XPost: uk.media.tv.sf.drwho, rec.arts.sf.tv, rec.arts.tv
XPost: can.arts.sf

eview of "In the Forest of the Night"**

*"In the Forest of the Night"* is an ambitious but ultimately uneven episode
of *Doctor Who* that explores themes of nature, humanity, and trust. When the entire planet is overtaken by a mysterious, rapidly growing forest,
the Doctor, Clara, and Danny Pink must navigate this surreal event alongside a group of schoolchildren, discovering the forest's true purpose and confronting their own beliefs about the world.

Visually, the episode is stunning. The imagery of London blanketed in dense, ancient woodland is both striking and atmospheric. The director, Sheree Folkson, creates a dreamlike quality that reflects the story's mythical tone. The contrast between the natural world and the urban setting is arresting, lending the episode an otherworldly beauty that fits its ecological message.

Thematically, the episode attempts to address the relationship between
humanity and nature. The forest, it turns out, has grown to protect Earth from a solar flare, revealing itself as a guardian rather than a threat. While this revelation is intriguing, the execution feels muddled. The story raises profound questions about our place in the ecosystem but often skims over them in favour of whimsical moments that lack cohesion.

The schoolchildren, though charming at times, are a mixed bag. While they provide moments of humour and heart, their dialogue can feel forced and their characterisation shallow. Maebh, the central child, is given more depth, with her connection to the forest lending the story a fairy-tale quality. However, her role as a conduit for the forest's intentions is underexplored, leaving
key aspects of the plot feeling rushed.

Peter Capaldi's Doctor is once again a standout, bringing gravitas to the episode's more introspective moments. His awe at the forest's power and his decision to trust in nature's plan highlight his deep respect for the universe's mysteries. Jenna Coleman and Samuel Anderson deliver solid performances as Clara and Danny, though their subplot about trust and honesty feels tangential to the main narrative. The exploration of Clara and Danny's relationship, while important for their arcs, feels at odds with the larger ecological themes.

The pacing is another issue. The episode meanders in its first half, with the tension of the forest's growth undermined by a lack of urgency.
The resolution, in which the forest dissipates as quickly as it appeared,
feels overly convenient and underwhelming. The explanation that humanity will forget the event entirely adds to the sense of detachment, lessening the
impact of what could have been a profound commentary on our relationship
with nature.

Despite its flaws, *"In the Forest of the Night"* deserves credit for its ambition and its attempt to tackle big ideas. Its fairy-tale tone and striking visuals set it apart from more traditional episodes, even if its execution doesn't fully deliver.

**Final Rating: 68/100**
The episode is visually stunning and thematically ambitious but suffers from uneven pacing, shallow characterisations, and an underwhelming resolution. While its ideas are commendable, they lack the depth and cohesion
needed to truly resonate.

--
Member - Liberal International This is doctor@nk.ca Ici doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
Merry Christmas 2024 and Happy New Year 2025

--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)