| Sysop: | Amessyroom |
|---|---|
| Location: | Fayetteville, NC |
| Users: | 23 |
| Nodes: | 6 (0 / 6) |
| Uptime: | 52:26:10 |
| Calls: | 583 |
| Files: | 1,139 |
| D/L today: |
179 files (27,921K bytes) |
| Messages: | 111,611 |
User-Agent: ForteAgent/8.00.32.1272 trialware
(Posting via Forte Agent...looks I will have to make the inevitable
switch)
(Posting via Forte Agent...looks I will have to make the inevitable
switch)
Following the discussion I was having with MH in the other
interminable thread, here is what ChatGPT thinks about the possibility
of creating a modern-looking highlight reel from a newspaper account
of a 1930 soccer match:
Prompt: If I gave a good AI model a newspaper account of a soccer
match from the 1930s (say, the 1934 World Cup semifinal), would it be
able to produce a modern-looking highlight reel from it?
Answer:
Great question u and yes, with some caveats, a good AI model could
produce a modern-looking highlight reel of a 1930s soccer match from a well-written newspaper account, but it wouldn't be "real" video u it
would be a **plausible reconstruction** or **stylized simulation**,
not historically accurate footage.
---
### ? WhatAs Possible Today (Mid-2025):
1. **Text-to-Video Generation**:
* Advanced models like Sora (by OpenAI), or competitors from
Runway, Pika, and others, can now generate highly realistic video from
text prompts.
* If you provide a **detailed match description** u e.g., oIn the
24th minute, Giuseppe Meazza dribbled past two Austrian defenders and
slotted the ball into the bottom left cornero u these models can
visualize that moment as a video scene.
2. **Stylistic Control**:
* You can ask the model to use **modern camera angles**,
**broadcast graphics**, **slow motion replays**, **stadium sound
effects**, and even commentary in the style of a 2020s highlight
reel.
* You can choose black-and-white or colorized footage, retro kits
or updated uniforms, old or modern stadium aesthetics.
3. **Player Likenesses**:
* If you provide photos or descriptions of key players (e.g.,
Meazza), the model can create avatars that resemble them, though not perfectly unless guided by reference imagery.
4. **Sequence Reconstruction**:
* A well-written newspaper article might not provide
second-by-second play-by-play, but if it gives a good **narrative of
major events**, the AI can reconstruct those into a sequence of highlight-worthy scenes (goals, fouls, saves, etc.).
---
### ?? WhatAs Not Possible (Yet or Ever):
* **Historical Accuracy**: AI cannot guess what actually happened
beyond whatAs described. If the newspaper doesn't mention a key play
or misreports it, the AI will reproduce the error.
* **Real Faces and Movements**: Without actual footage, the body
language, facial expressions, and crowd behavior are all speculative.
* **Full Matches**: A full 90-minute recreation would be technically possible, but very labor-intensive and computationally heavy, and
still mostly fictional beyond whatAs described.
---
### ?? How You Could Do This:
If you wanted to try this today, hereAs a pipeline:
1. **Feed the Article** to GPT-4 or GPT-4o and ask it to extract a scene-by-scene list of major events.
2. For each scene, generate a prompt like:
> oScene: A packed Stadio Giovanni Berta in Florence, June 1934.
ItalyAs Giuseppe Meazza receives the ball at the top of the box,
sidesteps a sliding Austrian defender, and fires a low shot past the goalkeeper. Modern TV camera angle, HD quality, colorized footage,
excited Italian crowd in the background.o
3. Send each prompt to a text-to-video model like Sora, **Runway
Gen-3**, Pika, or **Luma Dream Machine**.
4. Stitch together the clips, add music, crowd sound, and commentary.
---
### ?? Bottom Line:
Yes, a good AI can turn a historical match report into a **convincing
modern highlight reel**, but it will be a **creative reimagining**,
not an archival reconstruction. ItAs a powerful tool for education, storytelling, and even fan art u but not for documentary accuracy.
Would you like to try one together? You can upload a match report and
I can help generate prompts or even visuals.
(Posting via Forte Agent...looks I will have to make the inevitable
switch)
Following the discussion I was having with MH in the other
interminable thread, here is what ChatGPT thinks about the possibility
of creating a modern-looking highlight reel from a newspaper account
of a 1930 soccer match:
Prompt: If I gave a good AI model a newspaper account of a soccer
match from the 1930s (say, the 1934 World Cup semifinal),
would it be
able to produce a modern-looking highlight reel from it?
Futbolmetrix wrote:
(Posting via Forte Agent...looks I will have to make the inevitable
switch)
What's Forte Agent?
Following the discussion I was having with MH in the other
interminable thread, here is what ChatGPT thinks about the possibility
of creating a modern-looking highlight reel from a newspaper account
of a 1930 soccer match:
Is this to more accurately compare teams from the 1930s with teams from
the 21st century, so we can see whether Barcelona 2009-15 really were a >better team than Juventus 1931-35 for example?
I'd be willing to post my match report of Uruguay v Argentina in the
2011 Copa America quarter-final to experiment with if you want.
You picked the wrong scenario prompt though, it
should have been aGiuseppe Meazza crashes into the
Austrian goalkeeper who drops the ball, and the
Swedish referee has been bribed into awarding the
goalA!
would it be
able to produce a modern-looking highlight reel from it?
I wonder if it wouldnAt be worthwhile to do something
different first - there is existing footage of e.g. the
1934 World Cup Final, but itAs very disjointed, and
the low frame rate makes everything look more
distorted than it would have appeared in real life.
I suppose AI could easily spruce that up, add colour,
maybe combine several scenes into a more
compelling highlight reel.
On Fri, 25 Jul 2025 13:34:02 -0000 (UTC), Werner Pichler
You picked the wrong scenario prompt though, it
should have been rCyGiuseppe Meazza crashes into the
Austrian goalkeeper who drops the ball, and the
Swedish referee has been bribed into awarding the
goalrCO!
Fake news!
Here is one description of the goal:
"Seszta toglie con pulita furberia un pallone a Schiavio, ma questi
insiste, lo riprende e tira. Platzer para, la palla gli sfugge: tre
uomini gli sono addosso. Schiavio, Meazza, Ferrari. La palla si ferma
nel fango, e` fuori portata di Platzer. Guaita, prima ancora che
Ferrari fosse entrato sul portiere, aveva dato il colpo di grazia e
segnato. Meazza e Platzer rimangono a terra contusi: il portiere e` il
primo a rialzarsi, e Meazza lo segue dopo pochi secondi"
"Seszta steals the ball from Schiavio with a clever trick, but he
persists, takes it back, and shoots. Platzer saves, the ball slips
away: three men are on him: Schiavio, Meazza, Ferrari. The ball lands
in the mud, out of Platzer's reach. Guaita, even before Ferrari had
run into the goalkeeper, had delivered the coup de grace and scored.
Meazza and Platzer remain on the ground, bruised: the goalkeeper is
the first to get up, and Meazza follows a few seconds later."
If Platzer had really been fouled, he would have rolled on the ground
for an eternity. Instead, he gets up immediately, undeniable proof
that there was no wrongdoing. Good call by the ref to award the goal.
;-)
would it be
able to produce a modern-looking highlight reel from it?
I wonder if it wouldnrCOt be worthwhile to do something
different first - there is existing footage of e.g. the
1934 World Cup Final, but itrCOs very disjointed, and
the low frame rate makes everything look more
distorted than it would have appeared in real life.
I suppose AI could easily spruce that up, add colour,
maybe combine several scenes into a more
compelling highlight reel.
Yes, that should be relatively easy. It would be also give us a
benchmark of what current technology can do
"Seszta steals the ball from Schiavio with a clever trick, but he
persists, takes it back, and shoots. Platzer saves, the ball slips
away: three men are on him: Schiavio, Meazza, Ferrari. The ball lands
in the mud, out of Platzer's reach. Guaita, even before Ferrari had
run into the goalkeeper, had delivered the coup de grace and scored.
Meazza and Platzer remain on the ground, bruised: the goalkeeper is
the first to get up, and Meazza follows a few seconds later."
"Using good interplay the Italian forward line attacked. Platzer has to
parry a powerful shot by Schiavio; he drops the ball as three Italians
close in on him; Meazza brutally (!) tackles the goalkeeper,
he prevents a stooping Platzer from reaching the ball, two other
strikers throw him fully to the ground and in the next moment Guaita
jumps and pushes the ball over the goal line. Platzer is injured, Meazza
got hurt, too. The Austrian goalkeeper is soon ready for battle again,
but the Italian striker needs refreshment (!) in order to return to
action."
(I'll say one thing, sports commentary in the olden days was much more >colourful!)
AI, do your job!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GgpUEgJlzLU&t=157s