From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.tv

AI/LLM Reviews of Star Trek The Next Generation - The Price

Google Gemini

"Star Trek: The Next Generation - The Price"
combines a high-stakes diplomatic negotiation
over a unique astronomical phenomenon with
a personal romantic subplot for Counselor
Deanna Troi, exploring themes of trust,
deception, and the allure of power.

Plot Overview:

The USS Enterprise-D arrives at Barzan II,
the site of an interstellar conference where
various powers are bidding for control of a
newly discovered, seemingly stable wormhole.
This wormhole promises an unprecedented
shortcut to the distant Gamma Quadrant,
making it an incredibly valuable asset.
Premier Bhavani of Barzan is hosting
the negotiations, with representatives
from the Federation, the Chrysalians,
and the ever-opportunistic Ferengi present.
The Federation's lead negotiator, Mendoza,
mysteriously falls ill, forcing Commander
Riker to step in as his replacement.

While the diplomatic maneuvering unfolds,
Lieutenant Commander Data and Lieutenant
Commander La Forge embark on a mission
through the wormhole to determine its
true stability. They make a crucial
discovery: the wormhole's far end shifts
positions periodically and, more alarmingly,
is not in the Gamma Quadrant as initially
believed, but in the even more distant
Delta Quadrant. Meanwhile, Counselor Troi
finds herself drawn into a romantic
relationship with Devinoni Ral,
the charismatic Chrysalian negotiator.
Their budding romance is complicated
by Ral's intense ambition
and his surprising empathic abilities.
Troi eventually uncovers Ral's deception:
he has been using his empathic powers
to subtly manipulate the negotiations
to his advantage.

Troi exposes Ral's unethical tactics.
With the wormhole proven unstable
and its destination far from what
was advertised, the Federation wisely
withdraws its bid. The Ferengi, having
rushed into the wormhole, find their pod
trapped on the other side in the Delta
Quadrant. Ral is disgraced
and recalled by the Chrysalians.
In a final, desperate plea, he asks
Troi to leave Starfleet and join him,
but she ultimately declines, choosing
her duty and integrity over a relationship
built on manipulation.

Strengths:

Intriguing Sci-Fi Concept: The stable wormhole
and its shifting destination provide
a compelling scientific mystery
and a high-stakes prize for the various factions.

Troi's Romantic Arc: The episode offers
a significant romantic subplot for Deanna Troi,
allowing her to explore a personal relationship
and confront deception. It highlights
her empathic abilities in a new context.

Devinoni Ral as an Antagonist: Ral is
a charismatic and complex antagonist.
His use of empathy for manipulation is a clever
twist, making him a more nuanced villain
than pure greed-driven Ferengi.

Diplomatic Intrigue: The negotiations between
the different species, and the various
strategies employed, add a layer of
political and diplomatic tension.

Data and La Forge's Investigation: The subplot
with Data and La Forge exploring the wormhole
is engaging and crucial to uncovering
the truth about its instability.

Weaknesses:

Pacing: The episode can feel a bit slow at times,
particularly in the early stages
of the negotiations and the development
of Troi's relationship with Ral.

Convenient Illness: Mendoza's sudden illness,
while necessary to put Riker in the negotiation
hot seat, feels a bit too convenient.

Ferengi Portrayal: The Ferengi, while providing
some comic relief, are still somewhat
one-dimensional in this early appearance,
primarily serving as greedy foils.

Dated Visuals: As an early TNG episode,
some of the visual effects for the wormhole
and the alien delegates show their age.

Ral's Motivation (Limited): While his ambition
is clear, the depth of Ral's personal motivations
for his deception could have been more thoroughly
explored.

Overall Impression:

"The Price" is a decent and engaging episode
of Star Trek: The Next Generation that effectively
blends a scientific mystery and diplomatic
intrigue with a personal story for Counselor
Troi. While it has some pacing issues
and dated visuals, its exploration of trust,
deception, and the complexities of alien
interaction makes it a worthwhile entry
in the series.

Rating: 6.5/10

ChatGPT

Certainly rCo hererCOs a review
of **rCLStar Trek: The Next GenerationrCY rCo *The Price***
using the script from [chakoteya.net] (http://www.chakoteya.net/NextGen/156.htm).

---

**Episode:** *The Price*
**Season:** 3, Episode 8
**Original Air Date:** November 13, 1989
**Written by:** Hannah Louise Shearer
**Directed by:** Robert Scheerer

---

## Efoi **Summary (based on the transcript)**

A rare opportunity arises: a **stable wormhole**
has been discovered in the Barzan system,
potentially granting reliable access to the
distant Delta Quadrant. The Barzans want
to auction the rights to it to the highest
bidder, hoping to economically benefit.
Several delegations rCo including the Federation,
the Ferengi, and a mysterious race called
the Chrysalians rCo arrive to negotiate.

The Federation sends a civilian negotiator,
**Devononi Ral**, who quickly becomes
romantically involved with Counselor **Troi**.
Ral is charming but manipulative rCo secretly
an empath (half-Betazoid) who uses his powers
to gain unfair advantages in negotiations.
Troi is torn between her personal relationship
and her professional ethics.

Meanwhile, the Ferengi rCo suspicious
of the wormholerCOs stability rCo send a
shuttle through it. La Forge and Data
follow them and discover that the wormhole
is only stable on the Barzan side;
on the far end, itrCOs unstable and useless.
The Ferengi crew gets stranded,
a fate played for comic effect.

Picard, armed with the new information,
halts the Federation bid. Troi confronts
Ral about his dishonesty.
He leaves, exposed and rejected.

---

## rLa **Strengths**

**rRe First real Troi-centered episode:** This
is the first episode to explore Deanna Troi
as more than just the shiprCOs emotional radar.
Her romantic involvement with Ral adds emotional
depth, even if the outcome is bittersweet.

**rRi Geopolitical Trek:** The idea of bidding
for a wormhole rCo a kind of celestial real
estate deal rCo is classic TNG. The diplomatic
tension and negotiation scenes are well
constructed.

**rRi Early mention of the Delta Quadrant:** This
is the wormhole that would later
become *Voyager*rCOs domain rCo the episode plants
interesting continuity seeds.

**rRi The Ferengi subplot:** Although theyrCOre
used for comic relief, their fate is ironic
and effective. Data and La Forge's mission
provides some fun tech-driven exploration.

**rRA Ethical dilemmas:** TroirCOs
conflict rCo balancing personal feeling
with ethical duty rCo is very Trek
and feels believable.

---

## rYi **Weaknesses**

**rRe Devononi Ral is a bit generic:** HerCOs
suave and manipulative but ultimately one-note.
His hidden empathic abilities feel like
a narrative shortcut more than a real twist.

**rRi Romantic subplot is rushed:** The romance
between Troi and Ral develops very quickly.
It doesnrCOt have much room to breathe, making
TroirCOs emotional journey feel slightly forced.

**rRi Not much action or high stakes:** This is
a quieter, dialogue-heavy episode. Some viewers
might find it dry compared to other Season 3
entries.

**rRi Limited long-term impact:** The wormhole
turns out to be unstable, so the stakes vanish
by the end rCo and the FerengirCOs fate is just
played for laughs.

---

## EfA! **Standout Moments**

* Troi confronting Ral in the end: her
realization that he used his abilities
unethically is one of her stronger
scenes to date.

* Data and La Forge trapped at the other
end of the wormhole rCo a fun reminder of
the dangers of trusting cosmic shortcuts.

* RikerrCOs deadpan dealing with the Ferengi delegates.

---

## Efu?N+A **Best line**

**Ral:** *rCLWe all wear masks. Mine happens

to be a negotiatorrCOs smile.rCY*

**Troi:** *rCLYours is deception.rCY*

This exchange crystalizes the episoderCOs core
conflict between charm and manipulation,
empathy and ethics.

---

## r!E **Rating: 6.5/10**

**Verdict:** *The Price* is a competent
but modest episode. It gives Troi some
overdue character development and presents
an intriguing diplomatic scenario with
classic Trek themes rCo ethics, identity,
and power. While it doesnrCOt rank among
Season 3rCOs most memorable outings, itrCOs
a solid mid-season entry that tries
something different and succeeds
more often than not.
--
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant
--- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2