From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.tv

AI/LLM Reviews of Star Trek The Next Generation - The Enemy

Google Gemini

"Star Trek: The Next Generation - The Enemy"
is a tense and thought-provoking episode that
explores themes of prejudice, trust,
and the enduring animosity between the Federation
and the Romulan Star Empire. It provides a strong
character focus for Geordi La Forge and Worf.

Plot Overview:

The USS Enterprise-D responds to a distress
signal from Galorndon Core, a harsh
and electromagnetically active planet. An away
team, consisting of Commander Riker, Lieutenant
Worf, and Lieutenant Commander La Forge, beams
down to investigate. They discover the wreckage
of a crashed Romulan scout ship and a single
Romulan survivor. During their investigation,
La Forge is separated from the group
and falls into a deep, electromagnetically
charged pit, becoming trapped
and critically injured.

The Enterprise crew races against time to locate
and rescue La Forge, all while facing a new
complication: the arrival of a hostile Romulan
Warbird, commanded by the cunning
and aggressive Commander Tomalak, who demands
the return of his officer. The situation quickly
escalates into a tense standoff between the two
rival powers. Trapped in the pit, La Forge finds
himself forced to cooperate with the injured
Romulan survivor, Centurion Bochra, despite
their ingrained mutual distrust. Through their
desperate efforts, La Forge, with Bochra's
reluctant help, manages to send a signal to
the Enterprise. Captain Picard, facing
a difficult choice, makes a risky gesture
of trust: he lowers the Enterprise's shields to
beam up La Forge and the Romulan, averting a
potential full-scale conflict with Tomalak.
The episode culminates in a fragile
de-escalation, leaving the deep-seated
animosity between the Federation and Romulans
unresolved but briefly tempered by necessity.

Strengths:

Exploration of Prejudice: The episode powerfully
explores the deep-seated prejudice and distrust
between humans/Klingons and Romulans. Worf's
refusal to donate blood to the Romulan is a
particularly impactful and controversial
moment that highlights this theme.

Geordi's Showcase: This is a strong episode
for Geordi La Forge, as he is put in a
life-threatening situation and forced to rely on
his wits and an unlikely ally. His struggle to
survive and his interactions with Bochra
are compelling.

Tense Standoff: The diplomatic and tactical
standoff between Picard and Tomalak
is well-executed, creating genuine tension
and showcasing Picard's strategic thinking
and willingness to take risks for his crew.

Romulan Characterization: Commander Tomalak
is introduced as a formidable and intelligent
Romulan adversary, setting the stage for future
encounters. Centurion Bochra also provides
a more nuanced look at an individual Romulan.

Moral Dilemma: The episode forces the crew
to confront their own biases and the ethical
complexities of helping an enemy, even when
lives are at stake.

Weaknesses:

Convenient Medical Solution: The resolution
to La Forge's immediate medical needs
and the ability to beam him out of the pit, while
dramatic, feels somewhat conveniently achieved.

Dated Visuals: As an early TNG episode, some of
the visual effects for the planetary environment
and the Romulan ship show their age.

Worf's Extreme Reaction: While serving the theme,
Worf's absolute refusal to help the Romulan,
even in a life-or-death medical emergency,
can feel overly harsh and somewhat out of
character for his Starfleet oath.

Overall Impression:

"The Enemy" is a strong and impactful episode
of Star Trek: The Next Generation. It excels
in its exploration of complex themes like
prejudice and trust, provides a compelling
character focus for Geordi and Worf,
and introduces a memorable Romulan antagonist.
Despite some minor plot conveniences and dated
visuals, its high stakes and willingness to
tackle uncomfortable truths make it a significant
and highly regarded entry in the series.

Rating: 8.5/10

ChatGPT

Absolutely rCo letrCOs dive into
**rCLStar Trek: The Next GenerationrCY rCo *The Enemy***
using the script from [chakoteya.net] (http://www.chakoteya.net/NextGen/155.htm).

---

**Episode:** *The Enemy*
**Season:** 3, Episode 7
**Original Air Date:** November 6, 1989
**Written by:** David Kemper, Michael Piller
**Directed by:** David Carson

---

## Efoi **Summary (from the transcript)**

The Enterprise responds to a distress call from
the surface of Galorndon Core rCo a storm-ravaged
planet with intense magnetic interference. They
find a crashed Romulan ship. Geordi is stranded
on the hostile surface while trying to rescue a
Romulan survivor. Meanwhile, Worf and Riker bring
back another Romulan rCo critically wounded rCo to
the Enterprise.

This sets up three conflicts:

1. **Geordi vs. the elements:** Geordi must
survive the stormy planet, and herCOs forced to
work with Bochra, another stranded Romulan,
despite deep mistrust.

2. **Picard vs. the Romulans:** A Romulan Warbird
arrives, demanding the return of their men and
accusing the Federation of violating the Neutral
Zone.

3. **Worf vs. his hatred:** The dying Romulan
needs a transfusion only Worf can give rCo but
Worf refuses, unable to forgive the Romulans
who killed his parents.

In the end, Geordi and Bochra cooperate to
survive and signal the ship, overcoming mutual
prejudice. WorfrCOs refusal leads to the RomulanrCOs
death, which fuels a tense standoff
with Commander Tomalak rCo but Picard defuses
it with the return of Bochra
as proof of Federation goodwill.

---

## rLa **Strengths**

**rRe Strong tension and moral conflict:** This is
classic TNG rCo an ethical dilemma with no easy answer.
WorfrCOs refusal to save an enemy, even at the cost
of his own honour, is a powerful character beat.

**rRi GeordirCOs forced alliance:** The stranded
subplot is pure Trek rCo two enemies must cooperate
to survive. Geordi and BochrarCOs grudging teamwork
is believable and rewarding.

**rRi TomalakrCOs debut:** Andreas Katsulas makes
Tomalak memorable rCo calm, cunning, and menacing
in a way that sets the tone for future Romulan episodes.

**rRi The Romulans as real adversaries:** This episode
continues the showrCOs effort to make the Romulans more
layered than mustache-twirling villains rCo theyrCOre proud,
ruthless, but not cartoonish.

**rRA Great atmosphere:** The scenes on Galorndon
Core feel harsh and immersive, with real stakes
for Geordi.

---

## rYi **Weaknesses**

**rRe Pacing:** The planet scenes are stronger
than the shipboard drama rCo WorfrCOs conflict
could have used even more depth.

**rRi Slightly convenient ending:** TomalakrCOs
withdrawal is maybe a bit too neat, given
how tense the standoff is.

**rRi No real follow-up:** WorfrCOs refusal doesnrCOt
have lasting consequences beyond this
episode rCo which feels like a missed chance.

---

## EfA! **Standout moments**

* WorfrCOs cold line: *rCLI will not help a Romulan live.rCY*

* Geordi and Bochra building trust: the visor
scene is a great bit of sci-fi teamwork.

* PicardrCOs standoff with Tomalak:
classic Trek diplomacy under pressure.

---

## Efu?N+A **Best line**

**Worf:** *rCLI would be giving him my fatherrCOs blood!rCY*

Brutal, honest, and perfectly
Klingon rCo this sums up the moral
collision at the heart of the story.

---

## r!E **Rating: 8/10**

**Verdict:** *The Enemy* is a strong Season 3
entry: tense, morally complicated, and filled
with character-driven drama. It shows how TNGrCOs
third season matured rCo tackling prejudice,
old wounds, and the fine line between duty
and hatred. ItrCOs not quite an all-time classic,
but itrCOs a solid, memorable hour that deepens
both the Romulans and Worf.
--
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant
--- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2