From Newsgroup: rec.arts.drwho

AI/LLM reviews of STNG - Contagion

Google Gemini

"Star Trek: The Next Generation - Contagion"
is a fast-paced and suspenseful episode that
combines a technological mystery with a tense
Romulan standoff, exploring the dangers
of ancient, powerful alien technology.

Plot Overview:The USS Enterprise-D responds
to a desperate distress call from the USS Yamato,
a Federation starship commanded
by Captain Jean-Luc Picard's old friend,
Captain Donald Varley. The Yamato is experiencing
severe and escalating malfunctions, and Picard
hopes that the combined expertise of both crews
can resolve the issues before their presence
in the Romulan Neutral Zone is detected.
However, before they can render significant
aid, the Yamato is tragically destroyed.
The Enterprise soon encounters a Romulan Warbird,
commanded by the cunning Sub-Commander Taris,
further escalating tensions in the sensitive
border region.

Picard learns that Captain Varley
was investigating a mysterious,
ancient Iconian gateway and its associated
technology in the Neutral Zone, which ultimately
led to the Yamato's destruction. The Enterprise
is then scanned by an Iconian probe, which
transmits a sophisticated and insidious
computer program directly into the Enterprise's
systems. This alien program immediately begins
to cause widespread and dangerous malfunctions
across the ship, mirroring the Yamato's fate.
The crew races against time to understand
and counteract the alien program before
it destroys the Enterprise, all while
navigating the hostile presence of the Romulans,
who have laid claim to the Iconian planet. Data,
with his unique positronic brain, is able to
clear the Iconian program from his own system,
providing a crucial clue. The crew uses this
method to perform a daring and risky wipe
of the Enterprise's main computer
and restore its systems. During the chaotic process,
Picard is inadvertently transported
to the Romulan ship, which, it turns out,
is also suffering from the same Iconian-induced
malfunctions, having been infected by the same probe.

Strengths:High Stakes and Pacing: The episode maintains
a high level of tension and a brisk pace,
with the Enterprise constantly battling against
internal malfunctions and external threats.

Romulan Conflict: The re-engagement with
the Romulans is well-executed, showcasing
their cunning and adding a layer of geopolitical
tension to the technological mystery.

Iconian Technology: The introduction of the Iconians
and their highly advanced, dangerous technology is a
fascinating concept that adds to the Star Trek lore.
The "demon-class" gateway is particularly intriguing.

Technological Mystery: The core mystery
of the self-replicating, destructive computer program
is compelling, forcing the crew to use their wits
and technical expertise.

Data's Role: Data is crucial to solving the crisis,
as his unique mind provides the key to understanding
and defeating the Iconian program.

Picard's Leadership: Picard's calm under pressure,
his strategic thinking, and his willingness to take
calculated risks are on full display.

Weaknesses:

Convenient Solutions: The method of wiping
and restoring the ship's computer, while dramatic,
feels somewhat convenient as a solution to such
a complex alien program.

Dated Visuals: As an early TNG episode,
some of the visual effects, particularly
the computer malfunctions and the Iconian probe,
show their age.

Romulan Motivation (Limited): While Taris
is a good antagonist, the Romulans' immediate
and aggressive claim over the Iconian planet,
despite the clear danger, feels a bit one-dimensional.

Picard's Transport: Picard being accidentally
transported to the Romulan ship is a somewhat
contrived plot device to bring the two captains
together for the final confrontation.

Overall Impression:"Contagion" is a strong
and exciting early episode
of Star Trek: The Next Generation.
It delivers a compelling blend of technological
mystery, high-stakes action, and tense diplomatic
relations with the Romulans. While it has some
minor plot conveniences and dated visuals,
its fast pace, intriguing alien technology,
and effective portrayal of the Enterprise
crew under pressure make it a memorable
and significant entry in the series.

Rating: 8/10

Google Gemini

Absolutely! Let’s break
down **“Star Trek: The Next Generation” — *Contagion***
using the transcript from [chakoteya.net] (http://www.chakoteya.net/NextGen/137.htm).

---

**Episode:** *Contagion*
**Season:** 2, Episode 11
**Original Air Date:** March 20, 1989

---

### **Summary (based on the transcript)**

The Enterprise responds to a distress call
from its sister ship, the USS *Yamato*.
Captain Donald Varley, an old friend of Picard’s,
has taken the *Yamato* into the Neutral Zone
to investigate the long-extinct Iconian
civilisation — a race whose advanced technology
is legendary. But the *Yamato* is mysteriously
plagued by catastrophic malfunctions and explodes,
killing everyone aboard. When the Enterprise
retrieves the *Yamato*’s logs, it too becomes
infected by the same Iconian computer virus
that’s corrupting its systems. While under
threat from both the virus and an opportunistic
Romulan warbird, Picard, Data, and Worf beam
down to the Iconian homeworld to find answers.
Data gets infected by the virus, Picard narrowly
escapes by self-destructing the Iconian gateway,
and the crew ultimately saves the Enterprise
by performing a system reboot — basically,
they “turn it off and back on again.”

---

### **Strengths:**

✅ **Solid sci-fi mystery:** The Iconians
are one of TNG’s coolest pieces
of ancient-civilisation lore. The idea
of a super-advanced race that vanished
long ago, leaving behind dangerous tech,
is classic Trek.

✅ **Good tension and pacing:** The episode
balances a technical mystery with a real
threat — the Romulans — and the ship’s
systems failing piece by piece adds real
suspense. The *Yamato*’s destruction
in the teaser is shocking
and ups the stakes immediately.

✅ **Romulan intrigue:** The Romulans
lurking in the Neutral Zone add a political
layer. Commander Tomalak (Andreas Katsulas)
is one of TNG’s best Romulan
characters — sly and menacing
without being cartoonish.

✅ **Fun technobabble:** The computer virus plot
is very “Trek” — a nice blend of sci-fi
and plausible 24th-century digital catastrophe.
Watching Geordi and Data puzzle it
out is satisfying, if a bit dated.

✅ **Nice Data showcase:** Data is instrumental
here, showing both his vulnerability
(getting “infected” by the virus)
and his value to the crew.

---

### **Weaknesses:**

❌ **Low character stakes:** Apart
from Picard’s interest in archaeology,
there’s not a ton of personal development.
The episode is more about plot
mechanics than deep character work.

❌ **Technobabble overload:** Some
of the “virus = computer magic” explanation
is vague, even by Trek standards. The
solution — reboot the ship — is realistic
but narratively anticlimactic.

❌ **Iconians underused:** The Iconians
are intriguing but remain mostly background lore.
They’ll pop up later in Trek (*Deep Space Nine*)
but here they’re more an excuse for the virus
plot than a deeply explored mystery.

---

### **Standout line:**

* **Picard (to Data):** *“If the
past teaches us anything,
it’s that we can learn from it.”*

* A classic Picard line that sums
up his archaeological fascination
and Starfleet’s ethos.

---

### **Rating: 7/10**

*Contagion* is a strong, classic-feeling
TNG adventure. It’s not deep character
drama like *The Measure of a Man*, but
it’s an entertaining mix of ancient
alien mystery, ship-in-peril tension,
and Romulan politics. It’s solid
mid-tier TNG that expands
the universe’s lore in a fun way,
even if the resolution is
more “IT help desk” than epic.
--
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant
--- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2