• Re: Van DAB radio question

    From Nick Odell@nickodell49@yahoo.ca to uk.d-i-y on Sun Aug 24 12:38:59 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.d-i-y

    On Sat, 23 Aug 2025 18:47:39 +0100, ARW
    <adamwadsworth@blueyonder.co.uk> wrote:

    A follow on from the car DAB question.


    The van also has DAB reception problems. Granted the van does have some
    sort of rubber ariel - however with the ladder and pipe rack around it
    then it probably does not work as well as it should.

    But why does plugging in a phone/tablet/USB chargeable touch etc into to
    the USB port kill the DAB signal in weak signal areas?


    Sorry, sorry, sorry...

    ...but every time I see this subject title I think the content is
    going to be about post-impressionist Dutch painting.

    Sorry.


    Nick
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Natural Philosopher@tnp@invalid.invalid to uk.d-i-y on Sun Aug 24 13:10:36 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.d-i-y

    On 24/08/2025 12:38, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sat, 23 Aug 2025 18:47:39 +0100, ARW
    <adamwadsworth@blueyonder.co.uk> wrote:

    A follow on from the car DAB question.


    The van also has DAB reception problems. Granted the van does have some
    sort of rubber ariel - however with the ladder and pipe rack around it
    then it probably does not work as well as it should.

    But why does plugging in a phone/tablet/USB chargeable touch etc into to
    the USB port kill the DAB signal in weak signal areas?


    Sorry, sorry, sorry...

    ...but every time I see this subject title I think the content is
    going to be about post-impressionist Dutch painting.

    Sorry.


    Nick
    +1
    --
    "A point of view can be a dangerous luxury when substituted for insight
    and understanding".

    Marshall McLuhan


    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From ARW@adamwadsworth@blueyonder.co.uk to uk.d-i-y on Sun Aug 24 15:09:24 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.d-i-y

    On 23/08/2025 19:38, Fredxx wrote:
    On 23/08/2025 18:47, ARW wrote:
    A follow on from the car DAB question.


    The van also has DAB reception problems. Granted the van does have
    some sort of rubber ariel - however with the ladder and pipe rack
    around it then it probably does not work as well as it should.

    But why does plugging in a phone/tablet/USB chargeable touch etc into
    to the USB port kill the DAB signal in weak signal areas?

    DAB uses the old band III TV spectrum, 174-230MHz. USB High-Speed uses a transmission rate of 480Mb/s and must produce a lot of random noise according to the data and encoding.

    The other aspect of DAB is that performance with signal strength is not progressive like FM radio. As the signal strength falls of there will be
    a near brick wall where the error rate is such the data cannot be
    recovered.

    What's the FM performance like when the phone is plugged in?

    That also suffers. but not as badly.

    Can you check to see if the phone can charge USB with USB coms turned
    off and just accept standard charging?

    Would that mean I don't have access to Google maps on the dash? I'll
    have a mess when I get the van back.

    Use an alternative cigarette lighter charger?


    I do. But it's not one I can reach when driving. That still causes some problems but no where as bad as the dedicated USB port on the dash.


    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brian@noinv@lid.org to uk.d-i-y on Sun Aug 24 15:10:50 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.d-i-y

    ARW <adamwadsworth@blueyonder.co.uk> wrote:
    A follow on from the car DAB question.


    The van also has DAB reception problems. Granted the van does have some
    sort of rubber ariel - however with the ladder and pipe rack around it
    then it probably does not work as well as it should.

    But why does plugging in a phone/tablet/USB chargeable touch etc into to
    the USB port kill the DAB signal in weak signal areas?




    It isnrCOt a Ducato by any chance, specifically a X250 or 290?

    I ask as, some of these originally have the radio antenna in one of the
    door mirrors ( I think the driverrCOs one). Besides not being the best of antennas, it isnrCOt unknown for mirrors to be replaced for ones without the antenna and another antenna added. Typically, the mirrors off Boxers donrCOt have antennas and Boxers have an antenna on the roof, above the windscreen.
    Ducatos often have a blanking plug here as they use the same body shell.


    I understand the correct antenna has a powered amplifier but IrCOm not 100% sure.

    Antenna problems are common on some Ducato based motorhomes. The companies
    buy in rCyspecialrCO basic base vehicles and add inferior antennas.

    IrCOm on my third Ducato based MH. The first one had a terrible antenna.
    Second was fine. Current one, bought in March, has a door mirror one, and
    is fine.


    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Brian@noinv@lid.org to uk.d-i-y on Sun Aug 24 15:29:20 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.d-i-y

    Brian <noinv@lid.org> wrote:
    ARW <adamwadsworth@blueyonder.co.uk> wrote:
    A follow on from the car DAB question.


    The van also has DAB reception problems. Granted the van does have some
    sort of rubber ariel - however with the ladder and pipe rack around it
    then it probably does not work as well as it should.

    But why does plugging in a phone/tablet/USB chargeable touch etc into to
    the USB port kill the DAB signal in weak signal areas?




    It isnrCOt a Ducato by any chance, specifically a X250 or 290?

    I ask as, some of these originally have the radio antenna in one of the
    door mirrors ( I think the driverrCOs one). Besides not being the best of antennas, it isnrCOt unknown for mirrors to be replaced for ones without the antenna and another antenna added. Typically, the mirrors off Boxers donrCOt have antennas and Boxers have an antenna on the roof, above the windscreen.
    Ducatos often have a blanking plug here as they use the same body shell.


    I understand the correct antenna has a powered amplifier but IrCOm not 100% sure.

    Antenna problems are common on some Ducato based motorhomes. The companies buy in rCyspecialrCO basic base vehicles and add inferior antennas.

    IrCOm on my third Ducato based MH. The first one had a terrible antenna. Second was fine. Current one, bought in March, has a door mirror one, and
    is fine.




    If it is a Ducato and you conclude you have the rCywrongrCO mirror, be aware the mirror also includes a temperature sensor. This is more than for a dashboard display, it is used by the ECU etc. A bad or missing one causes
    all kinds of issues. It is a little rCybumprCO under the driverrCOs mirror, about 10mm in dia if that.

    There are after market mirrors available, including with all the right
    bits, but there are numerous versions ( heated, unheated, remote, manual,
    with/ without antenna, two types ( at least) of indicator, rCarCa. Plus, length short, med, long arms.

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Fredxx@fredxx@spam.invalid to uk.d-i-y on Sun Aug 24 16:51:00 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.d-i-y

    On 24/08/2025 15:09, ARW wrote:
    On 23/08/2025 19:38, Fredxx wrote:
    On 23/08/2025 18:47, ARW wrote:
    A follow on from the car DAB question.


    The van also has DAB reception problems. Granted the van does have
    some sort of rubber ariel - however with the ladder and pipe rack
    around it then it probably does not work as well as it should.

    But why does plugging in a phone/tablet/USB chargeable touch etc into
    to the USB port kill the DAB signal in weak signal areas?

    DAB uses the old band III TV spectrum, 174-230MHz. USB High-Speed uses
    a transmission rate of 480Mb/s and must produce a lot of random noise
    according to the data and encoding.

    The other aspect of DAB is that performance with signal strength is
    not progressive like FM radio. As the signal strength falls of there
    will be a near brick wall where the error rate is such the data cannot
    be recovered.

    What's the FM performance like when the phone is plugged in?

    That also suffers. but not as badly.

    Can you check to see if the phone can charge USB with USB coms turned
    off and just accept standard charging?

    Would that mean I don't have access to Google maps on the dash? I'll
    have a mess when I get the van back.

    Use an alternative cigarette lighter charger?


    I do. But it's not one I can reach when driving. That still causes some problems but no where as bad as the dedicated USB port on the dash.

    Most radio stations have an online presence where you can stream the
    channel. I use BBC Sounds and stream to my radio, though mine is a
    little outdated and go the Bluetooth route.


    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From wasbit@wasbit@REMOVEhotmail.com to uk.d-i-y on Mon Aug 25 10:03:18 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.d-i-y

    On 24/08/2025 12:38, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sat, 23 Aug 2025 18:47:39 +0100, ARW
    <adamwadsworth@blueyonder.co.uk> wrote:

    A follow on from the car DAB question.


    The van also has DAB reception problems. Granted the van does have some
    sort of rubber ariel - however with the ladder and pipe rack around it
    then it probably does not work as well as it should.

    But why does plugging in a phone/tablet/USB chargeable touch etc into to
    the USB port kill the DAB signal in weak signal areas?


    Sorry, sorry, sorry...

    ...but every time I see this subject title I think the content is
    going to be about post-impressionist Dutch painting.

    Sorry.

    Van Gogh Family Tree

    The Family Tree of Vincent Van Gogh
    (Gogh pronounced go not goff)

    His dizzy aunt ................................ Verti Gogh
    The brother who ate prunes .................... Gotta Gogh
    The brother who worked at a convenience store . Stop N Gogh
    The grandfather from Yugoslavia ............... U Gogh
    His magician uncle ............................ Where-diddy Gogh
    His Mexican cousin ............................ A Mee Gogh
    The Mexican cousin's American half-brother .... Gring Gogh
    The nephew who drove a stage coach ............ Wells-far Gogh
    The constipated uncle ......................... Can't Gogh
    The ballroom dancing aunt ..................... Tang Gogh
    The bird lover uncle .......................... Flamin Gogh
    The fruit-loving cousin ....................... Man Gogh
    An aunt who taught positive thinking .......... Way-to-Gogh
    The little bouncy nephew ...................... Po Gogh
    A sister who loved disco ...................... Go Gogh
    The niece who travels the country in an RV .... Winnie Bay Gogh

    The uncle who dominates every party ........... Big E Gogh
    The cousin who studies maths .................. Al Gogh Rythm
    The future administrator ...................... Mun Gogh
    The musical nephew ............................ Bon Gogh
    The sister who never married .................. Vir Gogh

    I saw you smiling . . . there ya Gogh!
    --
    Regards
    wasbit
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Indy Jess John@bathwatchdog@OMITTHISgooglemail.com to uk.d-i-y on Mon Aug 25 13:49:56 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.d-i-y

    On 25/08/2025 10:03, wasbit wrote:
    On 24/08/2025 12:38, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sat, 23 Aug 2025 18:47:39 +0100, ARW
    <adamwadsworth@blueyonder.co.uk> wrote:

    A follow on from the car DAB question.


    The van also has DAB reception problems. Granted the van does have some
    sort of rubber ariel - however with the ladder and pipe rack around it
    then it probably does not work as well as it should.

    But why does plugging in a phone/tablet/USB chargeable touch etc into to >>> the USB port kill the DAB signal in weak signal areas?


    Sorry, sorry, sorry...

    ...but every time I see this subject title I think the content is
    going to be about post-impressionist Dutch painting.

    Sorry.

    Van Gogh Family Tree

    The Family Tree of Vincent Van Gogh
    -a(Gogh pronounced go not goff)

    His dizzy aunt ................................ Verti Gogh
    The brother who ate prunes .................... Gotta Gogh
    The brother who worked at a convenience store . Stop N Gogh
    The grandfather from Yugoslavia ............... U Gogh
    His magician uncle ............................ Where-diddy Gogh
    His Mexican cousin ............................ A Mee Gogh
    The Mexican cousin's American half-brother .... Gring Gogh
    The nephew who drove a stage coach ............ Wells-far Gogh
    The constipated uncle ......................... Can't Gogh
    The ballroom dancing aunt ..................... Tang Gogh
    The bird lover uncle .......................... Flamin Gogh
    The fruit-loving cousin ....................... Man Gogh
    An aunt who taught positive thinking .......... Way-to-Gogh
    The little bouncy nephew ...................... Po Gogh
    A sister who loved disco ...................... Go Gogh
    The niece who travels the country in an RV .... Winnie Bay Gogh

    The uncle who dominates every party ........... Big E Gogh
    The cousin who studies maths .................. Al Gogh Rythm
    The future administrator ...................... Mun Gogh
    The musical nephew ............................ Bon Gogh
    The sister who never married .................. Vir Gogh

    I saw you smiling . . . there ya Gogh!


    Don't forget his mum, Ma gogh

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Sam Plusnet@not@home.com to uk.d-i-y on Mon Aug 25 18:38:39 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.d-i-y

    On 25/08/2025 10:03, wasbit wrote:
    On 24/08/2025 12:38, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sat, 23 Aug 2025 18:47:39 +0100, ARW
    <adamwadsworth@blueyonder.co.uk> wrote:

    A follow on from the car DAB question.


    The van also has DAB reception problems. Granted the van does have some
    sort of rubber ariel - however with the ladder and pipe rack around it
    then it probably does not work as well as it should.

    But why does plugging in a phone/tablet/USB chargeable touch etc into to >>> the USB port kill the DAB signal in weak signal areas?


    Sorry, sorry, sorry...

    ...but every time I see this subject title I think the content is
    going to be about post-impressionist Dutch painting.

    Sorry.

    Van Gogh Family Tree

    The Family Tree of Vincent Van Gogh
    -a(Gogh pronounced go not goff)

    Not being French, his name wasn't pronounced like that - but still...
    --
    Sam Plusnet
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From The Natural Philosopher@tnp@invalid.invalid to uk.d-i-y on Tue Aug 26 10:24:56 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.d-i-y

    On 25/08/2025 18:38, Sam Plusnet wrote:
    On 25/08/2025 10:03, wasbit wrote:
    On 24/08/2025 12:38, Nick Odell wrote:
    On Sat, 23 Aug 2025 18:47:39 +0100, ARW
    <adamwadsworth@blueyonder.co.uk> wrote:

    A follow on from the car DAB question.


    The van also has DAB reception problems. Granted the van does have some >>>> sort of rubber ariel - however with the ladder and pipe rack around it >>>> then it probably does not work as well as it should.

    But why does plugging in a phone/tablet/USB chargeable touch etc
    into to
    the USB port kill the DAB signal in weak signal areas?


    Sorry, sorry, sorry...

    ...but every time I see this subject title I think the content is
    going to be about post-impressionist Dutch painting.

    Sorry.

    Van Gogh Family Tree

    The Family Tree of Vincent Van Gogh
    -a-a(Gogh pronounced go not goff)

    Not being French, his name wasn't pronounced like that - but still...

    isn't it a sort of clearing of the throat 'hoough'

    "The most accurate pronunciation for Van Gogh, according to Dutch
    speakers, is "vahn KHOKH" with a guttural "kh" sound at the end. "
    --
    All political activity makes complete sense once the proposition that
    all government is basically a self-legalising protection racket, is
    fully understood.


    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Paul@nospam@needed.invalid to uk.d-i-y on Wed Aug 27 17:16:19 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.d-i-y

    On Sat, 8/23/2025 1:47 PM, ARW wrote:
    A follow on from the car DAB question.


    The van also has DAB reception problems. Granted the van does have some sort of rubber ariel - however with the ladder and pipe rack around it then it probably does not work as well as it should.

    But why does plugging in a phone/tablet/USB chargeable touch etc into to the USB port kill the DAB signal in weak signal areas?

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_radio_in_the_United_Kingdom

    I'm surprised a Google, brings up no experimental results at
    all for DAB reception. (Try plugging in "gray hoverman" as a search
    term and see just how much experimenter activity can show up in a
    Google, for comparison.)

    It's almost like no one uses it, and we know that isn't true. We have
    people saying "it's just as good as FM" while it runs on a multiplex at 32kbit/sec :-/

    So as an experimenter, I would start with:

    1) TV rabbit ears, 300:75 ohm balun (rough match, not the best but
    may be in your junk box). This is a *directional* antenna, but our
    objective here is to see what happens when the vehicle ground
    is made less of a factor. You could test with a vehicle in the
    picture, in the driveway (rest rabbit ears on a potential resting
    point, see whether any USB activity inside the van, upsets the signal).
    Extending or shortening the telescoping rabbit ears, allows optimizing
    for frequency (a shortened rabbit ears will pick up a bit of UHF signal).
    Just as my bow-tie antenna for television, picks up both bands. ~200MHz
    reception, is rather hard to suppress. A lump of coal will pick up 200MHz.

    2) Battery powered DAB receiver with a 50 ohm input. This is to be used
    as an antenna evaluation unit, where the receiver is isolated from
    chassis ground. You will need to make a back to back connector adapter,
    using two connectors from each ecosystem. This is just a picture from the Wiki
    of a Roberts portable receiver (may not have the connector required for antenna
    input).

    https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/1/15/Portable_radio_receiving_DAB%2B_transmission_in_UK.jpg/500px-Portable_radio_receiving_DAB%2B_transmission_in_UK.jpg

    If this unit has Bluetooth output, so much the better, as the
    equipment in the van might already have a Bluetooth (input) capability.
    Bluetooth is at 2.4GHz and has poor infrastructure penetration. But it works
    with a Bluetooth speaker for example.

    Your current antenna (rubber duck) is an omnidirectional, but is an unbalanced antenna
    and uses chassis ground as the ground plane for reception.

    They make a "balanced T" for vehicle mount, but a "balanced T" and a
    TV rabbit ears, while not using the van as a ground plane, they are
    directional antennas, which means the radio station is going to
    wink out, every time you go round a turn in the road. I'm not even sure
    the balanced T available, is for the right frequency range, as the elements look
    too short for VHF high. (The arms of the T have adhesive for sticking to glass.)

    You can combine the output of antennas. In the case of DAB, they make
    it sound like the receiver can distinguish and suppress multipath.

    But as long as there is so little info of a technical nature in Google,
    who knows what a "proper" solution looks like. DAB is like witchcraft.

    Somehow you have to get the chassis metals, out of the equation.
    A different antenna type might do it. But the directionality requirement,
    makes most antenna types non-starters. A YAGI would give excellent gain,
    but at the expense of "only working once in a while" as you drive.
    You could put a YAGI on a computer controlled rotator, that maintains
    a particular compass point as you drive, for an example of how that could be fixed.
    But a mount on the top of a van, that's going to be a significant mechanical load on the antenna (wind resistance).

    Good luck, Mr.Science :-) Think of the Nobel Prize for Peace you could win.

    https://cdn.images.express.co.uk/img/dynamic/36/590x/back-to-the-future-theory-doc-brown-1239160.jpg?r=1581067400671

    There are licensed radio amateurs in this group. They could quote you a
    Slim Jim or a J Pole. They know more antenna types. I'm looking for an antenna, to start, that just picks up a signal, without the noise.

    Paul
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From tony sayer@tony@bancom.co.uk to uk.d-i-y on Sun Aug 31 14:17:21 2025
    From Newsgroup: uk.d-i-y

    Just a bit of bit reduction!..

    But a mount on the top of a van, that's going to be a significant mechanical >load on the antenna (wind resistance).

    Good luck, Mr.Science :-) Think of the Nobel Prize for Peace you could win.

    https://cdn.images.express.co.uk/img/dynamic/36/590x/back-to-the-future-theory-
    doc-brown-1239160.jpg?r=1581067400671

    There are licensed radio amateurs in this group. They could quote you a
    Slim Jim or a J Pole. They know more antenna types. I'm looking for an antenna,
    to start, that just picks up a signal, without the noise.

    Paul

    A car roof is a very good reception environment consider that its not
    indoors! also the quarter wave whip on a ground plane is a pretty decent
    and practical receive aerial. OK in Adams case the van aerial surrounded
    by ladders and the like won't help much as will aerials inbuilt into the
    glass rear window but that is almost al that you can do in practice. A
    radio ham can or will have a much longer aerial that covers more than
    the one band but for most all users thats not practical as is a Yagi
    array!.

    There is or was a BBC white paper WHP-195 comes to mind that was mainly
    the effect of small power line IP LAN links that can upset DAB radio.

    Its a bit insidious DAB in that with FM you can usually hear
    interference but that just causes "bubbling mud" and dropout/s on DAB.

    However the BBC and the main commercial multiples are now well
    established as regards coverage but even so that may be areas where insufficient signal does cause reception issues and sometimes they might
    add in a small filler station if its really unusable.

    I am involved in some small scale DAB MUX's using the AAC HE coder or
    DAB Plus, pretty good results can be obtained at 40 K/Bits for general
    radio use.

    As to the DAB-v-FM debate i was talking the service dept of a very well
    known Hi-fi firm they get a glut of FM tuners in for repair before the
    BBC Prom concert season starts, the owners much prefer the sound of
    FM!..
    --
    Tony Sayer


    Man is least himself when he talks in his own person.

    Give him a keyboard, and he will reveal himself.


    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2