XPost: uk.media.tv.sf.drwho, rec.arts.sf.tv, rec.arts.tv
XPost: can.arts.sf
**"Doctor Who: The Waters of Mars" - Review**
In *"The Waters of Mars,"* the Doctor (David
Tennant) arrives on Mars in 2059, where he
faces a fixed point in time. He meets the crew
of Bowie Base One, who are unknowingly doomed
to perish. The episode blends tension, horror,
and ethical dilemmas.
**Plot Summary:**
The Doctor lands on Mars and encounters the
crew of Bowie Base One, led by Captain Adelaide
Brooke. Soon, the crew discovers that the base's
water supply is infected with an alien virus
that transforms people into deadly creatures
called the Flood. The Doctor realizes that
this is a fixed point in time—Adelaide and
her crew are destined to die, and their
sacrifice is essential for the future of
human space exploration.
Struggling with the ethics of letting people
die, the Doctor ultimately defies the laws
of time and saves Adelaide and two other
crew members. However, Adelaide takes her
own life to preserve history, leaving the
Doctor shaken and filled with regret. He
realizes the danger of his newfound arrogance
in trying to alter time.
**Themes and Character Development:**
1. **Time and Destiny:** The episode explores
the conflict between the Doctor’s power
and the immutable rules of time.
2. **Hubris and Arrogance:** The Doctor’s
decision to change history reflects his
growing hubris, showing how dangerous
his power can become.
3. **Sacrifice:** Adelaide’s suicide to
restore the timeline adds emotional
weight and highlights the cost of
altering destiny.
**Strengths:**
- **Tense Atmosphere:** The episode builds
tension with the creeping horror of the
Flood and the looming threat of the fixed
timeline.
- **Moral Dilemma:** The Doctor’s internal
conflict about changing a fixed point in
time adds depth and raises ethical
questions.
- **Emotional Impact:** Adelaide’s sacrifice
and the Doctor’s guilt create a poignant,
emotionally charged conclusion.
**Weaknesses:**
- **Pacing:** The episode's tension is
effective, but some viewers might find
the slower moments dragging.
- **Limited Exploration of the Flood:**
The Flood is a chilling enemy, but its
origins and nature remain underexplored.
**Conclusion:**
"The Waters of Mars" is a tense, emotional
episode that explores the Doctor's power,
arrogance, and the limits of time travel.
Its moral dilemmas and tragic ending make
it one of the most impactful specials.
**Rating: 9/10**
Tense, emotional, and thought-provoking,
with only minor pacing issues.
--
Member - Liberal International This is
doctor@nk.ca Ici
doctor@nk.ca
Yahweh, King & country!Never Satan President Republic!Beware AntiChrist rising! Look at Psalms 14 and 53 on Atheism ;
--- SoupGate-Win32 v1.05
* Origin: fsxNet Usenet Gateway (21:1/5)