• How was it for you?

    From Nick Odell@nickodell49@yahoo.ca to uk.media.radio.archers on Sun Sep 7 16:47:09 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    Only one of my phones did anything. It sounded the alarm and left the
    test message on my home screen. None of the others did anything.

    2G Voda own brand - legacy SIM - nothing. I didn't expect otherwise.
    But I keep it and use it for 2FA and because I have a legacy deal on
    the SIM for free international calls.

    3G Voda Moto - no SIM - nothing. But Voda have already switched off
    3G. I used to use it only for Skype (remember Skype?) and now just use
    it as a mini tablet on wi-fi

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to
    use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    5G Voda iPhone 12, 5G SIM but set on airplane mode and did nothing.
    Not surprising but surely taking account of phones operating only on
    wi-fi would be a good idea since this is an emergency system, no?

    Nick
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mike McMillan@toodle.pip1@virginmedia.com to uk.media.radio.archers on Sun Sep 7 16:40:14 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    Nick Odell <nickodell49@yahoo.ca> wrote:
    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    Only one of my phones did anything. It sounded the alarm and left the
    test message on my home screen. None of the others did anything.

    2G Voda own brand - legacy SIM - nothing. I didn't expect otherwise.
    But I keep it and use it for 2FA and because I have a legacy deal on
    the SIM for free international calls.

    3G Voda Moto - no SIM - nothing. But Voda have already switched off
    3G. I used to use it only for Skype (remember Skype?) and now just use
    it as a mini tablet on wi-fi

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to
    use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    5G Voda iPhone 12, 5G SIM but set on airplane mode and did nothing.
    Not surprising but surely taking account of phones operating only on
    wi-fi would be a good idea since this is an emergency system, no?

    Nick


    Smarty 4G via my iPhone, noisy alarm and massage on the screen.
    --
    Toodle Pip, Mike McMillan
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Joe Kerr@joe_kerr@cheerful.com to uk.media.radio.archers on Sun Sep 7 17:57:57 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On 07/09/2025 16:47, Nick Odell wrote:
    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    Mine did just what it should. I think it was about 3 minutes late last time.

    Only one of my phones did anything. It sounded the alarm and left the
    test message on my home screen. None of the others did anything.

    2G Voda own brand - legacy SIM - nothing. I didn't expect otherwise.
    But I keep it and use it for 2FA and because I have a legacy deal on
    the SIM for free international calls.

    3G Voda Moto - no SIM - nothing. But Voda have already switched off
    3G. I used to use it only for Skype (remember Skype?) and now just use
    it as a mini tablet on wi-fi

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to
    use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    No SIM. I'm surprised.

    5G Voda iPhone 12, 5G SIM but set on airplane mode and did nothing.
    Not surprising but surely taking account of phones operating only on
    wi-fi would be a good idea since this is an emergency system, no?

    I'm inclined to say no. The number of phones on Wi-Fi is probably very
    small (and surrounded by phones connected to the mobile network). There
    could be quite a few tablets connected. It might work using public
    access points but if connected privately how would it know where you
    are? The internet used to think I was in north Worcestershire (I
    wasn't). Now it often seems to think I'm in Manchester (I'm not) or
    several other locations (I'm almost certainly not). I haven't moved.
    There's an awful lot of other stuff connected wired and wireless too
    that wouldn't be interested, but smart speakers might be.
    Nick
    --
    Ric
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nick Odell@nickodell49@yahoo.ca to uk.media.radio.archers on Sun Sep 7 19:03:43 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On Sun, 7 Sep 2025 17:57:57 +0100, Joe Kerr <joe_kerr@cheerful.com>
    wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 16:47, Nick Odell wrote:
    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    Mine did just what it should. I think it was about 3 minutes late last time.

    Only one of my phones did anything. It sounded the alarm and left the
    test message on my home screen. None of the others did anything.

    2G Voda own brand - legacy SIM - nothing. I didn't expect otherwise.
    But I keep it and use it for 2FA and because I have a legacy deal on
    the SIM for free international calls.

    3G Voda Moto - no SIM - nothing. But Voda have already switched off
    3G. I used to use it only for Skype (remember Skype?) and now just use
    it as a mini tablet on wi-fi

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to
    use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    No SIM. I'm surprised.

    I've always believed one may call the emergency services from a phone
    with no SIM so I would have expected that the Emergency Broadcast
    ought to be able to do the reverse.


    5G Voda iPhone 12, 5G SIM but set on airplane mode and did nothing.
    Not surprising but surely taking account of phones operating only on
    wi-fi would be a good idea since this is an emergency system, no?

    I'm inclined to say no. The number of phones on Wi-Fi is probably very
    small (and surrounded by phones connected to the mobile network). There >could be quite a few tablets connected. It might work using public
    access points but if connected privately how would it know where you
    are? The internet used to think I was in north Worcestershire (I
    wasn't). Now it often seems to think I'm in Manchester (I'm not) or
    several other locations (I'm almost certainly not). I haven't moved.
    There's an awful lot of other stuff connected wired and wireless too
    that wouldn't be interested, but smart speakers might be.

    True. Just to complicate matters, my broadband comes from a mobile
    connection: I have a router with a Smarty/3 data SIM in it and it
    might have been nice if what was broadcast from local phone masts had
    triggered something useful. A bit too much to ask for really, when I'm
    reading reports of people using perfectly normal phones on perfectly
    normal networks who didn't get anything. On the bright side, if there
    is a nuclear emergency I won't spend 4mts worrying about things: the
    first I'll know about it will be when my flesh starts evaporating off
    my bones.

    There's a nice, cheerful thought for a Sunday night!

    Nick
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Sam Plusnet@not@home.com to uk.media.radio.archers on Sun Sep 7 19:29:58 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On 07/09/2025 19:03, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sun, 7 Sep 2025 17:57:57 +0100, Joe Kerr <joe_kerr@cheerful.com>
    wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 16:47, Nick Odell wrote:
    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    Mine did just what it should. I think it was about 3 minutes late last time. >>
    Only one of my phones did anything. It sounded the alarm and left the
    test message on my home screen. None of the others did anything.

    2G Voda own brand - legacy SIM - nothing. I didn't expect otherwise.
    But I keep it and use it for 2FA and because I have a legacy deal on
    the SIM for free international calls.

    3G Voda Moto - no SIM - nothing. But Voda have already switched off
    3G. I used to use it only for Skype (remember Skype?) and now just use
    it as a mini tablet on wi-fi

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to
    use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    No SIM. I'm surprised.

    I've always believed one may call the emergency services from a phone
    with no SIM so I would have expected that the Emergency Broadcast
    ought to be able to do the reverse.


    5G Voda iPhone 12, 5G SIM but set on airplane mode and did nothing.
    Not surprising but surely taking account of phones operating only on
    wi-fi would be a good idea since this is an emergency system, no?

    I'm inclined to say no. The number of phones on Wi-Fi is probably very
    small (and surrounded by phones connected to the mobile network). There
    could be quite a few tablets connected. It might work using public
    access points but if connected privately how would it know where you
    are? The internet used to think I was in north Worcestershire (I
    wasn't). Now it often seems to think I'm in Manchester (I'm not) or
    several other locations (I'm almost certainly not). I haven't moved.
    There's an awful lot of other stuff connected wired and wireless too
    that wouldn't be interested, but smart speakers might be.

    True. Just to complicate matters, my broadband comes from a mobile connection: I have a router with a Smarty/3 data SIM in it and it
    might have been nice if what was broadcast from local phone masts had triggered something useful. A bit too much to ask for really, when I'm reading reports of people using perfectly normal phones on perfectly
    normal networks who didn't get anything. On the bright side, if there
    is a nuclear emergency I won't spend 4mts worrying about things: the
    first I'll know about it will be when my flesh starts evaporating off
    my bones.

    Now there's a weight loss plan that is guaranteed to work!
    No chance of putting the weight back on again later.>
    There's a nice, cheerful thought for a Sunday night!
    --
    Sam Plusnet
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From J. P. Gilliver@G6JPG@255soft.uk to uk.media.radio.archers on Sun Sep 7 21:43:04 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    My Nokia dumbphone (105 I think, 2G I think) did nothing.

    I had thought it would: such simple 'phones are surely likely to be had
    by those for whom such alerts are particularly important.

    Also: the relevant branch of authority put out notes on nextdoor on how
    to turn off the alert, for those victims of domestic abuse who might
    have a hidden emergency 'phone that might be revealed by the alert
    sounding. But they only gave the instructions for iPhone and Android.
    Possibly as a result of my replying that they ought to cover dumbphones
    too, in that such people might have those (I didn't say, but the reasons
    being [a] much longer battery life [b] on the whole smaller), they later included such guidance - but when I tried to follow it on mine, I
    couldn't. (Probably impossible as such 'phones maybe vary widely? At
    least they tried.) But if such 'phones don't sound the alert anyway,
    academic.

    On 2025/9/7 19:29:58, Sam Plusnet wrote:
    On 07/09/2025 19:03, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sun, 7 Sep 2025 17:57:57 +0100, Joe Kerr <joe_kerr@cheerful.com>
    wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 16:47, Nick Odell wrote:
    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    []

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to >>>> use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    No SIM. I'm surprised.

    I've always believed one may call the emergency services from a phone
    with no SIM so I would have expected that the Emergency Broadcast
    ought to be able to do the reverse.

    Ah, but from an engineering point of view, it's a much more difficult
    problem. Calling 999 from a SIMless 'phone means the network (the base stations) suddenly receiving signals from a device they were previously
    unaware of - but they can respond, and triangulate. But having the
    system alert all SIMless 'phones means it has to know of their
    existence. I suppose if they broadcast something on the calling channel,
    so don't _interact_ with 'phones, i. e. the alert is entirely one-way in
    the same way as one over the AM/FM/DAB "network" would be, that could
    work - the system not interacting at all, so it doesn't know how many
    'phones it reached. Yes, that might work.>>>
    5G Voda iPhone 12, 5G SIM but set on airplane mode and did nothing.
    Not surprising but surely taking account of phones operating only on
    wi-fi would be a good idea since this is an emergency system, no?

    I'm inclined to say no. The number of phones on Wi-Fi is probably very
    small (and surrounded by phones connected to the mobile network). There
    could be quite a few tablets connected. It might work using public
    access points but if connected privately how would it know where you

    If it's a truly unidirectional system, it doesn't need to know where you
    are, or even that it reached you: if it can just alert all 'phones in
    the affected area, that would work. I don't know if 'phones are set up
    to receive such "broadcasts" that require no interaction.

    I was thinking it ought to alert landlines too. But (a) that would
    require many sequential calls (b) the POTS is going to be turned off one
    of these years. [Incidentally I've just renewed with PlusNet (albeit at
    a painful 32% increase) _including_ the landline, which surprised me: I
    was under the impression that they weren't including it in any renewals,
    in anticipation of the POTS end.]

    are? The internet used to think I was in north Worcestershire (I
    wasn't). Now it often seems to think I'm in Manchester (I'm not) or
    several other locations (I'm almost certainly not). I haven't moved.
    There's an awful lot of other stuff connected wired and wireless too
    that wouldn't be interested, but smart speakers might be.

    Oh, companies frequently think I'm in a completely different part of the country; I presume that's based on the IP and is where PlusNet is/are.>>
    True. Just to complicate matters, my broadband comes from a mobile
    connection: I have a router with a Smarty/3 data SIM in it and it

    I've occasionally thought of going that way instead of my wired
    connection - it would give me mobile use for the rare occasions I go out
    (and mobile 'phone too [I currently have an emergency PAYG SIM]). When
    I've looked into it in the past, though, it's always been a lot more
    expensive than my home broadband/phone package, and concerns about data
    limit and/or speed problems. However, with the hefty price increase I
    maybe ought to look again, thought the data amount and speed concerns
    would remain.

    might have been nice if what was broadcast from local phone masts had
    triggered something useful. A bit too much to ask for really, when I'm
    reading reports of people using perfectly normal phones on perfectly
    normal networks who didn't get anything. On the bright side, if there
    is a nuclear emergency I won't spend 4mts worrying about things: the
    first I'll know about it will be when my flesh starts evaporating off
    my bones.

    Sadly, Tom Lehrer died recently, but had a song about that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TIoBrob3bjI&t=19 - such a cheerful song! (Written when the world population was under 3 billion!)>
    Now there's a weight loss plan that is guaranteed to work!
    No chance of putting the weight back on again later.>
    There's a nice, cheerful thought for a Sunday night!

    --
    J. P. Gilliver. UMRA: 1960/<1985 MB++G()AL-IS-Ch++(p)Ar@T+H+Sh0!:`)DNAf

    Who were your favourite TV stars or shows when you were a child? Sadly
    they've all been arrested ...
    - Ian Hislop, in Radio Times 28 September-4 October 2013
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nick Odell@nickodell49@yahoo.ca to uk.media.radio.archers on Mon Sep 8 00:01:18 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On Sun, 7 Sep 2025 19:29:58 +0100, Sam Plusnet <not@home.com> wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 19:03, Nick Odell wrote:
    is a nuclear emergency I won't spend 4mts worrying about things: the
    first I'll know about it will be when my flesh starts evaporating off
    my bones.

    Now there's a weight loss plan that is guaranteed to work!
    No chance of putting the weight back on again later.>

    To a fanfare of regal trumpets, he unlocks the cabinet doors and
    withdraws the ceremonial keyboard. It has lain in that dark space,
    unwanted and unloved, for so long that a film of dust has formed over
    the keys. Pulling on his white, cotton gloves he tenderly brushes the instrument with an ostrich-feather duster until it is gleaming again.

    The letters stand proud and clear. There is now no possibility, bad
    eyesight notwithstanding, of mistaking an E for and F, an I for an L
    or finding one has written [;7w instead of plus.

    He massages his finger joints and flexes his knuckles (or was it the
    other way round?) There must be no mistakes so he does it again until
    his fingers are sure and supple and will be obedient to his will.

    He is holding his breath as if the slightest tremor could throw the
    whole plan into disarray. He has only one chance. One opportunity to
    do what he must do. He poises over the keys and he types...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    BTN




    Nick
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Mike McMillan@toodle.pip1@virginmedia.com to uk.media.radio.archers on Mon Sep 8 08:02:00 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    Sam Plusnet <not@home.com> wrote:
    On 07/09/2025 19:03, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sun, 7 Sep 2025 17:57:57 +0100, Joe Kerr <joe_kerr@cheerful.com>
    wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 16:47, Nick Odell wrote:
    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    Mine did just what it should. I think it was about 3 minutes late last time.

    Only one of my phones did anything. It sounded the alarm and left the
    test message on my home screen. None of the others did anything.

    2G Voda own brand - legacy SIM - nothing. I didn't expect otherwise.
    But I keep it and use it for 2FA and because I have a legacy deal on
    the SIM for free international calls.

    3G Voda Moto - no SIM - nothing. But Voda have already switched off
    3G. I used to use it only for Skype (remember Skype?) and now just use >>>> it as a mini tablet on wi-fi

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to >>>> use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    No SIM. I'm surprised.

    I've always believed one may call the emergency services from a phone
    with no SIM so I would have expected that the Emergency Broadcast
    ought to be able to do the reverse.


    5G Voda iPhone 12, 5G SIM but set on airplane mode and did nothing.
    Not surprising but surely taking account of phones operating only on
    wi-fi would be a good idea since this is an emergency system, no?

    I'm inclined to say no. The number of phones on Wi-Fi is probably very
    small (and surrounded by phones connected to the mobile network). There
    could be quite a few tablets connected. It might work using public
    access points but if connected privately how would it know where you
    are? The internet used to think I was in north Worcestershire (I
    wasn't). Now it often seems to think I'm in Manchester (I'm not) or
    several other locations (I'm almost certainly not). I haven't moved.
    There's an awful lot of other stuff connected wired and wireless too
    that wouldn't be interested, but smart speakers might be.

    True. Just to complicate matters, my broadband comes from a mobile
    connection: I have a router with a Smarty/3 data SIM in it and it
    might have been nice if what was broadcast from local phone masts had
    triggered something useful. A bit too much to ask for really, when I'm
    reading reports of people using perfectly normal phones on perfectly
    normal networks who didn't get anything. On the bright side, if there
    is a nuclear emergency I won't spend 4mts worrying about things: the
    first I'll know about it will be when my flesh starts evaporating off
    my bones.

    Now there's a weight loss plan that is guaranteed to work!
    No chance of putting the weight back on again later.>
    There's a nice, cheerful thought for a Sunday night!


    This weight loss technique has a name: New Clear.
    --
    Toodle Pip, Mike McMillan
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jenny M Benson@NemoNews@hotmail.co.uk to uk.media.radio.archers on Mon Sep 8 10:26:47 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On 08/09/2025 00:01, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sun, 7 Sep 2025 19:29:58 +0100, Sam Plusnet <not@home.com> wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 19:03, Nick Odell wrote:
    is a nuclear emergency I won't spend 4mts worrying about things: the
    first I'll know about it will be when my flesh starts evaporating off
    my bones.

    Now there's a weight loss plan that is guaranteed to work!
    No chance of putting the weight back on again later.>

    To a fanfare of regal trumpets, he unlocks the cabinet doors and
    withdraws the ceremonial keyboard. It has lain in that dark space,
    unwanted and unloved, for so long that a film of dust has formed over
    the keys. Pulling on his white, cotton gloves he tenderly brushes the instrument with an ostrich-feather duster until it is gleaming again.

    The letters stand proud and clear. There is now no possibility, bad
    eyesight notwithstanding, of mistaking an E for and F, an I for an L
    or finding one has written [;7w instead of plus.

    He massages his finger joints and flexes his knuckles (or was it the
    other way round?) There must be no mistakes so he does it again until
    his fingers are sure and supple and will be obedient to his will.

    He is holding his breath as if the slightest tremor could throw the
    whole plan into disarray. He has only one chance. One opportunity to
    do what he must do. He poises over the keys and he types...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    BTN

    Hurrah!
    --
    Jenny M Benson
    Wrexham, UK
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Jane Vernon@jane@clothandclay.co.uk to uk.media.radio.archers on Mon Sep 8 10:41:52 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On 08/09/2025 00:01, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sun, 7 Sep 2025 19:29:58 +0100, Sam Plusnet <not@home.com> wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 19:03, Nick Odell wrote:
    is a nuclear emergency I won't spend 4mts worrying about things: the
    first I'll know about it will be when my flesh starts evaporating off
    my bones.

    Now there's a weight loss plan that is guaranteed to work!
    No chance of putting the weight back on again later.>

    To a fanfare of regal trumpets, he unlocks the cabinet doors and
    withdraws the ceremonial keyboard. It has lain in that dark space,
    unwanted and unloved, for so long that a film of dust has formed over
    the keys. Pulling on his white, cotton gloves he tenderly brushes the instrument with an ostrich-feather duster until it is gleaming again.

    The letters stand proud and clear. There is now no possibility, bad
    eyesight notwithstanding, of mistaking an E for and F, an I for an L
    or finding one has written [;7w instead of plus.

    He massages his finger joints and flexes his knuckles (or was it the
    other way round?) There must be no mistakes so he does it again until
    his fingers are sure and supple and will be obedient to his will.

    He is holding his breath as if the slightest tremor could throw the
    whole plan into disarray. He has only one chance. One opportunity to
    do what he must do. He poises over the keys and he types...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    BTN




    Nick

    Nearly missed that! Only the second one this year. Weak, but accepted.
    --
    Jane
    The Amethyst Artist
    BTM

    http://www.clothandclay.co.uk/umra/cookbook.htm - Umrats' recipes






    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Joe Kerr@joe_kerr@cheerful.com to uk.media.radio.archers on Mon Sep 8 13:43:47 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On 07/09/2025 19:03, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sun, 7 Sep 2025 17:57:57 +0100, Joe Kerr <joe_kerr@cheerful.com>
    wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 16:47, Nick Odell wrote:
    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    Mine did just what it should. I think it was about 3 minutes late last time. >>
    Only one of my phones did anything. It sounded the alarm and left the
    test message on my home screen. None of the others did anything.

    2G Voda own brand - legacy SIM - nothing. I didn't expect otherwise.
    But I keep it and use it for 2FA and because I have a legacy deal on
    the SIM for free international calls.

    3G Voda Moto - no SIM - nothing. But Voda have already switched off
    3G. I used to use it only for Skype (remember Skype?) and now just use
    it as a mini tablet on wi-fi

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to
    use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    No SIM. I'm surprised.

    I've always believed one may call the emergency services from a phone
    with no SIM so I would have expected that the Emergency Broadcast
    ought to be able to do the reverse.

    I had forgotten about that. And hadn't thought of the reverse scenario.


    5G Voda iPhone 12, 5G SIM but set on airplane mode and did nothing.
    Not surprising but surely taking account of phones operating only on
    wi-fi would be a good idea since this is an emergency system, no?

    I'm inclined to say no. The number of phones on Wi-Fi is probably very
    small (and surrounded by phones connected to the mobile network). There
    could be quite a few tablets connected. It might work using public
    access points but if connected privately how would it know where you
    are? The internet used to think I was in north Worcestershire (I
    wasn't). Now it often seems to think I'm in Manchester (I'm not) or
    several other locations (I'm almost certainly not). I haven't moved.
    There's an awful lot of other stuff connected wired and wireless too
    that wouldn't be interested, but smart speakers might be.

    True. Just to complicate matters, my broadband comes from a mobile connection: I have a router with a Smarty/3 data SIM in it and it
    might have been nice if what was broadcast from local phone masts had triggered something useful. A bit too much to ask for really, when I'm reading reports of people using perfectly normal phones on perfectly
    normal networks who didn't get anything. On the bright side, if there
    is a nuclear emergency I won't spend 4mts worrying about things: the
    first I'll know about it will be when my flesh starts evaporating off
    my bones.

    Having given it a little more thought I realised that the internet
    doesn't need to know where you are, only your ISP, and they probably
    have a better, but still vague, idea of your location. I also remembered
    your set-up and see no reason in theory why it couldn't work provided
    your router has a screen and appropriate software.Having it forward an
    alert to a connected device could be awkward and the number of people
    without a suitable phone who are sitting next to a Wi-Fi router at the relevant time is probably likely to be too few to make it worth the
    effort of making it work.
    There's a nice, cheerful thought for a Sunday night!

    Nick
    --
    Ric
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Joe Kerr@joe_kerr@cheerful.com to uk.media.radio.archers on Mon Sep 8 13:49:53 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On 08/09/2025 00:01, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sun, 7 Sep 2025 19:29:58 +0100, Sam Plusnet <not@home.com> wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 19:03, Nick Odell wrote:
    is a nuclear emergency I won't spend 4mts worrying about things: the
    first I'll know about it will be when my flesh starts evaporating off
    my bones.

    Now there's a weight loss plan that is guaranteed to work!
    No chance of putting the weight back on again later.>

    To a fanfare of regal trumpets, he unlocks the cabinet doors and
    withdraws the ceremonial keyboard. It has lain in that dark space,
    unwanted and unloved, for so long that a film of dust has formed over
    the keys. Pulling on his white, cotton gloves he tenderly brushes the instrument with an ostrich-feather duster until it is gleaming again.

    The letters stand proud and clear. There is now no possibility, bad
    eyesight notwithstanding, of mistaking an E for and F, an I for an L
    or finding one has written [;7w instead of plus.

    He massages his finger joints and flexes his knuckles (or was it the
    other way round?) There must be no mistakes so he does it again until
    his fingers are sure and supple and will be obedient to his will.

    He is holding his breath as if the slightest tremor could throw the
    whole plan into disarray. He has only one chance. One opportunity to
    do what he must do. He poises over the keys and he types...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    BTN




    Nick

    After that build up I was expecting at least a bit of Bach in some post-apocalyptic setting.
    --
    Ric
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Sam Plusnet@not@home.com to uk.media.radio.archers on Mon Sep 8 20:26:13 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On 08/09/2025 13:49, Joe Kerr wrote:
    On 08/09/2025 00:01, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sun, 7 Sep 2025 19:29:58 +0100, Sam Plusnet <not@home.com> wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 19:03, Nick Odell wrote:
    is a nuclear emergency I won't spend 4mts worrying about things: the
    first I'll know about it will be when my flesh starts evaporating off
    my bones.

    Now there's a weight loss plan that is guaranteed to work!
    No chance of putting the weight back on again later.>

    To a fanfare of regal trumpets, he unlocks the cabinet doors and
    withdraws the ceremonial keyboard. It has lain in that dark space,
    unwanted and unloved, for so long that a film of dust has formed over
    the keys. Pulling on his white, cotton gloves he tenderly brushes the
    instrument with an ostrich-feather duster until it is gleaming again.

    The letters stand proud and clear. There is now no possibility, bad
    eyesight notwithstanding, of mistaking an E for and F, an I for an L
    or finding one has written [;7w instead of plus.

    He massages his finger joints and flexes his knuckles (or was it the
    other way round?) There must be no mistakes so he does it again until
    his fingers are sure and supple and will be obedient to his will.

    He is holding his breath as if the slightest tremor could throw the
    whole plan into disarray. He has only one chance. One opportunity to
    do what he must do. He poises over the keys and he types...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    ...

    BTN




    Nick

    After that build up I was expecting at least a bit of Bach in some post- apocalyptic setting.

    Someone the Welsh would call Die Bach?
    --
    Sam Plusnet
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From BrritSki@rtilbury@gmail.com to uk.media.radio.archers on Wed Sep 10 10:54:06 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On 07/09/2025 16:47, Nick Odell wrote:
    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    Only one of my phones did anything. It sounded the alarm and left the
    test message on my home screen. None of the others did anything.

    2G Voda own brand - legacy SIM - nothing. I didn't expect otherwise.
    But I keep it and use it for 2FA and because I have a legacy deal on
    the SIM for free international calls.

    3G Voda Moto - no SIM - nothing. But Voda have already switched off
    3G. I used to use it only for Skype (remember Skype?) and now just use
    it as a mini tablet on wi-fi

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to
    use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    5G Voda iPhone 12, 5G SIM but set on airplane mode and did nothing.
    Not surprising but surely taking account of phones operating only on
    wi-fi would be a good idea since this is an emergency system, no?


    Hmmm, why do you need so many burners ? EMNTK

    Or are you in an abusive relationship ;)
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From BrritSki@rtilbury@gmail.com to uk.media.radio.archers on Wed Sep 10 11:03:47 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On 07/09/2025 19:03, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sun, 7 Sep 2025 17:57:57 +0100, Joe Kerr <joe_kerr@cheerful.com>
    wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 16:47, Nick Odell wrote:
    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    Mine did just what it should. I think it was about 3 minutes late last time. >>
    Only one of my phones did anything. It sounded the alarm and left the
    test message on my home screen. None of the others did anything.

    2G Voda own brand - legacy SIM - nothing. I didn't expect otherwise.
    But I keep it and use it for 2FA and because I have a legacy deal on
    the SIM for free international calls.

    3G Voda Moto - no SIM - nothing. But Voda have already switched off
    3G. I used to use it only for Skype (remember Skype?) and now just use
    it as a mini tablet on wi-fi

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to
    use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    No SIM. I'm surprised.

    I've always believed one may call the emergency services from a phone
    with no SIM so I would have expected that the Emergency Broadcast
    ought to be able to do the reverse.


    Exactly right.

    I remember having a conversation in the pub many years ago (so long ago
    that the only mobile I'd seen was the one that belonged to the office
    that we could borrow if we went anywhere by car - it was too big and
    heavy to carry otherwise) with our very smart network engineers.

    They pooh-poohed my suggestion that the brick could be tracked, but as I pointed out, if they didn't know where you were, how could they contact
    you ? Even with the small number of phones in use back then it was
    impractical for every mast to broadcast a signal when someone called you...

    Some very smart people can be very dim. cf Climate Change.


    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Sam Plusnet@not@home.com to uk.media.radio.archers on Wed Sep 10 18:46:16 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On 10/09/2025 10:54, BrritSki wrote:
    On 07/09/2025 16:47, Nick Odell wrote:
    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    Only one of my phones did anything. It sounded the alarm and left the
    test message on my home screen. None of the others did anything.

    2G Voda own brand - legacy SIM - nothing. I didn't expect otherwise.
    But I keep it and use it for 2FA and because I have a legacy deal on
    the SIM for free international calls.

    3G Voda Moto - no SIM - nothing. But Voda have already switched off
    3G. I used to use it only for Skype (remember Skype?) and now just use
    it as a mini tablet on wi-fi

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to
    use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    5G Voda iPhone 12, 5G SIM but set on airplane mode and did nothing.
    Not surprising but surely taking account of phones operating only on
    wi-fi would be a good idea since this is an emergency system, no?


    Hmmm, why do you need so many burners ?-a-a EMNTK

    Or are you in an abusive relationship ;)

    Why are such phones named after the inventor of the World Wide Web?
    There must be a story there.
    --
    Sam Plusnet
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nick Odell@nickodell49@yahoo.ca to uk.media.radio.archers on Wed Sep 10 19:46:18 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On Wed, 10 Sep 2025 10:54:06 +0100, BrritSki <rtilbury@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 16:47, Nick Odell wrote:
    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    Only one of my phones did anything. It sounded the alarm and left the
    test message on my home screen. None of the others did anything.

    2G Voda own brand - legacy SIM - nothing. I didn't expect otherwise.
    But I keep it and use it for 2FA and because I have a legacy deal on
    the SIM for free international calls.

    3G Voda Moto - no SIM - nothing. But Voda have already switched off
    3G. I used to use it only for Skype (remember Skype?) and now just use
    it as a mini tablet on wi-fi

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to
    use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    5G Voda iPhone 12, 5G SIM but set on airplane mode and did nothing.
    Not surprising but surely taking account of phones operating only on
    wi-fi would be a good idea since this is an emergency system, no?


    Hmmm, why do you need so many burners ? EMNTK

    The answer is so boring that you might well fall asleep before you
    reach the end of the post. Made all the more likely if you are still
    tired after your jaunt to Italy.

    1)The 2G phone uses the 2G PAYG SIM that came with my first ever
    mobile phone and the legacy PAYG package is cheaper than the current
    offer so I keep on using it as long as I can. Plus, I get a legacy
    offer of free international minutes every time I top up. Plus all my
    2FAs are using that number and it would be a faff to change them all
    if I don't have to.

    2)I bought the 3G phone to use exclusively as a Skype handset because
    I was by then making a lot of Skype calls and it was cheaper to buy
    that Moto than buy a proper Skype handset. It's never had a SIM
    fitted. Now that Skype has gone (see 4 below) I continue to use it
    just as a micro-tablet on wi-fi

    3)I bought the 4G handset because I knew that one day I would have to
    abandon the 2G phone when the 2G signal is inevitably switched off
    eventually. But I never got around to doing anything with it because
    Skype got switched off before 2G and I put the 4G SIM in phone no. 4)
    instead.

    4)After Skype was switched off, I was loaned a 5G iPhone so that I can
    continue my regular Skype calls using FaceTime as an alternative and I
    have put the SIM from the 4G phone in that phone, instead.

    It's my understanding that SIMs for 4G and 5G work on a different
    voltage and further, that they need to contain different and/or more information than the simple 2G SIM so I have never tried to cur down
    the old 2G SIM to use with the newer phones. Anyway I don't want to
    risk damaging it while the prices and the promo keep working.

    Are you asleep yet?

    Or are you in an abusive relationship ;)
    ;-)

    Nick
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From BrritSki@rtilbury@gmail.com to uk.media.radio.archers on Wed Sep 10 20:15:27 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On 10/09/2025 19:46, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Wed, 10 Sep 2025 10:54:06 +0100, BrritSki <rtilbury@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 16:47, Nick Odell wrote:
    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    Only one of my phones did anything. It sounded the alarm and left the
    test message on my home screen. None of the others did anything.

    2G Voda own brand - legacy SIM - nothing. I didn't expect otherwise.
    But I keep it and use it for 2FA and because I have a legacy deal on
    the SIM for free international calls.

    3G Voda Moto - no SIM - nothing. But Voda have already switched off
    3G. I used to use it only for Skype (remember Skype?) and now just use
    it as a mini tablet on wi-fi

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to
    use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    5G Voda iPhone 12, 5G SIM but set on airplane mode and did nothing.
    Not surprising but surely taking account of phones operating only on
    wi-fi would be a good idea since this is an emergency system, no?


    Hmmm, why do you need so many burners ? EMNTK

    The answer is so boring that you might well fall asleep before you
    reach the end of the post. Made all the more likely if you are still
    tired after your jaunt to Italy.

    1)The 2G phone uses the 2G PAYG SIM that came with my first ever
    mobile phone and the legacy PAYG package is cheaper than the current
    offer so I keep on using it as long as I can. Plus, I get a legacy
    offer of free international minutes every time I top up. Plus all my
    2FAs are using that number and it would be a faff to change them all
    if I don't have to.

    2)I bought the 3G phone to use exclusively as a Skype handset because
    I was by then making a lot of Skype calls and it was cheaper to buy
    that Moto than buy a proper Skype handset. It's never had a SIM
    fitted. Now that Skype has gone (see 4 below) I continue to use it
    just as a micro-tablet on wi-fi

    Zzzzzzzzzz


    3)I bought the 4G handset because I knew that one day I would have to
    abandon the 2G phone when the 2G signal is inevitably switched off eventually. But I never got around to doing anything with it because
    Skype got switched off before 2G and I put the 4G SIM in phone no. 4) instead.

    4)After Skype was switched off, I was loaned a 5G iPhone so that I can continue my regular Skype calls using FaceTime as an alternative and I
    have put the SIM from the 4G phone in that phone, instead.

    It's my understanding that SIMs for 4G and 5G work on a different
    voltage and further, that they need to contain different and/or more information than the simple 2G SIM so I have never tried to cur down
    the old 2G SIM to use with the newer phones. Anyway I don't want to
    risk damaging it while the prices and the promo keep working.

    Are you asleep yet?

    Did somebody say something ?
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Nick Odell@nickodell49@yahoo.ca to uk.media.radio.archers on Wed Sep 10 22:41:51 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.media.radio.archers

    On Wed, 10 Sep 2025 20:15:27 +0100, BrritSki <rtilbury@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    On 10/09/2025 19:46, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Wed, 10 Sep 2025 10:54:06 +0100, BrritSki <rtilbury@gmail.com>
    wrote:

    On 07/09/2025 16:47, Nick Odell wrote:
    The Emergency Alert test at 15.00 today?

    Only one of my phones did anything. It sounded the alarm and left the
    test message on my home screen. None of the others did anything.

    2G Voda own brand - legacy SIM - nothing. I didn't expect otherwise.
    But I keep it and use it for 2FA and because I have a legacy deal on
    the SIM for free international calls.

    3G Voda Moto - no SIM - nothing. But Voda have already switched off
    3G. I used to use it only for Skype (remember Skype?) and now just use >>>> it as a mini tablet on wi-fi

    4G Voda Nokia - no SIM - yet it squawked and messaged as it should.
    But I only switched it on for the test out of curiosity. I've never
    used this Nokia because when Skype skipped, I was loaned the iPhone to >>>> use for FaceTime and put the Nokia SIM card in the iPhone instead.

    5G Voda iPhone 12, 5G SIM but set on airplane mode and did nothing.
    Not surprising but surely taking account of phones operating only on
    wi-fi would be a good idea since this is an emergency system, no?


    Hmmm, why do you need so many burners ? EMNTK

    The answer is so boring that you might well fall asleep before you
    reach the end of the post. Made all the more likely if you are still
    tired after your jaunt to Italy.

    1)The 2G phone uses the 2G PAYG SIM that came with my first ever
    mobile phone and the legacy PAYG package is cheaper than the current
    offer so I keep on using it as long as I can. Plus, I get a legacy
    offer of free international minutes every time I top up. Plus all my
    2FAs are using that number and it would be a faff to change them all
    if I don't have to.

    2)I bought the 3G phone to use exclusively as a Skype handset because
    I was by then making a lot of Skype calls and it was cheaper to buy
    that Moto than buy a proper Skype handset. It's never had a SIM
    fitted. Now that Skype has gone (see 4 below) I continue to use it
    just as a micro-tablet on wi-fi

    Zzzzzzzzzz


    3)I bought the 4G handset because I knew that one day I would have to
    abandon the 2G phone when the 2G signal is inevitably switched off
    eventually. But I never got around to doing anything with it because
    Skype got switched off before 2G and I put the 4G SIM in phone no. 4)
    instead.

    4)After Skype was switched off, I was loaned a 5G iPhone so that I can
    continue my regular Skype calls using FaceTime as an alternative and I
    have put the SIM from the 4G phone in that phone, instead.

    It's my understanding that SIMs for 4G and 5G work on a different
    voltage and further, that they need to contain different and/or more
    information than the simple 2G SIM so I have never tried to cur down
    the old 2G SIM to use with the newer phones. Anyway I don't want to
    risk damaging it while the prices and the promo keep working.

    Are you asleep yet?

    Did somebody say something ?

    :o)

    N.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2