• Woman in the Moon, 1929 film

    From Gary McGath@garym@mcgath.com to rec.arts.sf.fandom,alt.movies.silent on Mon Jun 23 11:44:14 2025
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.fandom

    In 1929, Fritz Lang's silent movie _Frau im Mond_ (_Woman in the Moon_)
    came out. It depicts a trip to the Moon which gets an amazing amount
    right, considering it was released 40 years before Apollo 11. It
    includes a countdown, a multi-stage rocket, G-force stress,
    retro-rockets for landing, and more.

    I've written a blog post discussing the points it got right, along with
    a few errors and some translation problems.

    https://garymcgath.com/wp/fritz-lang-woman-in-the-moon/

    Also, I've posted this part of the film, with my accompaniment, on
    YouTube. I'm less impressed with the rest of it, and 2 3/4 hours of
    music was more than I wanted to do. The part in the video is about 40
    minutes long, from 50 minutes before launch to opening the hatch on the
    lunar surface.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JVSXSEGXV2c

    If you want to see the whole movie, which is now in the public domain,
    it's easy to find on YouTube.
    --
    Gary McGath http://www.mcgath.com

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Charles Packer@mailbox@cpacker.org to rec.arts.sf.fandom,alt.movies.silent on Wed Jun 25 07:26:13 2025
    From Newsgroup: rec.arts.sf.fandom

    On Mon, 23 Jun 2025 11:44:14 -0400, Gary McGath wrote:

    In 1929, Fritz Lang's silent movie _Frau im Mond_ (_Woman in the Moon_)
    came out. It depicts a trip to the Moon which gets an amazing amount
    right, considering it was released 40 years before Apollo 11. It
    includes a countdown, a multi-stage rocket, G-force stress,
    retro-rockets for landing, and more.

    I've written a blog post discussing the points it got right, along with
    a few errors and some translation problems.

    https://garymcgath.com/wp/fritz-lang-woman-in-the-moon/

    Also, I've posted this part of the film, with my accompaniment, on
    YouTube. I'm less impressed with the rest of it, and 2 3/4 hours of
    music was more than I wanted to do. The part in the video is about 40
    minutes long, from 50 minutes before launch to opening the hatch on the
    lunar surface.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JVSXSEGXV2c

    If you want to see the whole movie, which is now in the public domain,
    it's easy to find on YouTube.


    For those who want to compare McGath's version of the music
    with the original, his excerpt begins at about 1:22:00 into the
    original. His take on it is wonderfully Schubertian.

    The movie was unknown to me, so I was intrigued at the similarities
    of the launch scene to the Apollo program. In addition to those
    mentioned by McGrath in his blog post, Walter Cronkite is
    anticipated in the person of the avuncular commentator standing
    before microphones.

    I figured that Apollo-era journalists must have been aware of the
    movie and that there would be at least a feature or two about it
    to be found in the newspaper archives. Alas, the search algorithm
    is too sloppy to distinguish "The Girl in the Moon" -- the title
    as released in the U.S. -- from many other combinations of girl and
    moon.

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2