.

    My concern about closing that route to navigation is that it's the last
    resort to return to the main inland waterways from the north, if there's problems elsewhere. Two years ago we were on the Leeds and Liverpool
    going east (another 50yr anniversary trip) and there were numerous
    closures due to lack of water and maintenance.

    The boat was slightly too big to return to Manchester via the
    Huddersfield Canal, and there were again sporadic stoppages on the
    Rochdale Canal.

    I had to bail out at Wakefield (close to Kirkgate station), having
    originally planned - in the time available - to get at least to Rochdale itself. The remaining crew did eventually get as far as a marina in
    Droylsden, where the boat languished for a couple of months because all onwards routes to the south were blocked. It spent the winter near
    Anderton, and finally made it home to Litchfield in the Spring.
    --
    Roland Perry
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From chrisnd @ukrw@chrisnd@privacy.net to uk.rec.waterways,uk.railway on Mon Jul 7 10:15:43 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.waterways

    On 07/07/2025 07:40, Roland Perry wrote:
    In message <104etnh$2fovn$1@dont-email.me>, at 22:35:29 on Sun, 6 Jul
    2025, Mike Humphrey <mail@michaelhumphrey.me.uk> remarked:
    On Sun, 6 Jul 2025 17:51:02 +0100, chrisnd @ukrw wrote:
    On 05/07/2025 16:25, Graeme Wall wrote:
    As it is a wide canal, it's probably possible to keep a level channel
    to maintain the water supply while still allowing space for a
    drop-locked route for boats to pass under the railway. It is already
    narrowed to reduce the bridge length.

    -a Or move Keadby Lock about 200 yards westwards?
    At the railway's expense of course!

    Not sure that would help. Keadby lock has gates facing both ways, and
    looks to be more about keeping the changes in level in the Trent
    (which is
    tidal here) out of the canal than difference in heights. If the lock was
    moved above the railway and the bridge fixed, boats would only be able to
    pass the bridge when the Trent was low.

    You can already only use the lock to the tidal Trent at certain times,
    to co-ordinate with those times Cromwell Lock is also open to traverse to/from the non-tidal Thames. It's not recommended to try to moor
    overnight on the tidal section.

    I went through there exactly 50yrs ago (almost to the day). We were
    doing a three-week narrowboat cruise from Shropshire via Nottingham, the Trent, Leeds and the Leeds/Liverpool Canal, to Manchester, the Ship
    Canal and back to Shropshire via Chester. I'll be posting some photos in
    my Facebook group "canal trips 50ys ago" in the next few days.

    To exit the tidal Trent it was necessary to go slightly past the lock entrance, with the tide. Then do a u-turn and FULL SPEED ahead into the tide, turning right. Luckily the boat's maximum water speed was slightly greater then the tidal flow, otherwise we'd have ended up in the Humber
    near Hull.

    I am familiar with the tidal Trent - but only as far north as far as Stockwith. However I am aware that entry into Keadby has always been 'tricky'! My comment was therefore partly tongue in cheek but also semi-serious because having, in effect, a long entry to the lock this
    would also present a 'deceleration zone' (akin to Torksey? <G>) for
    those needing to make a speedy approach. On the other hand it might also
    be prone to greater siltation?

    I am not familiar either with the relative heights of the waterways but
    do know that there is considerable rise and fall in the Trent, due not
    only to tides but also flood waters. It just seemed to me easier to
    move a single lock than consider the drop lock that has been suggested.

    At the end of the day however, this is a railway problem - which is
    impacting as a waterways/navigation problem. I am surprised that,
    despite the uniqueness of this railway bridge, the engineering is
    proving so difficult to sort out.* It really isn't rocket science after
    all!

    Chris

    *I suspect that the re-engineering, which seems to have involved large
    amounts of concrete added to existing foundations, has proved to heavy
    for the existing soil structure** below and has sunk as a result. ***

    ** This is little more than peaty fenland as I recall?

    *** ie someone messed up the calculations and is being very careful not
    to admit it?
    --
    https://www.Deuchars.org.uk
    Author & Publisher: "A Boaters Guide to BOATING"
    Mixing old and new waterway techniques. ISBN 9780953151202
    Details: https://www.deuchars.org.uk/publication/

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Roland Perry@roland@perry.uk to uk.rec.waterways,uk.railway on Mon Jul 7 13:44:32 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.waterways

    In message <hppTufRmv2aoFA9D@perry.uk>, at 07:40:38 on Mon, 7 Jul 2025,
    Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> remarked:
    In message <104etnh$2fovn$1@dont-email.me>, at 22:35:29 on Sun, 6 Jul
    2025, Mike Humphrey <mail@michaelhumphrey.me.uk> remarked:
    On Sun, 6 Jul 2025 17:51:02 +0100, chrisnd @ukrw wrote:
    On 05/07/2025 16:25, Graeme Wall wrote:
    As it is a wide canal, it's probably possible to keep a level channel
    to maintain the water supply while still allowing space for a
    drop-locked route for boats to pass under the railway. It is already
    narrowed to reduce the bridge length.

    Or move Keadby Lock about 200 yards westwards?
    At the railway's expense of course!

    Not sure that would help. Keadby lock has gates facing both ways, and
    looks to be more about keeping the changes in level in the Trent (which is >>tidal here) out of the canal than difference in heights. If the lock was >>moved above the railway and the bridge fixed, boats would only be able to >>pass the bridge when the Trent was low.

    You can already only use the lock to the tidal Trent at certain times,
    to co-ordinate with those times Cromwell Lock is also open to traverse >to/from the non-tidal Thames.

    <cough> Trent.

    It's not recommended to try to moor overnight on the tidal section.

    I went through there exactly 50yrs ago (almost to the day). We were
    doing a three-week narrowboat cruise from Shropshire via Nottingham,
    the Trent, Leeds and the Leeds/Liverpool Canal, to Manchester, the Ship >Canal and back to Shropshire via Chester. I'll be posting some photos
    in my Facebook group "canal trips 50ys ago" in the next few days.

    To exit the tidal Trent it was necessary to go slightly past the lock >entrance, with the tide. Then do a u-turn and FULL SPEED ahead into the >tide, turning right. Luckily the boat's maximum water speed was
    slightly greater then the tidal flow, otherwise we'd have ended up in
    the Humber near Hull.

    My concern about closing that route to navigation is that it's the last >resort to return to the main inland waterways from the north, if
    there's problems elsewhere. Two years ago we were on the Leeds and
    Liverpool going east (another 50yr anniversary trip) and there were
    numerous closures due to lack of water and maintenance.

    The boat was slightly too big to return to Manchester via the
    Huddersfield Canal, and there were again sporadic stoppages on the
    Rochdale Canal.

    I had to bail out at Wakefield (close to Kirkgate station), having >originally planned - in the time available - to get at least to
    Rochdale itself. The remaining crew did eventually get as far as a
    marina in Droylsden, where the boat languished for a couple of months >because all onwards routes to the south were blocked. It spent the
    winter near Anderton, and finally made it home to Litchfield in the Spring.
    --
    Roland Perry
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From chrisnd @ukrw@chrisnd@privacy.net to uk.rec.waterways,uk.railway on Mon Jul 7 14:04:44 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.rec.waterways

    On 07/07/2025 13:44, Roland Perry wrote:
    In message <hppTufRmv2aoFA9D@perry.uk>, at 07:40:38 on Mon, 7 Jul 2025, Roland Perry <roland@perry.uk> remarked:
    In message <104etnh$2fovn$1@dont-email.me>, at 22:35:29 on Sun, 6 Jul
    2025, Mike Humphrey <mail@michaelhumphrey.me.uk> remarked:
    On Sun, 6 Jul 2025 17:51:02 +0100, chrisnd @ukrw wrote:
    On 05/07/2025 16:25, Graeme Wall wrote:
    As it is a wide canal, it's probably possible to keep a level channel >>>>> to maintain the water supply while still allowing space for a
    drop-locked route for boats to pass under the railway. It is already >>>>> narrowed to reduce the bridge length.

    -a Or move Keadby Lock about 200 yards westwards?
    At the railway's expense of course!

    Not sure that would help. Keadby lock has gates facing both ways, and
    looks to be more about keeping the changes in level in the Trent
    (which is
    tidal here) out of the canal than difference in heights. If the lock was >>> moved above the railway and the bridge fixed, boats would only be
    able to
    pass the bridge when the Trent was low.

    You can already only use the lock to the tidal Trent at certain times,
    to co-ordinate with those times Cromwell Lock is also open to traverse
    to/from the non-tidal Thames.

    <cough> Trent.


    We know what you meant :-)

    Chris
    --
    https://www.Deuchars.org.uk
    Author & Publisher: "A Boaters Guide to BOATING"
    Mixing old and new waterway techniques. ISBN 9780953151202
    Details: https://www.deuchars.org.uk/publication/

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2