XPost: rec.arts.startrek.misc, rec.arts.startrek.fandom, rec.arts.tv
XPost: can.arts.sf
AI/LLM reviews of Review Star Trek - Bem based
on
http://www.chakoteya.net/StarTrek/TAS018.htm
Google Gemini
"Bem" is an episode of Star Trek: The Animated Series
that explores themes of cultural observation,
interference, and the responsibilities that come
with interacting with developing civilizations.
Strengths:
Intriguing Premise: The concept of an alien
observer studying another culture,
and the ethical dilemmas that arise from this observation,
is a classic Star Trek theme that provides a strong
foundation for the story.
Exploration of Cultural Relativism: The episode touches
on the complexities of understanding and respecting cultures
with different values and levels of development.
Character Focus: The episode centers on the character of Bem,
providing insight into his motivations and his ultimate
realisation about the importance of non-interference.
Unique Alien Culture: The episode introduces a new alien
culture and explores their relationship with a powerful
entity that guides their development.
Weaknesses:
Simplistic Plot: The plot is relatively straightforward,
with Bem interfering, Kirk and Spock being captured,
and the crew learning a lesson about non-interference.
Dated Animation: As with other episodes from
the animated series, the animation quality is dated
and may not appeal to modern viewers.
Questionable Decisions: Some of Bem's actions
and decisions may seem illogical or poorly motivated.
Convenient Resolution: The resolution, with Kirk deciding
to quarantine the planet, feels somewhat abrupt.
Overall Impression:"Bem" is a thought-provoking episode
that explores important Star Trek themes about cultural
observation and the ethics of interference. While
the plot is simplistic and the animation is dated,
the episode offers a unique perspective on these
issues and provides a memorable alien character.
Rating: 7/10
ChatGPT
**Review: *Star Trek: The Animated Series* – "Bem"**
**Rating: ★★★☆☆ (6/10)**
"Bem," the second episode of the second season
of *Star Trek: The Animated Series*, originally
aired on September 14, 1974. Written by David Gerrold,
known for his work on "The Trouble with Tribbles,"
this episode introduces Commander Ari bn Bem,
an observer from the planet Pandro, who joins
the Enterprise crew on a mission to Delta Theta III.([Wikipedia][1])
---
### **Plot Overview**
Commander Ari bn Bem, representing the advanced Pandronian species,
is aboard the USS Enterprise to evaluate the Federation's suitability
for diplomatic relations. During a mission to Delta Theta III,
Bem insists on joining the landing party. However, his unconventional
behaviour - such as secretly replacing the crew's weapons
with non-functional replicas and referring to himself
in the third person - complicates the mission. Bem's actions
lead to the capture of the landing party by the planet's
primitive inhabitants. The situation escalates when a powerful
non-corporeal entity, acting as a guardian of the natives,
intervenes, challenging the crew's presence and intentions.
Ultimately, through communication and understanding,
the crew resolves the conflict, and Bem acknowledges
his misjudgments. ([Cygnus-X1][2], [Wikipedia][1])
---
### **Strengths**
* **Exploration of Cultural Differences**: The episode delves
into the complexities of cross-cult