• Re: Re. Re. Paleo-etymology (Final 400)

    From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Wed Aug 6 05:11:03 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    Back from exile. Now using Newsgrouper, learning the format.

    My website: https://groups.io/g/1WorldofWords/message/578
    DD
    ---

    Daud Deden <daud.deden@gmail.com> posted:

    On Friday, July 28, 2023 at 7:11:08rC>AM UTC-4, Daud Deden wrote:
    On Friday, July 28, 2023 at 2:07:03rC>AM UTC-4, Ruud Harmsen wrote:
    Thu, 27 Jul 2023 13:45:38 -0700 (PDT): Daud Deden
    <daud....@gmail.com> scribeva:
    On Thursday, July 27, 2023 at 4:02:38?PM UTC-4, Ross Clark wrote:
    On 28/07/2023 1:22 a.m., Daud Deden wrote:
    Sons of Jacob (in Russian): Synovya Iakova (?)

    Not correct.
    What's not correct?
    synovial (adj.)
    1756, "pertaining to the synovia," albuminous fluid secreted by certain glands, from Modern Latin sinovia (16c.), probably coined by Paracelsus and apparently an invented word.

    syn- [ xyuamb, sum]
    word-forming element meaning "together with, jointly; alike; at the same time," also sometimes completive or intensive, from Greek syn (prep.) "with, together with, along with, in the company of," from PIE *ksun- "with" (source also of Russian so- "with, together," from Old Russian su(n)-). Assimilated to -l-, reduced to sy- before -s- and -z-, and altered to sym- before -b-, -m- and -p-.

    No,no,no.
    Synovya is an archaic plural of Russian /syn/ 'son'. Yes, cognate with
    the English word. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%D1%81%D1%8B%D0%BD#Declension_3 calls
    it irregular, not archaic.
    Thanks, interesting. I checked 3 sites googling 'etym synovya', no mention of syn/son in Russian, all mentioned synovial fluid, so I thought the original cite (Clive Cussler, author of fiction, novel) was in error or invented.
    I guess you mean that 'synovya' is cognate with 'sons'.
    --
    Ruud Harmsen, https://rudhar.com
    Etymology

    u-stem derivation from the root *sewH- (rCLto give birthrCY), thus the original meaning being "birth, fruit of the body". Tocharian, Greek and Armenian reflect the -yu- derivation from the same root: *suHy||s. Sanskrit an+aNean+an+ (s+2b|u-U|U, rCLparturient womanrCY) and Albanian gjysh (< Proto-Albanian *s+2+i-U) derived from later variation *suHs||s.

    Noun
    *suhreUn||s or *suhrean||s m[1]
    son

    -
    Cognate with 'issue'?
    Xyua(mbuatl) through, threw, in parallel with Malay bua(h/t/ng) fruit-fert/make/throw out-parturate (xyuam)buatl

    Compare *sewH- birthing with *tewh- swelling and to endu/endo, Theo/Deu/tue.sday, xyua- opening of dome hut
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Mon Aug 18 00:49:33 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    Restarting thread from here, Aug. 2025

    Spanish & Welsh cognates (facebook)

    https://www.facebook.com/share/p/178M8HSo9e/
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Aidan Kehoe@kehoea@parhasard.net to sci.lang on Mon Aug 18 21:08:03 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    Ar an t-ocht|| l|i d|-ag de m|! L||nasa, scr|!obh DDeden:

    Restarting thread from here, Aug. 2025

    Spanish & Welsh cognates (facebook)

    https://www.facebook.com/share/p/178M8HSo9e/

    God bless you, Facebook, you have locked me out, I cannot make any further comments without making a Facebook account, which account I deleted over a decade ago, and with which decision I am happy. I wish rCLPolyglots (The Community)rCY well with this long-standing thread which, as far as I can see, was
    a waste of everyonerCOs time.
    --
    rCyAs I sat looking up at the Guinness ad, I could never figure out /
    How your man stayed up on the surfboard after fourteen pints of stoutrCO
    (C. Moore)
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Wed Aug 20 04:33:21 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    Aidan Kehoe <kehoea@parhasard.net> posted:


    Ar an t-ocht|| l|i d|-ag de m|! L||nasa, scr|!obh DDeden:

    Restarting thread from here, Aug. 2025

    Spanish & Welsh cognates (facebook)

    https://www.facebook.com/share/p/178M8HSo9e/

    God bless you, Facebook, you have locked me out, I cannot make any further comments without making a Facebook account, which account I deleted over a decade ago, and with which decision I am happy. I wish rCLPolyglots (The Community)rCY well with this long-standing thread which, as far as I can see, was
    a waste of everyonerCOs time.

    Thanks for the input, Aidan.
    Actually I deleted facebook a few hours ago, after restarting Facebook-lite, a much smaller interface.
    If you refer to this Paleo-etymology thread at Sci.lang as 'a waste of everyone's time', (rather than the link to the thread Spanish & Welsh cognates), then I suggest you not read any further Paleo-etymology posts.

    Slainte
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Thu Aug 21 06:08:05 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    Cringe crouch s.crunch shrug crotch squat

    Cringe
    1570s, "to bend or crouch, especially with servility or fear," variant of crenge, crenche "to bend" (c. 1200), from causative of Old English cringan "yield, give way, fall (in battle); become bent," from Proto-Germanic *krank- "bend, curl up" (source also of Old Norse kringr, Dutch kring, German Kring "circle, ring"). Related: Cringed; cringing. As a noun from 1590s

    Crouch
    "to stoop low, lie close to the ground," late 14c., probably from Old French crochir "become bent, crooked," from croche "hook" (see crochet). Related: Crouched; crouching. As a noun, "a crouching position," from 1590s

    S.Crunch
    1825, "to bite, crush with or as with the teeth," intensive form of crunch (v.); ultimately imitative (see scr-). The colloquial meaning "to squeeze, crush" is by 1835 (implied in scrunched). The intransitive sense of "contract oneself into a more compact shape" is by 1884

    initial sound-cluster, containing the exceptions to the general rule that sc- or sk- in Modern English indicates a word not from Old English (whose sc- regularly becomes sh-). Words often are found in pairs, especially in dialect and slang, one in scr-, one in shr- (or schr-); a prominent surviving example is shred and screed, the same Old English word surviving in two forms now much different in meaning.OED also notes that "Many English words beginning with scr- agree more or less closely in meaning with other words differing from them in form only by the absence of the initial s" (such as crunch/scrunch, scringe, an alternative form of cringe, etc.)It does not appear that these coincidences are due to any one general cause ..., but it is probable that the existence of many pairs of synonyms with scr- and cr- produced a tendency to change cr-, in words expressive of sounds or physical movements, into scr- so as to render the word echoic or phonetically symbolic. [OED]

    Shrug
    late 14c., shruggen, "raise or draw up (the shoulders) with a sudden movement," a word of uncertain origin, perhaps connected to Danish skrugge "to stoop, crouch".

    Crotch
    1530s, "pitchfork," from Old North French croche "shepherd's crook," variant of croc "hook," from Old Norse krokr "hook," which is of obscure origin but perhaps related to the widespread group of Germanic kr- words meaning "bent, hooked".

    Squat
    mid-14c., squatten, "to crush, flatten" (a sense now obsolete); early 15c., "crouch on the heels," from Old French esquatir, escatir "compress, press down, lay flat, crush," from es- "out" (see ex-) + Old French quatir "press down, flatten," from Vulgar Latin *coactire "press together, force," from Latin coactus, past participle of cogere "to compel, curdle, collect" (see cogent).

    https://www.facebook.com/share/r/19JSt1sgEF/
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Sun Aug 24 20:08:54 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    Camphor, a white crystalline tree resin, from PMP qapuR : lime from burnt coral/shell, for betel chewing, also a white crystalline powder, used around SEA but not at Vanatua where kava2 usage originated (kava <~ qapuR?).

    https://groups.io/g/1WorldofWords/message/630

    Camphor sounds similar to camp, kampong, kampf, xyuambuatl; perhaps derived from use of calcium for cement or ceramic?
    Was powdered limestone mixed with mud or manure in house (mortar, brick, adobe?) construction?

    QapuR distinct from kapu = taboo

    Camphor was burnt at Batu Caves, M'sia during Thaipusam Indian festival which I attended.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Tue Aug 26 12:06:26 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    DDeden <user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid> posted:


    Camphor, a white crystalline tree resin, from PMP qapuR : lime from burnt coral/shell, for betel chewing, also a white crystalline powder, used around SEA but not at Vanatua where kava2 usage originated (kava <~ qapuR?).

    https://groups.io/g/1WorldofWords/message/630

    Camphor sounds similar to camp, kampong, kampf, xyuambuatl; perhaps derived from use of calcium for cement or ceramic?
    Was powdered limestone mixed with mud or manure in house (mortar, brick, adobe?) construction?

    Cob(b) construction uses lime qapuR when available:
    Cob, cobb, or clom (in Wales) is a natural building material made from subsoil, water, fibrous organic material (typically straw), and sometimes lime.[1] The contents of subsoil vary, and if it does not contain the right mixture, it can be modified with sand or clay. Cob is fireproof, termite proof, resistant to seismic activity,[2] and uses low-cost materials, although it is very labour intensive

    Copp: an English topographic name for someone who lived on the top of a (hump lump rounded) hill: from Middle English coppe, Old English copp 'summit'.

    Cob-a XyUAmBuatla KUPharigolu -> coracle qwrwgl curragh topi topa

    "heap, lump, rounded object," also "head," and metaphoric extensions of both. With its cognates in other Germanic languages, of uncertain origin and development."The O.E.D. recognizes eight nouns cob, with numerous sub-groups. Like other monosyllables common in the dial[ect] its hist[ory] is inextricable" [Weekley]. In the 2nd print edition, the number stands at 11. Some senses are probably from Old English copp "top, head," others probably from Old Norse kubbi or Low German, all the words perhaps trace to a Proto-Germanic base *kubb- "something rounded."Among the earliest attested English senses are "headman, chief," and "male swan," both early 15c., but the surname Cobb (1066) suggests Old English used a form of the word as a nickname for "big, leading man." The "corn shoot" sense is attested by 1680s
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Clark@benlizro@ihug.co.nz to sci.lang on Thu Aug 28 16:00:57 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang

    On 25/08/2025 8:08 a.m., DDeden wrote:

    Camphor, a white crystalline tree resin, from PMP qapuR : lime from burnt coral/shell, for betel chewing, also a white crystalline powder, used around SEA but not at Vanatua where kava2 usage originated (kava <~ qapuR?).

    https://groups.io/g/1WorldofWords/message/630

    Camphor sounds similar to camp, kampong, kampf, xyuambuatl; perhaps derived from use of calcium for cement or ceramic?
    Was powdered limestone mixed with mud or manure in house (mortar, brick, adobe?) construction?

    QapuR distinct from kapu = taboo

    Camphor was burnt at Batu Caves, M'sia during Thaipusam Indian festival which I attended.


    Camphor sounds to me like a product of medieval technology, hence not
    likely to be of any great antiquity in Austronesian cultures or
    languages. Blust has a PAN *dakeS for the camphor laurel (Cinnamomum
    spp.), but attested only in Formosan languages.
    Otherwise nothing.

    OED traces English "camphor" and the other European words through Arabic k-Uf+2r, and k-Up+2r in Old Persian, Hindi and Malay. They also cite a Sanskrit karp+2ram, but don't say how early that form is (they never do),
    or whether there is any evidence whether it's a local formation or a borrowing. I would see the Malay word as a straight borrowing from India
    or Persia, particularly given the long vowels in both syllables.
    My 1960s Eng-Indo dictionary doesn't even give a word for camphor. (It's
    not as common a household product as it used to be.) However, Winstedt
    says it's Malay kapor Barus. I don't know what "Barus" is supposed to
    mean there, but "kapor" is defnitely lime or lime-kiln. So clearly
    somebody saw a resemblance with that other white crystalline substance.

    PAN *qapuR, PMP *kapuR for lime (calcium carbonate), made by burning
    shell or coral limestone, used in betel-chewing, have reflexes all
    through AN as far as the Solomons. And, as you say, that's where the
    betel stops and kava begins. I don't think the name of Piper methysticum
    is related to the lime words. Proto-Oceanic *kawa is based on
    Polynesian, southern Vanuatu and a scattering of other cognate forms.
    (In most of Vanuatu it's called *maloqu.) John Lynch's conclusion was
    that it was a metathetic variant of *wakaR 'root'.

    The word *qapuR is still around in Vanuatu, often with adjacent senses
    such as "ashes" or "dust". Lime itself had other uses -- notably for
    bleaching hair (or even a head-covering when out fishing -- Buck, Samoan Material Culture) -- so the making of it never disappeared. In Fijian
    and Polynesian it's called *lase -- originally the coral rock from which
    it's derived.

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Mon Sep 1 13:36:35 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    Ross Clark <benlizro@ihug.co.nz> posted:

    On 25/08/2025 8:08 a.m., DDeden wrote:

    Camphor, a white crystalline tree resin, from PMP qapuR : lime from burnt coral/shell, for betel chewing, also a white crystalline powder, used around SEA but not at Vanatua where kava2 usage originated (kava <~ qapuR?).

    https://groups.io/g/1WorldofWords/message/630

    Camphor sounds similar to camp, kampong, kampf, xyuambuatl; perhaps derived from use of calcium for cement or ceramic?
    Was powdered limestone mixed with mud or manure in house (mortar, brick, adobe?) construction?

    QapuR distinct from kapu = taboo

    Camphor was burnt at Batu Caves, M'sia during Thaipusam Indian festival which I attended.


    Camphor sounds to me like a product of medieval technology, hence not
    likely to be of any great antiquity in Austronesian cultures or
    languages. Blust has a PAN *dakeS for the camphor laurel (Cinnamomum
    spp.), but attested only in Formosan languages.
    Otherwise nothing.

    OED traces English "camphor" and the other European words through Arabic k-Uf+2r, and k-Up+2r in Old Persian, Hindi and Malay. They also cite a Sanskrit karp+2ram, but don't say how early that form is (they never do),
    or whether there is any evidence whether it's a local formation or a borrowing. I would see the Malay word as a straight borrowing from India
    or Persia, particularly given the long vowels in both syllables.
    My 1960s Eng-Indo dictionary doesn't even give a word for camphor. (It's
    not as common a household product as it used to be.) However, Winstedt
    says it's Malay kapor Barus. I don't know what "Barus" is supposed to
    mean there, but "kapor" is defnitely lime or lime-kiln. So clearly
    somebody saw a resemblance with that other white crystalline substance.

    PAN *qapuR, PMP *kapuR for lime (calcium carbonate), made by burning
    shell or coral limestone, used in betel-chewing, have reflexes all
    through AN as far as the Solomons. And, as you say, that's where the
    betel stops and kava begins. I don't think the name of Piper methysticum
    is related to the lime words. Proto-Oceanic *kawa is based on
    Polynesian, southern Vanuatu and a scattering of other cognate forms.
    (In most of Vanuatu it's called *maloqu.) John Lynch's conclusion was
    that it was a metathetic variant of *wakaR 'root'.

    The word *qapuR is still around in Vanuatu, often with adjacent senses
    such as "ashes" or "dust". Lime itself had other uses -- notably for bleaching hair (or even a head-covering when out fishing -- Buck, Samoan Material Culture) -- so the making of it never disappeared. In Fijian
    and Polynesian it's called *lase -- originally the coral rock from which it's derived.

    That is interesting.

    I'd think Persian & Indian traders got kapur name from SEAsia, from powder via heat or maceration.


    "All the plant parts of camphor tree have the distinctive, easy-to-recognise camphoraceous odor." One could get medicinal benefit without complex methods of distillation just by heating foliage, bark & woodchips, in sunlight, later near fire, so probably very ancient. I would guess originally it was chewed into a pulp and spit into a bowl, similarly to how kava was chewed(?). A still can be made with bamboo & clay pots, perhaps leaving a crystalline powder on the receptacle.

    Taiwan was rich in camphor laurels until industrial extraction.

    "The finest camphor came from Malaya, Borneo and Sumatra, but long-distance trade took it to societies at the geographical poles of demand - China and the medieval West already in late Antiquity (ca. 6th century A.D.). In India it was in use at an even much earlier period."

    Barus: a west Sumatran port where camphor was traded.

    Pure Barus camphor is a natural, crystalline substance that sublimes (evaporates without leaving a residue).

    Origin of the Name
    Kapur Barus:
    This term comes from the Malay word "kapur," meaning "chalk," referring to its white color.
    Barus:
    This was an ancient port on the western coast of Sumatra where foreign traders would purchase this camphor, leading to the name "kapur Barus" or "chalk of Barus".
    Historical Significance
    Trade:
    Barus was a significant trading hub for this valuable commodity in ancient times, linking Southeast Asian production with Indian and Middle Eastern markets.
    Medicine and Rituals:
    In India and Southeast Asia, pure Barus camphor has long been used in Hindu religious rituals, as an Ayurvedic medicine, and as a fumigant.
    Characteristics
    Natural Product:
    Barus camphor is extracted from camphor trees found in regions like Sumatra. Sublimation:
    When pure, it is a volatile compound that sublimes, meaning it turns directly from a solid to a gas without melting.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ross Clark@benlizro@ihug.co.nz to sci.lang on Tue Sep 2 13:06:59 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang

    On 2/09/2025 1:36 a.m., DDeden wrote:

    Ross Clark <benlizro@ihug.co.nz> posted:

    On 25/08/2025 8:08 a.m., DDeden wrote:

    Camphor, a white crystalline tree resin, from PMP qapuR : lime from burnt coral/shell, for betel chewing, also a white crystalline powder, used around SEA but not at Vanatua where kava2 usage originated (kava <~ qapuR?).

    https://groups.io/g/1WorldofWords/message/630

    Camphor sounds similar to camp, kampong, kampf, xyuambuatl; perhaps derived from use of calcium for cement or ceramic?
    Was powdered limestone mixed with mud or manure in house (mortar, brick, adobe?) construction?

    QapuR distinct from kapu = taboo

    Camphor was burnt at Batu Caves, M'sia during Thaipusam Indian festival which I attended.


    Camphor sounds to me like a product of medieval technology, hence not
    likely to be of any great antiquity in Austronesian cultures or
    languages. Blust has a PAN *dakeS for the camphor laurel (Cinnamomum
    spp.), but attested only in Formosan languages.
    Otherwise nothing.

    OED traces English "camphor" and the other European words through Arabic
    k-Uf+2r, and k-Up+2r in Old Persian, Hindi and Malay. They also cite a
    Sanskrit karp+2ram, but don't say how early that form is (they never do),
    or whether there is any evidence whether it's a local formation or a
    borrowing. I would see the Malay word as a straight borrowing from India
    or Persia, particularly given the long vowels in both syllables.
    My 1960s Eng-Indo dictionary doesn't even give a word for camphor. (It's
    not as common a household product as it used to be.) However, Winstedt
    says it's Malay kapor Barus. I don't know what "Barus" is supposed to
    mean there, but "kapor" is defnitely lime or lime-kiln. So clearly
    somebody saw a resemblance with that other white crystalline substance.

    PAN *qapuR, PMP *kapuR for lime (calcium carbonate), made by burning
    shell or coral limestone, used in betel-chewing, have reflexes all
    through AN as far as the Solomons. And, as you say, that's where the
    betel stops and kava begins. I don't think the name of Piper methysticum
    is related to the lime words. Proto-Oceanic *kawa is based on
    Polynesian, southern Vanuatu and a scattering of other cognate forms.
    (In most of Vanuatu it's called *maloqu.) John Lynch's conclusion was
    that it was a metathetic variant of *wakaR 'root'.

    The word *qapuR is still around in Vanuatu, often with adjacent senses
    such as "ashes" or "dust". Lime itself had other uses -- notably for
    bleaching hair (or even a head-covering when out fishing -- Buck, Samoan
    Material Culture) -- so the making of it never disappeared. In Fijian
    and Polynesian it's called *lase -- originally the coral rock from which
    it's derived.

    That is interesting.

    I'd think Persian & Indian traders got kapur name from SEAsia, from powder via heat or maceration.


    "All the plant parts of camphor tree have the distinctive, easy-to-recognise camphoraceous odor." One could get medicinal benefit without complex methods of distillation just by heating foliage, bark & woodchips, in sunlight, later near fire, so probably very ancient. I would guess originally it was chewed into a pulp and spit into a bowl, similarly to how kava was chewed(?). A still can be made with bamboo & clay pots, perhaps leaving a crystalline powder on the receptacle.

    Taiwan was rich in camphor laurels until industrial extraction.

    "The finest camphor came from Malaya, Borneo and Sumatra, but long-distance trade took it to societies at the geographical poles of demand - China and the medieval West already in late Antiquity (ca. 6th century A.D.). In India it was in use at an even much earlier period."

    Barus: a west Sumatran port where camphor was traded.

    Pure Barus camphor is a natural, crystalline substance that sublimes (evaporates without leaving a residue).

    Origin of the Name
    Kapur Barus:
    This term comes from the Malay word "kapur," meaning "chalk," referring to its white color.
    Barus:
    This was an ancient port on the western coast of Sumatra where foreign traders would purchase this camphor, leading to the name "kapur Barus" or "chalk of Barus".
    Historical Significance
    Trade:
    Barus was a significant trading hub for this valuable commodity in ancient times, linking Southeast Asian production with Indian and Middle Eastern markets.
    Medicine and Rituals:
    In India and Southeast Asia, pure Barus camphor has long been used in Hindu religious rituals, as an Ayurvedic medicine, and as a fumigant.
    Characteristics
    Natural Product:
    Barus camphor is extracted from camphor trees found in regions like Sumatra. Sublimation:
    When pure, it is a volatile compound that sublimes, meaning it turns directly from a solid to a gas without melting.


    Hm. OK, this makes sense now. I can believe Austronesian is the source
    of the word (leaving the Sanskrit form and the long vowels as probably explainable).

    Even found a nice article on it in good old _Hobson-Jobson_, where they
    say there are three types of camphor:

    a. Borneo and Sumatra (from Dryobalanops aromatica)
    b. China and Japan (from Cinnamomum camphora)
    c. China (ngai camphor) (from Blumea balsamifera)

    And that the relative prices of these on the Canton market (1886) are in
    the ratio: a. 80 b. 1 c. 10.

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Tue Sep 2 01:17:13 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    DDeden <user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid> posted:


    Restarting thread from here, Aug. 2025

    Spanish & Welsh cognates (facebook)

    https://www.facebook.com/share/p/178M8HSo9e/

    Irish & Sanskrit cognates (facebook)

    https://www.facebook.com/share/p/177CGsVtNx/
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Tue Sep 2 22:15:07 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    DDeden <user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid> posted:

    English & Hebrew "cognates", Pseudo-etymology
    by Josef Mitterer at Quora


    Q: What are some English words that came from Hebrew? I heard examples, like rCyChildrCO comes from the word +O+L+o (Yeled) in Hebrew and rCyEyerCO from +o+O+f (ayin).


    A: If I remember right, Arnold Wadler mentions these rCLexamplesrCY in his-apseudo-etimological-abook-aDer Turm von Babel-a(rCyThe Tower of BabelrCO, I don't know if the book has been translated into English).

    It is a good example of how pseudo-etymologists claim linguistic relatedness on the basis of-asuperficial rCLsimilaritiesrCY-awithout considering even minimally sound laws or chronology. In most cases, like WadlerrCOs, they arenrCOt genuinely interested in actual etymology and thus do not conduct an-aopen-ended-ainvestigation into the wordrCOs history, but they begin with their religious or political beliefs and ideologies and attempt to rCLproverCY them using completely unscientific and dishonest rCLmethodsrCY.

    LetrCOs go back to Old English:

    [rCa] o|#|#e-aeagena-abearhtm
    forsite|# ond forsworce|# [rCa]

    (Beowulf, 1766 s.)




    In modern English it reads: rCyor the brightness-aof the eyes-afades and darkensrCO. The form-aeagena-ais the genitive plural of-aeage, from which the Modern-English word-aeye-ais derived. Now, if the word-aeye-areally came from Hebrew, wouldn't one expect it to rCLresemblerCY its Hebrew rCLetymonrCY more closely the further back in time one goes? Yet nobody would find it rCLintuitiverCY to consider-aeage-aa cognate of-aayin-arCoand rCLintuitionrCY is all these pseudo-etymologists aim torCo nor is it phonetically plausible.

    So, in order to answer the first question, I suppose that the vast majority of English words coming from Hebrew have some religious meaning or are related to Judaism; you wonrCOt find them among the basic vocabulary.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Thu Sep 4 00:36:31 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    DDeden <user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid> posted:


    Restarting thread from here, Aug. 2025

    Spanish & Welsh cognates (facebook)

    https://www.facebook.com/share/p/178M8HSo9e/

    2025 Shibata PAN & Formosan updates

    In 2025, Kye Shibata made several changes to reconstructed Proto-Austronesian phonology based on careful examination of Formosan reflexes.

    https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1BRgx7P57U/
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Thu Sep 4 00:37:20 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    2025 Shibata PAN & Formosan updates

    In 2025, Kye Shibata made several changes to reconstructed Proto-Austronesian phonology based on careful examination of Formosan reflexes.

    https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1BRgx7P57U/
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Thu Sep 4 04:58:42 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    After applying some thought to the question Was there just one original human language?, I maintain that yes, there was.
    Language follows genetic lineage, both undergo mutations, both undergo natural selection.


    The sound "-bu-" in Malay usually refers to something round.

    https://www.facebook.com/groups/austronesian.languages/permalink/1810407633215577/?app=fbl

    xyuamBUatl
    njamBUangdualua

    Constructing (cf build) dome shelter (buat); fruit & coconut (buahan); throw ball (cf Grk ballein), birth (buang)
    Mother (ibu)
    Hill (bukit)
    Bust, bosom @ Egl : breasts
    Bucket @ Egl : related to breasts as milk jugs & water bags
    "pail or open vessel for drawing and carrying water and other liquids," mid-13c., from Anglo-French buquet "bucket, pail," from Old French buquet "bucket," which is from Frankish or some other Germanic source, or a diminutive of cognate Old English buc "pitcher, bulging vessel," originally "belly" (buckets were formerly of leather as well as wood), both from West Germanic *buh- (source also of Dutch buik, Old High German buh, German Bauch "belly"), possibly from a variant of PIE root *beu-, *bheu- "to grow, swell" (see bull (n.2)).

    Probably paleo origin

    Not related:
    Book (buku, from English)

    Build.ing. xyuamBUATLa, boat bottle model
    Middle English bilden, from late Old English byldan "construct a house," verb form of bold "house," from Proto-Germanic *buthla- (source also of Old Saxon bodl, Old Frisian bodel "building, house"), from PIE *bhu- "to dwell," from root *bheue- "to be, exist, grow."
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Fri Sep 5 08:13:55 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    https://neurosciencenews.com/evolution-neuroscience-language-origin-29660/

    Researchers found that humans and marmosets both undergo rapid brain growth right after birth, unlike chimpanzees and macaques, making them especially sensitive to social feedback. These findings reveal how brain development and caregiving environments interact to support the emergence of communication skills.When a baby babbles and their parents respond, these back-and-forth exchanges are more than adorable-if-incoherent chatter rCo they help to build a babyrCOs emerging language skills.

    But it turns out this learning strategy makes humans an oddity within the animal kingdom.

    Only a handful of other species rCo including a few songbirds such as cowbirds and zebra finches rCo learn to rCLtalkrCY by noting their parentsrCO reactions to their initial coos and gurgles.In the new study, led by Princeton Ph.D. student Renata Biazzi, the researchers collected and analyzed previously published data on the brain development of four primate species including humans, marmosets, chimpanzees and rhesus macaques, from conception to adolescence.

    The results suggest that, in early infancy, the brains of humans and marmosets are growing faster than those of other primates. Importantly, most of that growth happens not in the confines of the womb, as is the case for chimpanzees and macaques, but right around the time they are born and first experience the outside world.

    In marmosets, as in humans, this also happens to be an incredibly social time, Ghazanfar said. ThatrCOs because marmoset moms, like human mothers, donrCOt raise their offspring without help. Babies interact with multiple caregivers who respond to every cry
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Sun Sep 14 01:21:13 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    At 95, Noam ChomskyrCothe legendary linguist, philosopher, and political thinkerrCohas reportedly lost much of his ability to speak and write due to health issues.

    For decades, Chomsky used words not to comfort, but to challenge. He dissected global power structures, media manipulation, war, and inequalityrCoalways urging people to think critically, even when the truth was uncomfortable.
    He never asked to be followed blindly. In fact, he warned against it.
    rCLThe smart way to keep people passive and obedient,rCY he once said, rCLis to strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion, but allow very lively debate within that spectrum.rCY
    He believed real change didnrCOt come from waiting on leadersrCobut from understanding systems, questioning history, and organizing ordinary people.
    Chomsky didnrCOt just give answers.
    He gave generations the tools to ask better questions.
    And though his voice may be quiet now, his words are still loud in classrooms, protests, libraries, and minds around the world.

    https://www.facebook.com/share/p/178M8HSo9e/
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Sun Sep 14 08:34:55 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    DDeden <user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid> posted:


    At 95, Noam ChomskyrCothe legendary linguist, philosopher, and political thinkerrCohas reportedly lost much of his ability to speak and write due to health issues.

    For decades, Chomsky used words not to comfort, but to challenge. He dissected global power structures, media manipulation, war, and inequalityrCoalways urging people to think critically, even when the truth was uncomfortable.
    He never asked to be followed blindly. In fact, he warned against it.
    rCLThe smart way to keep people passive and obedient,rCY he once said, rCLis to strictly limit the spectrum of acceptable opinion, but allow very lively debate within that spectrum.rCY
    He believed real change didnrCOt come from waiting on leadersrCobut from understanding systems, questioning history, and organizing ordinary people.
    Chomsky didnrCOt just give answers.
    He gave generations the tools to ask better questions.
    And though his voice may be quiet now, his words are still loud in classrooms, protests, libraries, and minds around the world.

    https://www.facebook.com/share/p/178M8HSo9e/

    Speaking of silence

    Wittgenstein, Heidegger, and the language of silence
    What happens when silence speaks

    11th September 2025
    Steven Bindeman | Formerly Professor of Philosophy and Department Chairperson at Strayer University. He is a leading theorist on silence and has published articles on Heidegger, Wittgenstein and the creative process.

    We think we communicate and understand most deeply using language. But how can we say what words cannot express? Silence. Drawing on Wittgenstein and Heidegger, philosopher Steven Bindeman argues that language often keeps us separated from the world and is fundamentally incapable of describing it. Only silence can bridge the gap between the self and world.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Tue Sep 16 16:39:11 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    True friends false cognates
    True friends, true cognates
    False friends, true cognates
    False friends, false cognates

    https://www.facebook.com/share/1EzmGMwohk/
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Mon Sep 29 14:07:24 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    DDeden <user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid> posted:


    True friends false cognates
    True friends, true cognates
    False friends, true cognates
    False friends, false cognates

    https://www.facebook.com/share/1EzmGMwohk/

    That post is one of many interesting etymology infographics by Taal

    https://www.facebook.com/taalaandewandel
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Mon Sep 29 17:53:20 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    Cepan @ Azt : combine <= XyUAMBuAtl

    There isn't a single, simple verb for "combine" in Nahuatl; instead, the idea is conveyed through the word cepan (or |oepan), which functions as an adverb meaning "together" or "in company with one another" and can be incorporated into verbs.
    Here's why and how it works:
    Adverbial meaning
    : cepan means "together" or "jointly".
    Incorporation into verbs
    : This adverb can be added to a verb to express the idea of combining or being together simultaneously. For example, in the sentence "yquac yaque sepanolestin yn i|oepan mexica opan Florida," sepanolestin is a verb formed from cepan, indicating that the Spanish went together with the Mexica.
    Contextual usage
    : The specific way to express "combine" depends on the context. You might use cepan with a verb of movement, like the example above, or other actions to show that things are done together.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Thu Oct 2 00:56:24 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    Gumbo = okra

    https://groups.io/g/1WorldofWords/post

    Gumbo < ngombo @ Mbundu Ctl Afr Bantu : okra
    soup thickened with okra, 1805, from Louisiana French, probably ultimately from Central Bantu dialect (compare Mbundu ngombo "okra"). Also used for "the creole patois of Louisiana" (1838).

    Okra < nkruma @ Akan W Afr Ghana : okra
    vegetable cultivated in the East and West Indies and southern U.S., 1670s, from a West African language (compare Akan nkruma "okra").
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Thu Oct 2 03:47:13 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    Laryngeal airsacs & external noses in humans, apes & proboscis monkeys

    https://newsgrouper.org/sci.anthropology.paleo/1757564103/1757564103 https://newsgrouper.org/sci.anthropology.paleo/1758689342/0
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Fri Oct 3 00:37:14 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    Antarctican accent, citizens

    https://groups.io/g/1WorldofWords/message/684
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Aidan Kehoe@kehoea@parhasard.net to sci.lang,alt.usage.english on Fri Oct 3 11:29:18 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    Ar an tri|| l|i de m|! Deireadh F||mhair, scr|!obh DDeden:

    Antarctican accent, citizens

    https://groups.io/g/1WorldofWords/message/684

    rCyFor instance, a German woman stationed at the Rothera Research Station began
    to speak like a native English speaker as she talked more and more with her
    colleagues from the UK.rCO

    [...]

    rCyThe incipient linguistic changes observed in Antarctica, while captured over
    a brief six-month period, are not without precedent. They represent the first
    moments of a process that has played out countless times throughout human
    history, leading to the diversification of languages and the birth of new
    dialects.

    While the rCLAntarctic accentrCY may sound surprising, itrCOs not without
    precedent. History is full of cases where small, isolated groups of people
    forged entirely new ways of speaking.rCO

    Glad it has been documented. The article has plenty of filler, which is not a shock.
    --
    rCyAs I sat looking up at the Guinness ad, I could never figure out /
    How your man stayed up on the surfboard after fourteen pints of stoutrCO
    (C. Moore)
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Sun Oct 5 07:03:47 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    DDeden <user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid> posted:


    Cepan @ Azt : combine <= XyUAMBuAtl

    There isn't a single, simple verb for "combine" in Nahuatl; instead, the idea is conveyed through the word cepan (or |oepan), which functions as an adverb meaning "together" or "in company with one another" and can be incorporated into verbs.
    Here's why and how it works:
    Adverbial meaning
    : cepan means "together" or "jointly".
    Incorporation into verbs
    : This adverb can be added to a verb to express the idea of combining or being together simultaneously. For example, in the sentence "yquac yaque sepanolestin yn i|oepan mexica opan Florida," sepanolestin is a verb formed from cepan, indicating that the Spanish went together with the Mexica.
    Contextual usage
    : The specific way to express "combine" depends on the context. You might use cepan with a verb of movement, like the example above, or other actions to show that things are done together.


    I somehow missed that both combine and (ac)company are obviously linked to cepan in meaning, sound and derivation. All three are apparently cognates, and can be traced back to xyuambuatl, where Aztec Nahuatl typically swaps p for mb.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang,alt.usage.english on Tue Oct 7 19:33:14 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    Aidan Kehoe <kehoea@parhasard.net> posted:


    Ar an tri|| l|i de m|! Deireadh F||mhair, scr|!obh DDeden:

    Antarctican accent, citizens

    https://groups.io/g/1WorldofWords/message/684

    rCyFor instance, a German woman stationed at the Rothera Research Station began
    to speak like a native English speaker as she talked more and more with her
    colleagues from the UK.rCO

    [...]

    rCyThe incipient linguistic changes observed in Antarctica, while captured over
    a brief six-month period, are not without precedent. They represent the first
    moments of a process that has played out countless times throughout human
    history, leading to the diversification of languages and the birth of new
    dialects.

    While the rCLAntarctic accentrCY may sound surprising, itrCOs not without
    precedent. History is full of cases where small, isolated groups of people
    forged entirely new ways of speaking.rCO

    Glad it has been documented. The article has plenty of filler, which is not a shock.

    Video of antarctic guides, I hear no particular accent:

    Antarctic guides

    https://youtube.com/shorts/LkjQT2mx80g?si=wFpYkDovon8j1ncL


    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From DDeden@user5108@newsgrouper.org.invalid to sci.lang on Sat Oct 11 23:08:54 2025
    From Newsgroup: sci.lang


    HAQERS & human language evolution

    https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.03.07.641231

    Ancient regulatory evolution shapes individual language abilities in present-day humans

    Lucas G Casten, Tanner Koomar, Taylor R Thomas, Jin-Young Koh, Dabney Hofammann, Savantha Thenuwara, Allison Momany, Marlea OrCOBrien, Jeffrey C Murray, J Bruce Tomblin, Jacob J Michaelson

    doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.03.07.641231

    Abstract
    Language is a defining feature of our species, yet the genomic changes enabling it remain poorly understood. Despite decades of work since FOXP2rCOs discovery, we still lack a clear picture of which regions shaped language evolution and how variation contributes to present-day phenotypic differences. Using a novel evolutionary stratified polygenic score approach in nearly 40,000 individuals, we find that Human Ancestor Quickly Evolved Regions (HAQERs) are specifically associated with language but not general cognition. HAQERs evolved before the humanrCoNeanderthal split, giving hominins stronger binding of Forkhead and Homeobox transcription factors, and show balancing selection across the past 20,000 years. Remarkably, language variants in HAQERs appear more prevalent in Neanderthals and have convergently evolved across vocal-learning mammals. Our results reveal how ancient innovations continue shaping human language.

    INTRODUCTION Human language is one of our speciesrCO most defining features, yet its genetic foundations remain incompletely understood. Previous research has shown how rare mutations in genes like FOXP2 can cause severe speech and language disorders, but these individual genes cannot explain typical variation in language capabilities or the broader evolutionary emergence of human language. Recent work has focused on identifying common genetic variants associated with language-related traits through large-scale genome-wide association studies, which have revealed hundreds of genomic loci contributing to traits like reading ability, rhythm, stuttering and vocabulary development. This emerging picture supports a highly polygenic architecture for language abilities, with numerous regulatory elements scattered throughout the genome collectively influencing language development. However, this polygenic model has left fundamental evolutionary questions unanswered about how these regulatory elements evolved during human evolution and when our species acquired its unique language-promoting functions.

    RESULTS Through analysis of nearly 40,000 individuals across multiple cohorts with detailed language phenotyping, we discovered that Human Ancestor Quickly Evolved Regions (HAQERs), genomic sequences that began rapidly accumulating mutations before the human-neanderthal ancestral split, show specific and robust associations with language abilities but not with nonverbal IQ. A single nucleotide polymorphism in a HAQER carries on average 188 times more impact on language ability than variants elsewhere in the genome, despite HAQERs comprising less than 0.1% of the human genome. We find that HAQERs evolved in hominins to support language through increased binding affinity to Forkhead and Homeobox box transcription factors, including FOXP2, with these binding motifs linked to individual differences in language capability. Additionally, HAQERs provided humans with novel cell-type-specific chromatin accessibility, including in medium spiny neurons and FOXP2 -expressing neurons. Ancient DNA analysis of early humans from the past 20,000 years revealed that language-promoting HAQER variants have remained stable in frequency, likely due to balancing selection, contrasting with general cognition variants that show evidence of recent positive selection. This apparent balancing selection can be explained by the link between HAQERs and prenatal development, including a larger head size at birth and birth complications. Surprisingly, archaic humans (Neanderthals and Denisovans) appear to carry higher frequencies of language-promoting variants than ancient and modern humans, suggesting complex language capabilities emerged before the human-Neanderthal split. Cross-species genomic analysis across 170 non-primate mammalian species demonstrated convergent evolution of HAQER-like sequences specifically in vocal learning mammals, providing independent evidence for the fundamental role of these regulatory elements in complex vocal communication.

    CONCLUSION These results establish a direct connection between ancient genomic changes and present-day variation in human language abilities, supporting that the genetic foundations for complex language capabilities predate Homo sapiens. The discovery that language-promoting variants show signatures of balancing rather than positive selection, combined with evidence that these variants influence prenatal brain size and birth complications, suggests an ongoing evolutionary trade-off between language capability and reproductive fitness that continues to shape human genetic variation today.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2