From Newsgroup: rec.arts.startrek.current
AI/LLM Reviews of Star Trek The Next Generation - Suddenly Human
Google Gemini
Plot Synopsis
The Enterprise discovers a lone human boy,
Jono, among the wreckage of a Talarian vessel.
Starfleet records indicate he is Jericho,
son of Lieutenant Commander Brian and Marybeth
Johnson, and he was presumed dead five years
earlier after his ship went missing. The crew
learns that the Talarians, led by their captain,
Endar, raised him as their own.
Captain Picard attempts to re-acclimate Jono
to human customs and his birth culture. However,
Jono is completely loyal to his Talarian family,
rejecting Picard and the Enterprise crew. He
expresses anger and confusion, and his attempts
to escape and return to his life with Endar
create significant tension. The situation
escalates when Endar returns, demanding the boy's
return, leading to a standoff between the two ships.
In the end, Picard makes the difficult decision
to allow Jono to return to his adopted family,
a choice that acknowledges the boy's true
identity and emotional connection.
Strengths
Moral Ambiguity: This episode avoids a
simple "good vs. evil" narrative. Endar,
the Talarian captain, is not a villain;
he is a grieving father who genuinely
loves his adopted son. This complexity
forces the crew and the audience
to confront a difficult moral question:
what is more important, biology
or the bonds of family and culture?
A Humanistic Approach: The episode is
a classic Trek example of a science-fiction
plot used to explore a deeply human issue.
It is a powerful exploration of cultural
assimilation, childhood trauma, a
nd the nature of what makes a family.
Picard's Compassion: The story showcases Picard's
leadership and compassion. He struggles with his
personal feelings about returning a human child
to an alien culture but ultimately makes the
choice that he believes is best for the boy's
well-being, even if it defies Starfleet protocol.
Weaknesses
The resolution may feel too convenient for some
viewers, especially the swiftness with which
Picard's decision is accepted.
Overall Impression
"Suddenly Human" is a compelling and mature
episode that tackles a complex ethical dilemma
with nuance and grace. It demonstrates the show's
willingness to challenge its characters
and audience with difficult questions
that have no easy answers. The episode's
focus on empathy and understanding, even
for one's adversaries, is a timeless message.
While it may not be the most action-packed
episode, its emotional depth and moral weight
make it a highly memorable story.
Rating: 8/10
ChatGPt
HererCOs a thoughtful review
of **Star Trek: The Next Generation** rCo **rCLSuddenly HumanrCY**
(Season 4, Episode 4), based on the transcript
and critical insights:
---
## Summary (from the transcript and sources)
The Enterprise rescues a Talarian vessel
suffering an engine malfunction. Among
the crew is a seemingly feral human teen,
**Jono**. Over time, it's revealed Jono
is actually **Jeremiah Rossa**, the grandson
of a Starfleet Admiral, who was adopted
by **Captain Endar** of the Talarians
after his parents were killed in a skirmish.
Dr. Crusher suspects abuse, while Jono remains
fiercely loyal to Endar. Picard is urged to
mentor him, despite his discomfort with children.
As Picard gains JonorCOs trust, memories
resurfacerCoincluding trauma from the attack
that killed his parents. Eventually, JonorCOs
choice to return with Endar is honoured,
despite pressure from his human relatives.
([Den of Geek][1], [Wikipedia][2], [Scifi Dimensions][3])
---
## What Works
* **Compelling moral dilemma:** The episode tackles
issues of cultural identity, loyalty, and the ethics
of rescue. Picard faces a genuine dilemma between
what society expects and what Jono truly wants.
([Scifi Dimensions][3], [Wikipedia][2])
* **Strong performances:** Chad Allen brings
heartfelt authenticity to Jono, while Patrick
Stewart portrays PicardrCOs struggle with dignity
and empathy.([IMDb][4], [Wikipedia][2])
* **Thought-provoking themes:** JonorCOs
torn identity and the collision of human
and Talarian cultures prompt deep questions
about belonging and what "home" means.
([Scifi Dimensions][3], [Wikipedia][2])
---
## Weaknesses
* **Narrative shortcomings:** Some critics,
such as Den of GeekrCOs James Hunt, described
it as a slow-moving rCLbottle episoderCY with
preachy moralising and an unresolved
dramatic tension.([Den of Geek][1])
* **Ambiguous character decisions:** Doux Reviews
raises concern about the Enterprise crewrCOs
discomfort with JonorCOs refusal to interact
with women and their own cultural insensitivity.
([douxreviews.com][5])
* **Mixed viewer reception:** A reviewer
on IMDb praised the paternal stakes
but questioned the finalerCOs fairnessrCoespecially
given Picard's lack of parental instincts.([IMDb][4])
---
## Overall Impression
"Suddenly Human" stands out as a deeply human
story amid TNGrCOs space-faring adventures.
It raises difficult questions and showcases
PicardrCOs personal and moral grapplingrConot
only as a starship captain but as a stand-in parent.
Yet, its emotional and narrative complexity
can feel uneven, with some executional missteps.
---
###  **Rating: 7 / 10**
A solid and thoughtful episode that may not sit
among TNGrCOs classics, but offers meaningful
character work and moral depth. Worth watching
for anyone interested in the tension between
duty, compassion, and cultural belonging.
[1]:
https://www.denofgeek.com/tv/revisiting-star-trek-tng-suddenly-human/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Revisiting Star Trek TNG: Suddenly Human - Den of Geek"
[2]:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suddenly_Human?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Suddenly Human"
[3]:
https://www.scifidimensions.com/is-suddenly-human-worth-watching/?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Is \"Suddenly Human\" Worth Watching? - Scifi Dimensions"
[4]:
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0708779/reviews?utm_source=chatgpt.com "\"Star Trek: The Next Generation\" Suddenly Human (TV Episode 1990 ... - IMDb"
[5]:
https://www.douxreviews.com/2016/06/star-trek-next-generation-suddenly-human.html?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Doux Reviews: Star Trek The Next Generation: Suddenly Human"
--
Member - Liberal International This is
doctor@nk.ca Ici
doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant
--- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2