Sysop: | Amessyroom |
---|---|
Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
Users: | 27 |
Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
Uptime: | 43:10:00 |
Calls: | 631 |
Calls today: | 2 |
Files: | 1,187 |
D/L today: |
24 files (29,813K bytes) |
Messages: | 175,377 |
I live in a mid-terrace house on a bend in the road. What's that got
to do with anything? Well, the back wall is noticeably wider than the
front wall and none of the walls are actually square in the corners. Consequently, the shower tray fits snugly into its corner but with one
side right up against its wall and the other with a gap behind which
ranges from zero to about 15mm. With the tile overhang that narrows to
about 7mm at the far edge. Water resistance previously came from the
shower base trim which covered over that gap.
Only it's not water resistant any more. I think the grout between the
tiles has become porous too.
I've stripped out everything except the tiles which seem well fixed
and in good condition. I'm in the process of regrouting them now.
The quadrant shower enclosure (now stripped out) was obviously
installed by a cowboy (probably the previous homeowner) who obviously
felt that there was nothing some extra sealant couldn't cure - except
it obviously wasn't curing the way one quadrant enclosure upright
overhung the back of the shower tray and had a tendency to drip water
into the gap between the tray and the wall.
cement, leveled off so that it becomes an extension of the shower tray profile and water running down inside the upright will run into tray
as it ought to. Good idea? Bad idea?
Should I seal the surface of the cement in any way or will its natural
water resistance be enough? I plan to seal the gap between the tiles
and the tray with quadrant beading sealed with silicone so the only
exposed cement will be behind the upright.
How could I do this better?
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated. Why not use a waterproof expanding polyurethane foam? Many examples here: <https://www.amazon.co.uk/waterproof-expanding-foam/s?k=waterproof+expanding+foam>
My plan is to fill the wedge-shaped void behind the shower tray with
cement, leveled off so that it becomes an extension of the shower tray profile and water running down inside the upright will run into tray
as it ought to. Good idea? Bad idea?
Should I seal the surface of the cement in any way or will its natural
water resistance be enough?
I plan to seal the gap between the tiles
and the tray with quadrant beading sealed with silicone so the only
exposed cement will be behind the upright.
How could I do this better?
Jeff Layman <Jeff@invalid.invalid> wrote:
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated. Why not use a waterproof expanding polyurethane foam? Many examples here: <https://www.amazon.co.uk/waterproof-expanding-foam/s?k=waterproof+expanding+foam>
For the record, most expanding foams are open cell and allow moisture through. Many of the search results on that term aren't actually waterproof (some are 'weatherproof' - not sure what that means but likely not
serious quantities of spray), so check your results carefully.
I recently ordered a can of this (at -u15 a can, not what they're currently charging): https://www.solseal.co.uk/building-products/foams-and-ancillaries/sika-boom-405-water-stop-expanding-foam-320ml/
which is a closed cell foam specifically designed for waterproofing. I haven't used it yet.
Jeff Layman <Jeff@invalid.invalid> wrote:
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated. Why not use a
waterproof expanding polyurethane foam? Many examples here:
<https://www.amazon.co.uk/waterproof-expanding-foam/s?k=waterproof+expanding+foam>
For the record, most expanding foams are open cell and allow moisture through. Many of the search results on that term aren't actually waterproof (some are 'weatherproof' - not sure what that means but likely not
serious quantities of spray), so check your results carefully.
I recently ordered a can of this (at -u15 a can, not what they're currently charging): https://www.solseal.co.uk/building-products/foams-and-ancillaries/sika-boom-405-water-stop-expanding-foam-320ml/
which is a closed cell foam specifically designed for waterproofing. I haven't used it yet.
Theo
Theo <theom+news@chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote:
Jeff Layman <Jeff@invalid.invalid> wrote:
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated. Why not use a
waterproof expanding polyurethane foam? Many examples here:
<https://www.amazon.co.uk/waterproof-expanding-foam/s?k=waterproof+expanding+foam>
For the record, most expanding foams are open cell and allow moisture
through. Many of the search results on that term aren't actually waterproof >> (some are 'weatherproof' - not sure what that means but likely not
serious quantities of spray), so check your results carefully.
I recently ordered a can of this (at -u15 a can, not what they're currently >> charging):
https://www.solseal.co.uk/building-products/foams-and-ancillaries/sika-boom-405-water-stop-expanding-foam-320ml/
which is a closed cell foam specifically designed for waterproofing. I
haven't used it yet.
A test of water absorption of various spray foams, conclusions inconclusive but the closed cell pond foam worked out a bit better: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P0vcxtCDYTs
On 02/10/2025 10:45, Theo wrote:
Jeff Layman <Jeff@invalid.invalid> wrote:
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated. Why not use a
waterproof expanding polyurethane foam? Many examples here:
<https://www.amazon.co.uk/waterproof-expanding-foam/s?k=waterproof+expanding+foam>
For the record, most expanding foams are open cell and allow moisture through. Many of the search results on that term aren't actually waterproof
(some are 'weatherproof' - not sure what that means but likely not
serious quantities of spray), so check your results carefully.
I recently ordered a can of this (at -u15 a can, not what they're currently charging): https://www.solseal.co.uk/building-products/foams-and-ancillaries/sika-boom-405-water-stop-expanding-foam-320ml/
which is a closed cell foam specifically designed for waterproofing. I haven't used it yet.
Theo
Even if what you say is true, a shower enclosure is no worse than e.g. a window cill in the rain etc.
But I think most foam is closed cell, or it wouldn't expand, would it?
But I think most foam is closed cell, or it wouldn't expand, would it?
On 02/10/2025 11:49, The Natural Philosopher wrote:
But I think most foam is closed cell, or it wouldn't expand, would it?
The stuff that your local energy advisor wanted to spray on your roof to replace the old style fibreglass loft insulation, and then make it impossible to get home insurance, was probably open cell.
Should I seal the surface of the cement in any way or will its natural
water resistance be enough? I plan to seal the gap between the tiles
and the tray with quadrant beading sealed with silicone so the only
exposed cement will be behind the upright.
How could I do this better?
For you final sealant consider CT1-a (toolstaion etc.)
alan_m wrote:
For you final sealant consider CT1-a (toolstaion etc.)
I've used it and it is impressive stuff, but they used to market it as
"the only sealant you'll ever need" but now they seem to be marketing
half a dozen different sealants for different jobs ...
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
alan_m wrote:
For you final sealant consider CT1-a (toolstaion etc.)
I've used it and it is impressive stuff, but they used to market it as "the only sealant you'll ever need" but now they seem to be marketing
half a dozen different sealants for different jobs ...
They market it as 'even works under water', but when did you ever need to apply sealant under water?
Theo wrote:While something is wet sure. But IIRC they showed it sticking two
They market it as 'even works under water', but when did you ever need to
apply sealant under water?
Quite often if you're tying to stop a window leaking for example.
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated.
On 02/10/2025 08:08, Jeff Layman wrote:
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated.
I have never tried it myself, so I am just throwing the idea out here
for others to comment on:
Would mixing PVA into the cement make it waterproof permanently after drying?
On 02/10/2025 08:08, Jeff Layman wrote:
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated.
I have never tried it myself, so I am just throwing the idea out here
for others to comment on:
Would mixing PVA into the cement make it waterproof permanently after
drying?
On 3 Oct 2025 at 10:05:14 BST, Indy Jess John wrote:
On 02/10/2025 08:08, Jeff Layman wrote:
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated.
I have never tried it myself, so I am just throwing the idea out here
for others to comment on:
Would mixing PVA into the cement make it waterproof permanently after
drying?
Not sure, but I'd guess it wasn't necessary for the construction of concrete ships. Just a strong concrete mix I'd have thought, 3 sand:1 concrete or some such.
On 02/10/2025 07:28, Nick Odell wrote:
Should I seal the surface of the cement in any way or will its natural
water resistance be enough? I plan to seal the gap between the tiles
and the tray with quadrant beading sealed with silicone so the only
exposed cement will be behind the upright.
How could I do this better?
For you final sealant consider CT1 (toolstaion etc.)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fd8Mqe18cAU
Andy Burns <usenet@andyburns.uk> wrote:
alan_m wrote:
For you final sealant consider CT1a (toolstaion etc.)
I've used it and it is impressive stuff, but they used to market it as
"the only sealant you'll ever need" but now they seem to be marketing
half a dozen different sealants for different jobs ...
They market it as 'even works under water', but when did you ever need to >apply sealant under water?
SF have a clone called OB1:
https://www.screwfix.com/brand/ob1
that seems to do the same things and is cheaper.
On 3 Oct 2025 at 10:05:14 BST, Indy Jess John wrote:
On 02/10/2025 08:08, Jeff Layman wrote:
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated.
I have never tried it myself, so I am just throwing the idea out here
for others to comment on:
Would mixing PVA into the cement make it waterproof permanently after
drying?
Not sure, but I'd guess it wasn't necessary for the construction of concrete >ships. Just a strong concrete mix I'd have thought, 3 sand:1 concrete or some >such.
alan_m wrote:I had a block paved driveway installed by a semi-cowboy outfit, the
For you final sealant consider CT1
That looks seriously interesting stuff. Way more expensive than
anything else I've ever used before but probably well worth it.
On 03/10/2025 10:05, Indy Jess John wrote:
On 02/10/2025 08:08, Jeff Layman wrote:I have found it waterproof if enough cement is used to fill the gaps
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated.
I have never tried it myself, so I am just throwing the idea out here
for others to comment on:
Would mixing PVA into the cement make it waterproof permanently after
drying?
between the sand. I am sure other things would work as well, possibly at
a cheaper price.
The "even works under water" claim never did Milliput any harm. Er...
has anybody actually seen any Milliput recently?
On Fri, 3 Oct 2025 10:08:38 +0100, The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 03/10/2025 10:05, Indy Jess John wrote:I've just bought a fresh 5kg bag of sand and cement mortar mix for
On 02/10/2025 08:08, Jeff Layman wrote:I have found it waterproof if enough cement is used to fill the gaps
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated.
I have never tried it myself, so I am just throwing the idea out here
for others to comment on:
Would mixing PVA into the cement make it waterproof permanently after
drying?
between the sand. I am sure other things would work as well, possibly at
a cheaper price.
another job. I have no idea what the sand/cement ratio is because the manufacturer's (Tarmac brand from B&Q) data doesn't tell me. Is that
likely to be suitable for this job too?
On 04/10/2025 17:38, Nick Odell wrote:
On Fri, 3 Oct 2025 10:08:38 +0100, The Natural Philosopher
<tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:
On 03/10/2025 10:05, Indy Jess John wrote:I've just bought a fresh 5kg bag of sand and cement mortar mix for
On 02/10/2025 08:08, Jeff Layman wrote:I have found it waterproof if enough cement is used to fill the gaps
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated.
I have never tried it myself, so I am just throwing the idea out here
for others to comment on:
Would mixing PVA into the cement make it waterproof permanently after
drying?
between the sand. I am sure other things would work as well, possibly at >>> a cheaper price.
another job. I have no idea what the sand/cement ratio is because the
manufacturer's (Tarmac brand from B&Q) data doesn't tell me. Is that
likely to be suitable for this job too?
If a bricklaying mortar mix it will be relatively weak. At least 4 parts >sand to 1 part cement but possibly 5 to 6 parts sand.
On Fri, 3 Oct 2025 10:08:38 +0100, The Natural Philosopher <tnp@invalid.invalid> wrote:No. It will be a much weaker mix
On 03/10/2025 10:05, Indy Jess John wrote:I've just bought a fresh 5kg bag of sand and cement mortar mix for
On 02/10/2025 08:08, Jeff Layman wrote:I have found it waterproof if enough cement is used to fill the gaps
Concrete is not waterproof unless specifically treated.
I have never tried it myself, so I am just throwing the idea out here
for others to comment on:
Would mixing PVA into the cement make it waterproof permanently after
drying?
between the sand. I am sure other things would work as well, possibly at
a cheaper price.
another job. I have no idea what the sand/cement ratio is because the manufacturer's (Tarmac brand from B&Q) data doesn't tell me. Is that
likely to be suitable for this job too?
Niok