• Re: Is Rocksolid Light really compromised and insecure?

    From Marco Moock@mm@dorfdsl.de to news.admin.peering on Sat Jul 12 20:55:07 2025
    From Newsgroup: news.admin.peering

    On 12.07.2025 10:21 Uhr Anonymous wrote:

    Some have claimed that Rocksolid Light is insecure. They have claimed
    that there are many vulnerabilities in the codebase. They have
    claimed that Rocksolid Light should not be used or peered.

    Yet I have not seen a single supposed vulnerability demonstrated.

    I have not seen any CVE filings.

    Can anyone demonstrate and prove any of the claimed exploits?

    It least older versions were vulnerable to SQL injections that made
    creating files in the spool directory possible. The files.php file also
    seems vulnerable to such attacks.
    --
    kind regards
    Marco

    Send spam to 1752308479muell@stinkedores.dorfdsl.de

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Ray Banana@rayban@raybanana.net to news.admin.peering on Sat Jul 12 19:41:55 2025
    From Newsgroup: news.admin.peering

    * Marco Moock wrote:
    On 12.07.2025 10:21 Uhr Anonymous wrote:

    Some have claimed that Rocksolid Light is insecure. They have claimed
    that there are many vulnerabilities in the codebase. They have
    claimed that Rocksolid Light should not be used or peered.

    Yet I have not seen a single supposed vulnerability demonstrated.

    I have not seen any CVE filings.

    Can anyone demonstrate and prove any of the claimed exploits?

    It least older versions were vulnerable to SQL injections that made
    creating files in the spool directory possible. The files.php file also
    seems vulnerable to such attacks.

    That would explain how the "haxxor" was able to grab account data for
    a technical account for i2pn2.org (presumably the account used for the communication between the rslight frontend and the i2pn2 backend server).



    To make things even worse, there is nobody who is able to revoke
    the compromised account or change its password.
    --
    -f-a|U-e-u-+ rCo -a-a-|-+-+|U
    https://www.eternal-september.org
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Billy G. (go-while)@no-reply@no.spam to news.admin.peering on Tue Jul 22 09:59:56 2025
    From Newsgroup: news.admin.peering

    On 12.07.25 17:21, Anonymous wrote:
    Some have claimed that Rocksolid Light is insecure. They have claimed that there are many vulnerabilities in the codebase. They have claimed that Rocksolid Light should not be used or peered.

    Yet I have not seen a single supposed vulnerability demonstrated.

    I have not seen any CVE filings.

    Can anyone demonstrate and prove any of the claimed exploits?

    Where would I find such proofs?


    Yes and if anyone is still running [rocksolid / rslight] (PHP):

    1. Turn it off!
    2. Backup /etc/rslight and /var/spool/rslight folders!
    3. Do NOT delete any configs or data!
    4. Wait for pugleaf.net open source release!
    5. Import to new software and be happy!

    If you don't want to turn your rslight off...
    Deny access from public and use it locally only.

    The path traversal vulnerability was used to rescue valuable
    community data from the rocksolidbbs.com server.

    Works on all other domains too and there is nobody to install a patch.. Passwords are already leaked... kids found the way in...

    That's not the only vulnerability but i won't publish any more details.

    We'll see how long his servers and sites keep running.

    Domain expiry = end of life for the sites

    novabbs.com / novabbs.org / novalink.us will expiry in jan/feb 2026. rocksolidbbs.com in end of nov 2025 and i2pn2.org end of the year 2025.

    Maybe there is credit... but if not ...

    ... RIP Retro Guy ...

    https://github.com/go-while/rocksolid-light/blob/claude-sonnet-4-test2/Rocksolid_Light/CRITICAL_VULNERABILITY.md

    https://github.com/go-while/rocksolid-light/tree/claude-sonnet-4-test2

    https://github.com/go-while/rocksolid-light

    EfU? CRITICAL SECURITY NOTICE

    This codebase contains multiple critical security vulnerabilities and is
    no longer under active development.
    Status: DEPRECATED AND UNSAFE FOR PRODUCTION USE

    Path Traversal Vulnerabilities: Complete file system access possible
    SQL Injection Attacks: Database compromise via multiple vectors
    Input Validation Failures: User input processed without
    sanitization throughout
    Legacy PHP Anti-Patterns: 20-year-old vulnerable coding practices
    Architectural Security Flaws: No security boundaries or privilege separation

    Evidence of Active Exploitation

    This codebase was actively compromised for over 1 year (May 2024 - June
    2025) with evidence of:

    Automated SQL injection campaigns
    File system pollution via malicious newsgroup names
    Systematic database content extraction
    Hundreds of attack artifacts preserved in the filesystem

    Why Development Has Stopped

    After comprehensive security analysis, this codebase is beyond repair:

    50+ distinct attack vectors across all major components
    No security architecture to retrofit modern protections
    Interconnected vulnerabilities where fixes create new problems
    Legacy dependencies that prevent meaningful security improvements


    Efoo SECURITY ADVISORY FOR ROCKSOLID LIGHT ADMINISTRATORS
    Subject: CRITICAL SECURITY VULNERABILITIES - Immediate Action Required

    To: RockSolid Light Administrators From: Security Research Team Date:
    June 20, 2025 Severity: CRITICAL

    EfU? EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

    Multiple critical security vulnerabilities have been discovered in
    RockSolid Light installations,

    with evidence of active exploitation spanning May 2024 - June 2025.

    Any RockSolid Light instance running during this period should be
    considered potentially compromised.

    rUaN+A IMMEDIATE ACTION REQUIRED

    You are running RockSolid Light:

    Take your installation offline immediately
    Audit your system logs for suspicious activity
    Check your spool directory for unusual files (see indicators below)
    Consider your system potentially compromised
    Do not restart without applying security fixes

    Efoi VULNERABILITY DETAILS
    Primary Vulnerability: Path Traversal (CVE Pending)

    File: /var/www/html/spoolnews/files.php
    Impact: Complete file system access
    Exploitation: Active attacks documented since May 2024

    Vulnerable Code Pattern:

    // files.php - Critical path traversal
    $getfilename = $spooldir . '/upload/' . $_REQUEST['showfile']; readfile($getfilename); // NO PATH VALIDATION

    Attack Vector:

    Attacker extracts site key from HTML form
    POST request with malicious showfile parameter
    Can read any system file accessible to web server
    Enables extraction of SSH credentials, database contents,
    configuration files

    Secondary Vulnerability: SQL Injection via Newsgroup Names

    Impact: Database manipulation and file system pollution
    Evidence: Hundreds of malicious database files found
    Attack Method: Injection through NNTP protocol and group name
    processing

    Efo|N+A COMPROMISE INDICATORS

    Check your spool directory for files with suspicious names:

    # Look for files containing SQL injection patterns
    find /var/spool/rslight -name "*CASE WHEN*" -o -name "*SELECT*" -o -name "*UNION*"
    find /var/spool/rslight -name "*ORDER BY*" -o -name "*CONCAT*" -o -name "*CHAR(*"

    Example malicious filenames found:

    (CASE WHEN (2018=4830) THEN 'newsgroup' ELSE SELECT...)-data.db3 comp.lang.python' WHERE 7629=7629 AND 5482=CONCAT...-data.db3 DOVE-Net.Synchronet_Announcements ORDER BY 3123-- fnTQ-cache.txt

    If you find such files, your system has been compromised.
    ATTACK TIMELINE

    May 2024: First evidence of SQL injection attacks
    May 2024 - June 2025: Continuous automated exploitation
    March 2025: Retro Guy's system was under active attack during his
    final months
    June 2025: Vulnerabilities discovered and documented

    EfA+ DATA AT RISK

    Potentially Compromised Information:

    System/Web configuration files and encryption keys
    All newsgroup content and user messages
    User account databases and authentication data
    SSH credentials and server access
    Email addresses and user metadata
    Any sensitive data accessible to the web server

    EfcaN+A IMMEDIATE REMEDIATION STEPS

    Emergency Shutdown

    # Stop web server and NNTP service immediately
    systemctl stop apache2 nginx

    Evidence Preservation

    # Backup current state for forensic analysis
    tar -czf rocksolid-incident-$(date +%Y%m%d).tar.gz /var/spool/rslight/

    This vulnerability was discovered during a digital preservation effort following Retro Guy's passing in March 2025.

    The path traversal vulnerability was used to rescue valuable community
    data from the rocksolidbbs.com server.

    ------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------------------
    --
    .......
    Billy G. (go-while)

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From doctor@doctor@doctor.nl2k.ab.ca (The Doctor) to news.admin.peering,comp.security.misc,news.software.nntp on Tue Jul 22 14:36:00 2025
    From Newsgroup: news.admin.peering

    In article <687f44fc$0$61204$882e4bbb@reader.netnews.com>,
    Billy G. (go-while) <no-reply@no.spam> wrote:
    On 12.07.25 17:21, Anonymous wrote:
    Some have claimed that Rocksolid Light is insecure. They have claimed
    that there are many vulnerabilities in the codebase. They have claimed
    that Rocksolid Light should not be used or peered.

    Yet I have not seen a single supposed vulnerability demonstrated.

    I have not seen any CVE filings.

    Can anyone demonstrate and prove any of the claimed exploits?

    Where would I find such proofs?


    Yes and if anyone is still running [rocksolid / rslight] (PHP):

    1. Turn it off!
    2. Backup /etc/rslight and /var/spool/rslight folders!
    3. Do NOT delete any configs or data!
    4. Wait for pugleaf.net open source release!
    5. Import to new software and be happy!

    If you don't want to turn your rslight off...
    Deny access from public and use it locally only.

    The path traversal vulnerability was used to rescue valuable
    community data from the rocksolidbbs.com server.

    Works on all other domains too and there is nobody to install a patch.. >Passwords are already leaked... kids found the way in...

    That's not the only vulnerability but i won't publish any more details.

    We'll see how long his servers and sites keep running.

    Domain expiry = end of life for the sites

    novabbs.com / novabbs.org / novalink.us will expiry in jan/feb 2026. >rocksolidbbs.com in end of nov 2025 and i2pn2.org end of the year 2025.

    Maybe there is credit... but if not ...

    ... RIP Retro Guy ...

    https://github.com/go-while/rocksolid-light/blob/claude-sonnet-4-test2/Rocksolid_Light/CRITICAL_VULNERABILITY.md

    https://github.com/go-while/rocksolid-light/tree/claude-sonnet-4-test2

    https://github.com/go-while/rocksolid-light

    EfU? CRITICAL SECURITY NOTICE

    This codebase contains multiple critical security vulnerabilities and is
    no longer under active development.
    Status: DEPRECATED AND UNSAFE FOR PRODUCTION USE

    Path Traversal Vulnerabilities: Complete file system access possible
    SQL Injection Attacks: Database compromise via multiple vectors
    Input Validation Failures: User input processed without
    sanitization throughout
    Legacy PHP Anti-Patterns: 20-year-old vulnerable coding practices
    Architectural Security Flaws: No security boundaries or privilege
    separation

    Evidence of Active Exploitation

    This codebase was actively compromised for over 1 year (May 2024 - June >2025) with evidence of:

    Automated SQL injection campaigns
    File system pollution via malicious newsgroup names
    Systematic database content extraction
    Hundreds of attack artifacts preserved in the filesystem

    Why Development Has Stopped

    After comprehensive security analysis, this codebase is beyond repair:

    50+ distinct attack vectors across all major components
    No security architecture to retrofit modern protections
    Interconnected vulnerabilities where fixes create new problems
    Legacy dependencies that prevent meaningful security improvements


    Efoo SECURITY ADVISORY FOR ROCKSOLID LIGHT ADMINISTRATORS
    Subject: CRITICAL SECURITY VULNERABILITIES - Immediate Action Required

    To: RockSolid Light Administrators From: Security Research Team Date:
    June 20, 2025 Severity: CRITICAL

    EfU? EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

    Multiple critical security vulnerabilities have been discovered in
    RockSolid Light installations,

    with evidence of active exploitation spanning May 2024 - June 2025.

    Any RockSolid Light instance running during this period should be
    considered potentially compromised.

    rUaN+A IMMEDIATE ACTION REQUIRED

    You are running RockSolid Light:

    Take your installation offline immediately
    Audit your system logs for suspicious activity
    Check your spool directory for unusual files (see indicators below)
    Consider your system potentially compromised
    Do not restart without applying security fixes

    Efoi VULNERABILITY DETAILS
    Primary Vulnerability: Path Traversal (CVE Pending)

    File: /var/www/html/spoolnews/files.php
    Impact: Complete file system access
    Exploitation: Active attacks documented since May 2024

    Vulnerable Code Pattern:

    // files.php - Critical path traversal
    $getfilename = $spooldir . '/upload/' . $_REQUEST['showfile']; >readfile($getfilename); // NO PATH VALIDATION

    Attack Vector:

    Attacker extracts site key from HTML form
    POST request with malicious showfile parameter
    Can read any system file accessible to web server
    Enables extraction of SSH credentials, database contents,
    configuration files

    Secondary Vulnerability: SQL Injection via Newsgroup Names

    Impact: Database manipulation and file system pollution
    Evidence: Hundreds of malicious database files found
    Attack Method: Injection through NNTP protocol and group name
    processing

    Efo|N+A COMPROMISE INDICATORS

    Check your spool directory for files with suspicious names:

    # Look for files containing SQL injection patterns
    find /var/spool/rslight -name "*CASE WHEN*" -o -name "*SELECT*" -o -name >"*UNION*"
    find /var/spool/rslight -name "*ORDER BY*" -o -name "*CONCAT*" -o -name >"*CHAR(*"

    Example malicious filenames found:

    (CASE WHEN (2018=4830) THEN 'newsgroup' ELSE SELECT...)-data.db3 >comp.lang.python' WHERE 7629=7629 AND 5482=CONCAT...-data.db3 >DOVE-Net.Synchronet_Announcements ORDER BY 3123-- fnTQ-cache.txt

    If you find such files, your system has been compromised.
    ATTACK TIMELINE

    May 2024: First evidence of SQL injection attacks
    May 2024 - June 2025: Continuous automated exploitation
    March 2025: Retro Guy's system was under active attack during his
    final months
    June 2025: Vulnerabilities discovered and documented

    EfA+ DATA AT RISK

    Potentially Compromised Information:

    System/Web configuration files and encryption keys
    All newsgroup content and user messages
    User account databases and authentication data
    SSH credentials and server access
    Email addresses and user metadata
    Any sensitive data accessible to the web server

    EfcaN+A IMMEDIATE REMEDIATION STEPS

    Emergency Shutdown

    # Stop web server and NNTP service immediately
    systemctl stop apache2 nginx

    Evidence Preservation

    # Backup current state for forensic analysis
    tar -czf rocksolid-incident-$(date +%Y%m%d).tar.gz /var/spool/rslight/

    This vulnerability was discovered during a digital preservation effort >following Retro Guy's passing in March 2025.

    The path traversal vulnerability was used to rescue valuable community
    data from the rocksolidbbs.com server.

    ------------------------------------------------------------- >------------------------------------------------------------- >-------------------------------------------------------------


    --
    .......
    Billy G. (go-while)


    Must be rectified!
    --
    Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
    Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
    All I want to hear from JEsus Christ is WEll done Good and Faithful servant
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Kyonshi@gmkeros@gmail.com to news.admin.peering on Sat Jul 26 17:06:29 2025
    From Newsgroup: news.admin.peering

    On 7/22/2025 9:59 AM, Billy G. (go-while) wrote:

    4. Wait for pugleaf.net open source release!

    When is that gonna be actually? I wanted to put a web-frontend on one of
    my little servers and had planned to use rslight, but then the whole
    thing happened.
    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marco Moock@mm@dorfdsl.de to news.admin.peering on Sat Jul 26 17:49:23 2025
    From Newsgroup: news.admin.peering

    On 26.07.2025 17:06 Uhr Kyonshi wrote:

    On 7/22/2025 9:59 AM, Billy G. (go-while) wrote:

    4. Wait for pugleaf.net open source release!

    When is that gonna be actually? I wanted to put a web-frontend on one
    of my little servers and had planned to use rslight, but then the
    whole thing happened.

    Ask him directly, I don't see a public release yet and the software
    itself seems to be not production-ready yet.
    --
    kind regards
    Marco

    Send spam to 1753542389muell@stinkedores.dorfdsl.de

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Billy G. (go-while)@no-reply@no.spam to news.admin.peering,rocksolid.nodes.help,rocksolid.nodes.announce on Sat Jul 26 22:31:49 2025
    From Newsgroup: news.admin.peering

    On 26.07.25 17:49, Marco Moock wrote:
    On 26.07.2025 17:06 Uhr Kyonshi wrote:

    On 7/22/2025 9:59 AM, Billy G. (go-while) wrote:

    4. Wait for pugleaf.net open source release!

    When is that gonna be actually? I wanted to put a web-frontend on one
    of my little servers and had planned to use rslight, but then the
    whole thing happened.

    Ask him directly, I don't see a public release yet and the software
    itself seems to be not production-ready yet.


    no ETA. It's done when it's done!
    still host breaking memory issues hidden in the code
    fetched and processed 800 GB of articles in 48h hours without crashing.
    sucking with 1000-2000 connections :D .. but mem goes up ..

    memory issue is maybe fixed now
    but found breaking bug in history / hashdb and need rebuild all now :D

    who wants, can join: https://discord.gg/rECSbHHFzp
    --
    .......
    Billy G. (go-while)
    https://pugleaf.net
    @Newsgroup: rocksolid.nodes.help

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Soul Patch@soul.patch@127.0.0.1 to news.admin.peering on Mon Aug 4 18:23:11 2025
    From Newsgroup: news.admin.peering

    On Sat, 12 Jul 2025 20:55:07 +0200
    Marco Moock <mm@dorfdsl.de> wrote:

    On 12.07.2025 10:21 Uhr Anonymous wrote:

    Some have claimed that Rocksolid Light is insecure. They have claimed
    that there are many vulnerabilities in the codebase. They have
    claimed that Rocksolid Light should not be used or peered.

    Yet I have not seen a single supposed vulnerability demonstrated.

    I have not seen any CVE filings.

    Can anyone demonstrate and prove any of the claimed exploits?

    It least older versions were vulnerable to SQL injections that made
    creating files in the spool directory possible. The files.php file also
    seems vulnerable to such attacks.

    I wouldn't be so quick to throw away the whole code base upon the claim that bugs can't be remediated. Give me a complete list of all the files where vulnerabilities were found.

    I started programming in PHP back around the time WordPress was first published. So I know enough to fix a lot of things. Given a list of the relevant files I can scan and suss out bugs for analysis. I'm not going to scan the whole source code or try to attack active installs since others already seem to have done this work. Give me the relevant file names and I'll have a look.
    --
    Soul Patch

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2
  • From Marco Moock@mm@dorfdsl.de to news.admin.peering on Tue Aug 5 20:14:36 2025
    From Newsgroup: news.admin.peering

    On 04.08.2025 18:23 Uhr Soul Patch wrote:

    I started programming in PHP back around the time WordPress was first published. So I know enough to fix a lot of things. Given a list of
    the relevant files I can scan and suss out bugs for analysis. I'm not
    going to scan the whole source code or try to attack active installs
    since others already seem to have done this work. Give me the
    relevant file names and I'll have a look.

    - **File**: `/var/www/html/spoolnews/files.php`
    #### Secondary Vulnerability: SQL Injection via Newsgroup Names

    IIRC there was also a document published on github that provided more
    details.
    --
    kind regards
    Marco

    Send spam to 1754324591muell@stinkedores.dorfdsl.de

    --- Synchronet 3.21a-Linux NewsLink 1.2