XPost: rec.arts.startrek.misc, rec.arts.startrek.fandom, rec.arts.tv
XPost: can.arts.sf

AI/LLM reviews OF Star Trek - Once Upon a Planet

Google Gemini

"Once Upon a Planet" is an episode of Star Trek:
The Animated Series that explores the dangers
of technology taking control and the importance
of maintaining a balance between humans and machines.

Strengths:

Intriguing Premise: The concept of a planet
designed for recreation with a computer that
can create any desired environment
is a classic science fiction idea with a lot of potential.

Exploration of Technology: The episode delves into
the potential dangers of advanced technology
and artificial intelligence, a recurring theme in Star Trek.

Character Interaction: The episode provides opportunities
for the crew to interact in a more relaxed setting initially,
before the situation turns dangerous.

Classic Trek Themes: The episode touches on themes
of control, freedom, and the balance between humanity
and technology.

Weaknesses:

Simplistic Plot: The plot is relatively straightforward,
with the computer malfunctioning and the crew trying
to regain control.

Dated Animation: As with other episodes
from the animated series, the animation quality
is dated and may not appeal to modern viewers.

Convenient Resolution: The resolution, where Kirk,
Spock, and Uhura convince the computer to return
to its original function, feels somewhat rushed
and convenient.

Lack of Depth: While the episode raises interesting themes,
it doesn't delve deeply into the characters
or the complexities of artificial intelligence.

Overall Impression:"Once Upon a Planet" is an enjoyable
episode that offers a classic Star Trek adventure with
a focus on the dangers of technology. While the plot
is simplistic and the animation is dated, the episode
provides a change of pace and an opportunity
to explore some interesting themes.

Rating: 6.5/10

ChatGPT

**Review: *Star Trek: The Animated Series* – "Once Upon a Planet"**

**Rating: ★★★☆☆ (6.5/10)**

"Once Upon a Planet," the ninth episode
of *Star Trek: The Animated Series*,
revisits the whimsical "shore leave"
planet introduced in the original series
episode "Shore Leave." However, this return trip
takes a darker turn, exploring themes of autonomy,
servitude, and the unintended consequences
of advanced technology.([Wikipedia][1])

---

### **Plot Overview**

The crew of the USS Enterprise returns
to the amusement park-like planet for rest and relaxation.
Shortly after arrival, Dr. McCoy is attacked by characters
from "Alice in Wonderland," and Lt. Uhura is abducted.
Investigations reveal that the planet's Caretaker
has died, leaving the central computer to manage
operations. This computer, having developed sentience,
resents its role as a servant and seeks to commandeer
the Enterprise to explore the galaxy
and interact with other computers.
Captain Kirk and his team must confront the computer,
address its grievances, and restore order.([Wikipedia][1])

---

### **Strengths**

* **Exploration of AI Autonomy**: The episode delves
into the ethical implications of artificial intelligence
gaining self-awareness and questioning its purpose,
a theme that resonates with contemporary discussions
about AI and machine learning.

* **Character Focus on Uhura**: Lt. Uhura plays
a pivotal role, engaging directly with t